This is an indy title and was never going to truly "compete" with EA Sports. It lacks the funding, branding and promotional reach to ever make up that gargantuan difference.
The fact that it provides a collegiate option is good, but gameplay was/is how the game should've been marketed and developed for. The former developer spent too much time on that aspect while nearly neglecting every other portion of the game. And it showed with the games near glacial progress from year - to - year, IMO.
As long as they have appropriate expectations, a reasonable budget (which they are optimizing by outsourcing development to overseas developers) and make real strides - something the old Maximum wasn't doing enough of - they can find a solid, cult following for themselves.
Official HQ of Bills Backer/Spurs Nation