EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mudtiger
    MVP
    • Jul 2002
    • 3223

    #1

    EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

    Just sharing some findings for anyone in a similar situation to me - loving the game but increasingly finding it becoming too easy as I skilled up my character in the first season and added better club unlocks.

    I'm playing on something of a modified SIM setting with a decent number of
    skill points assigned and most shot types unlocked. I was finding I had to increase the score slider to 100 to help the AI compete. I didn't like that the scores then became in my opinion on the unrealistic side. I play all 4 rounds and I wasn't winning them all, but after 15 events, I had the most wins by 1 and the most top 10 finishes and was 1st in fedex ranking. So I went to the drawing board to up the difficulty.

    Goals - have to deal with missing the fairways some times. Be forced to get creative and attempt difficult shots. Make the rough actually mean something, ie I'm tired of being in the sand or heavy rough and having a 90+% ball lie with a hybrid. Still be able to compete, but not dominate.


    Now the two conclusions I've come to.

    Do not use equipment upgrades. No ball upgrade, no driver/iron/hybrid/etc upgrades. None. You do not need them.

    Next, limit your use of skill points. Yes, the majority of your skill points will go unused.

    For Power and driving, you can only assign 4 total points to the group as a whole. So for example, 1 to power and then 2 to accuracy and 1 to control for 4 total between power and driving.

    For Approach, you can only assign 5 total between the 3 skills.

    For Short game and Putting you can only assign 8 skill points to the group. This one is higher mainly because I feel like the texas wedge in putting shouldn't be locked behind an upgrade skill. So there are enough points there to get T wedge and still have some short game.

    What does this do to you? Your accuracy in driving is low so you will miss the fairways now. You are going to be forced to be creative from outside the fairway. Sometimes you are going to have to lay up or make the safe shot instead of attacking the green 100% of the time. Your recovery skill is low so bad lies actually mean something. I hit the bunker and if I try to use a hybrid I see lies of 30% or less now. I have to go to a wedge or possibly iron if I want a controllable shot out of bad lies. Bye bye distance out of the bunker.

    BUT WHAT ABOUT MY SPINNER SHOT????!!! or whatever your favorite shot is? You will be fine without it. Get your texas wedge and finesse shot as you'll have enough points for those and those are almost essential, but the rest you don't really need.

    3 bits of advice are

    learn to pitch consistently - full loft and aim about 4 to 6 yards short and hit the shot at about 75%... depending on elevation, lie, etc.

    Learn to chip - full loft and aim about half the distance to the cup and backswing to 35-50% depending on elevation.

    For a short blast out of the sand, aim around 4-5 yards short at full height and aim for 100% power. Adjust for height, ball lie, and green contours.

    I might lower or raise a few of the max allowable skills per group once I get through a full season if something ends up being too easy or hard, but so far I'm happy. I also might decrease the allowable skill points for the 1st year on the tour to allow for another 1 or 2 points in each group in between seasons so you can increase a little bit and feel like you've gotten better.

    Last, some basic info on settings I use if that helps any....
    Swing stick - hard

    Putting stick - normal or hard depending on how good you are at putting. I struggle finding the read so I go with normal. I don't need to fight a bad read and missing on the stick putting....yet.

    Zoom cam - off. Just do it, you'll get used to it and it adds an element of realism and the unknown. Check the hole layout often and change the angle on your tee shot up more to see a little more.

    Wind - only direction. Pay attention to the wind speed range given going into the round.

    Elevation - either full or just direction only depending on how good you are putting. I find it too hard to determine elevation in putting so I use full info for elevation. The elevation putting grid in the lower right doesn't seem to have a set scale, so I need that info still.

    Putt grids on, beads on, no caddy line. If I can get better at reading elevation on the greens (EA Give us a putting cam lower to the ground PLEASE), I'll turn off the beads and set elevation to direction only....but that may never happen.
  • DarthRambo
    MVP
    • Mar 2008
    • 6630

    #2
    Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

    Sadly I kind of figured this was going to happen. Hopefully they patch the game to make it way more difficult. The lies in the rough and sand at 95% or more is broken. Just has to be.

    I'm not that great at the game, but already sense I will be winning about everything once M y character is leveled up. Especially after playing 18 holes with DJ and how easy it was to control spin with little effort.

