Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

[the onizzle]

I have 3 QB's on my rebuilding dynasty with Miami OH. None of them are exceptional but they all have potential. Need help figuring which one to stick with longterm. I play on Heisman with jkit's slider set, so a QB with a rag arm gets exposed. Also, my top rated QB is a Sophomore. The other 2 are Freshmen. Sometimes I'll go with the younger guy with more longterm potential when all other things are equal but I don't see that as much of a factor here.

See the attachment and appreciate the feedback!

[OHNOESNCAA14]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

I would go with Ricks, considering he's got better accuracy and you're using Jkit. But it's a tough decision if you want a mobile QB.

[LucianoJJ]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

Start Ricks since he is the better player, but consider redshirting your true freshman.

[Darianj22]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

personally, russell walker has the most potential. the game will progress him like a balanced QB so by his junior year he’ll be a high 70s speed elusive qb with mid 90 thp and mid to high 80 throw accuracy.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[the onizzle]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

personally, russell walker has the most potential. the game will progress him like a balanced QB so by his junior year he’ll be a high 70s speed elusive qb with mid 90 thp and mid to high 80 throw accuracy.

Thanks for the replies so far. I have used all 3 over the first 4 games to some degree, and have gone 2-2. I moved my team into the Big 10 to increase the difficulty and where I normally win 11-12 games a year this has been a lot more interesting.

It seems like Ricks is a little more reliable right now, especially on the road. Walker sometimes can't see all the pre-snap routes since he's a true freshman, and it takes him a couple of series to get warmed up accuracy-wise. Love the realism the slider set provides!

I hate being spellbound to the pocket with a slow guy, but I think that may be the right call until Walker gets a little more experience. Appreciate yall helping me sort through it.

[lung55555]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

Use Eddie Moon

[Rondo is GOD]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

I personally will roll with the awareness rating unless the freshies accuracy/athleticism is too good to pass up

[TarHeelPhenom]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

Tiebreaker always goes to the True Freshman in my book. Give him the keys and roll with him.

[the onizzle]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

Tiebreaker always goes to the True Freshman in my book. Give him the keys and roll with him.

Why is that buddy? My preference is always for a guy with a little bit of mobility over a statue QB. Ricks (sophomore) can roll out if needed, but doesn't have the speed to scramble for a gain. Walker (true fresh) can do both. Ricks has been more accurate from the start of the game, whereas it takes Walker a couple of series to get established. Using the jkit slider, in the early game he'll sometimes miss open throws on like a slant when he's standing still in the pocket.

In theory they should pickup the same amount of AWR during the season. I can't remember if THP / THA improve mid season, it's probably marginal if so. You seem like you've played quite a bit so love to hear your reasoning.

[TarHeelPhenom]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

Why is that buddy? My preference is always for a guy with a little bit of mobility over a statue QB. Ricks (sophomore) can roll out if needed, but doesn't have the speed to scramble for a gain. Walker (true fresh) can do both. Ricks has been more accurate from the start of the game, whereas it takes Walker a couple of series to get established. Using the jkit slider, in the early game he'll sometimes miss open throws on like a slant when he's standing still in the pocket.

In theory they should pickup the same amount of AWR during the season. I can't remember if THP / THA improve mid season, it's probably marginal if so. You seem like you've played quite a bit so love to hear your reasoning.

That's just the rule I go by in situations like that. I throw em into the fire lol.

[Rondo is GOD]

Re: Need help, which one of these 3 QBs would you start?

That's just the rule I go by in situations like that. I throw em into the fire lol.

I tend to do the same thing, but for every other position besides QB. Get those career records, gangsta