I think there are a lot of factors here at work. For example: you could be playing on a crummy tv with terrible input lag. Fast pitching could seem impossible. But to those of us on good equipment, the same speed could feel quite reasonable, or even easy.
I once played this game at a friend's house on a projector. He had pitch speeds lowered and I still found it near impossible to time the pitch. I asked him how he managed and he just shrugged his shoulders and said "I just do."
Sent from my Pixel 3 using
Operation Sports mobile app