    I hate having to handicap myself though so idk if I want to. I think the big thing not to do is use specs. Those just look like arcade game stuff in the store and really silly. 2k balances your stats way better by using clubs, shafts, etc. To buy some bogus spec that magically increases your stats is very cheap and feels like the easy way out for EA. It's like they felt they had to be different than 2k here. But if it works why not copy it?? Definitely the worst part of the game IMO

    Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
    Last edited by DarthRambo; 04-27-2023, 06:47 PM.
    https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

    Comment

    • DarthRambo
      MVP
      • Mar 2008
      • 6630

      #3
      Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

      Hopefully they patch the game to make lies in the rough and sand not always 90% or higher. I've been in heavy rough and it shows 95-97% which is crazy. No penalty for missing the fairways or greens.

      Definitely no need to use skill points in approach recovery at this time. Short game recovery yes because those shot types are one you do need and are good.

      Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
      https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

      Comment

      • mrsaito
        Pro
        • Nov 2009
        • 743

        #4
        Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

        What's odd about rough lies is that it seems to vary by course. At Bay Hill (Korn Ferry Tour Q School) the rough lies can be as low as 20% for a three wood, although they get better as you progress through the higher lofted clubs as they should.

        I would say that for this particular course the rough lies play exactly as they should.

        Comment

        • voodoo_magic
          On the 15 day DL-blister
          • Mar 2005
          • 726

          #5
          Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

          For the heavy rough shots that the game is allowing me to use a 3 wood or 3 iron and nearly no penalty I'm thinking I need to override it and play the more realistic lay up or punch shot. At least until there's a patch we don't HAVE TO play a shot we know is wrong.

          Shots from the light rough or even from the sand we could limit our use of loft and any of the special shot types to make the shot more difficult, or even just limit their use to a couple times a round to add strategy for when to use it.
          Or you could use 1 club longer than you need from the light rough and force yourself to hit a partial shot and a much tougher shot than at default.

          Comment

          • DarthRambo
            MVP
            • Mar 2008
            • 6630

            #6
            Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

            Originally posted by voodoo_magic
            For the heavy rough shots that the game is allowing me to use a 3 wood or 3 iron and nearly no penalty I'm thinking I need to override it and play the more realistic lay up or punch shot. At least until there's a patch we don't HAVE TO play a shot we know is wrong.



            Shots from the light rough or even from the sand we could limit our use of loft and any of the special shot types to make the shot more difficult, or even just limit their use to a couple times a round to add strategy for when to use it.

            Or you could use 1 club longer than you need from the light rough and force yourself to hit a partial shot and a much tougher shot than at default.
            So would you limit or not use the pick shot and always use the blast, which is way harder?

            I'm not a real life golf guru so in the rough, what clubs would be realistic to have to use? What shot type on the game and clubs would be realistic? I assume this will be patch soon though. Honestly it better be, because it takes away a huge part of the strategy of playing simulation golf.

            Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
            https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

            Comment

            • woody2goody
              MVP
              • Mar 2009
              • 2097

              #7
              Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

              I've stopped using the Pick and Hack altogether. Game is a lot more fun without them. Never use the spinner anyway so that's not an issue.
              Supporting Leeds United, Colorado Rockies, Detroit Lions and the Colorado Avalanche!

              Now Playing FIFA, UFC 4, PGA Tour 2k23, WWE, MLB The Show and Dirt Rally 2.0

              Comment

              • mudtiger
                MVP
                • Jul 2002
                • 3223

                #8
                Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                I lowered the skills by another 1 in approach group and 1 in short game for a new character, I still feel like I do a little too well. I'm only 3 tournaments in on the PGA tour after dominating my amateur event and getting cut at the masters though, so hopefully too early to draw any conclusions.

                It is closer to what I want though. Almost too many drives off the fairway where I'm somewhere in the low 70%s for FIR so far. Recovery from bad lies has been too easy though. So I might add 1 to drive accuracy and reduce recovery in approach and short game.

                AI at 50 still seems to be the way to get results at courses that match the last few years. It could probably go up a little over 50, but when you really push it to 90 or more, it gets out of hand. Which I can see why they need that though. If you spec out your equipment and add max skills, you unstoppable.

                Comment

                • DarthRambo
                  MVP
                  • Mar 2008
                  • 6630

                  #9
                  Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                  Originally posted by mudtiger

                  AI at 50 still seems to be the way to get results at courses that match the last few years. It could probably go up a little over 50, but when you really push it to 90 or more, it gets out of hand. Which I can see why they need that though. If you spec out your equipment and add max skills, you unstoppable.
                  This is my thought as well. 50 seems best for realistic scores. I suppose I can buy specs for online play only if I ever do that. Thr game at least allows you to take off specs easily.

