I've been burned in two separate games where a QB throws a hail mary pass to a player who is sitting, waiting for the ball to arrive and a defender standing there with him waiting for it. Both times, I went to interact with the ball and instead they did nothing while the receiver caught it without disruption. What am I doing wrong on these plays? I wait until it's nearing arrival to press/hold Triangle and when that did not work I opted for pressing/holding Square right as the ball was arriving. As both videos show, neither did anything.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zhr6H2YWkM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M5qUsTCxEIs