Thanks for the replies so far. I have used all 3 over the first 4 games to some degree, and have gone 2-2. I moved my team into the Big 10 to increase the difficulty and where I normally win 11-12 games a year this has been a lot more interesting.
It seems like Ricks is a little more reliable right now, especially on the road. Walker sometimes can't see all the pre-snap routes since he's a true freshman, and it takes him a couple of series to get warmed up accuracy-wise. Love the realism the slider set provides!
I hate being spellbound to the pocket with a slow guy, but I think that may be the right call until Walker gets a little more experience. Appreciate yall helping me sort through it.