                  So are you running with zero specs? Could you share a picture of your skill tree? I want the gane to be realistically hard, and I think we can certainly find that. I have yet to put anything on putting but I do want the Texas wedge so I will be.

                  I plan to now get rid of skills for pick shot and spinner shot. I think flops are okay to use though. And obviously pitch and chip shots are okay.

                  Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
                  https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

                  Comment

                  • DarthRambo
                    MVP
                    • Mar 2008
                    • 6630

                    #10
                    Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                    So I regressed back to 3 for short game control. No pick or spinner shots now. I do have gold long and high flops. Bronze runner which is difficult anyway and no different than normal pitch shot to me.

                    For approach I only have gold finesse, knock down.


                    For driving, I only have bronze power drive and approach. I have no idea if stinger shot is overpowered or not, but I see no point in getting driving control anyway.

                    Do you think going for silver or even gold power drive is too much? I'm thinking it could be honestly, but I'm gonna have so many leftover skill points I never use, lol.

                    This is what I'm coming up with as of now. I think the max 3 for short game control will increase difficulty a ton. I left driving accuracy at 5 for now just in case I feel silver power drive is OK to use. But thinking driving accuracy at 0 or 1 would be best to get realistic FIR%.

                    What do you guys think?

                    Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
                    https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

                    Comment

                    • mudtiger
                      MVP
                      • Jul 2002
                      • 3223

                      #11
                      Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                      I refined my approach some. Starting out as a rookie I'm going with

                      Rookie - total points that can be applied
                      Power and driving
                      1... So pick one of the sub groups in power or driving to add a single point. I would suggest accuracy in driving.

                      Approach
                      1 if you want to be brutal, 2 if a little less so.

                      Short game and putting
                      4... Again this is 4 so you can get the Texas wedge.


                      This really made me struggle. I'd have some good rounds and then really bad. Missed the cut on the masters. Mssed an invite to the pga and just snuck into Korn ferry. Really felt like an amateur playing with big boys.

                      No adding points until you get into next Korn ferry season

                      +1 in each group above going into Korn tour.if somehow you go to pga, add 2 points per grouping above.

                      At the end of he season you can add 1 point to each group whether you're in KF or pga.

                      Comment

                      • SituationSoap
                        Rookie
                        • Jul 2017
                        • 37

                        #12
                        Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                        Really curious how many people here are playing with 3-click swing on. In my experience, with that on hard, it's much, much harder to consistently be accurate, as even tiny misses outside the optimal window are pretty punished.

                        With 3-click on, and a golfer that's at 92 overall, I've had 4-round tournaments that ranged between -8 and -20. That's still too good, I should have tournaments where I'm even par, even at that level. But if I use the swing stick, I'll basically be hitting every fairway and every green without fail, unless the winds are cranked super high. With 3-click, that's not true.

                        Comment

                        • mudtiger
                          MVP
                          • Jul 2002
                          • 3223

                          #13
                          Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                          Skills for rookie on Korn Ferry Tour.... First round of 1st event, I finished at par. Leader was at -5 or -6. I had 3 birdies and a bogey and double bogey. Double bogey was avoidable so I could have been under. Liking this.....

                          Power
                          Power - 1

                          Driving
                          Accuracy - 1
                          Control - 0

                          Approach
                          Accuracy - 1
                          Control - 1
                          Recovery - 0

                          Short
                          Accuracy - 1
                          Control - 1
                          Recovery - 0

                          Putting
                          Putt - 3

                          I'm trying to figure out how to add additional points and at what point once I hit the PGA tour. I'm thinking if I skip an event, I can add a single skill point. Took the week off to practice with my caddy on a specific skill. This gives me a reason not to play every event on the tour.

                          I'm thinking on the korn ferry, I can only add skill points at the end of the season....a single point to power or one of the driving skills, 1 point to approach, and 1 point to short or putting. So I can add 3 points total at the end of korn ferry.

                          At some point I hit the max on allowed skill points as defined in the first post (or slightly adjusted from that post) and that is it.

                          Comment

                          • DarthRambo
                            MVP
                            • Mar 2008
                            • 6630

                            #14
                            Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                            Originally posted by mudtiger
                            Skills for rookie on Korn Ferry Tour.... First round of 1st event, I finished at par. Leader was at -5 or -6. I had 3 birdies and a bogey and double bogey. Double bogey was avoidable so I could have been under. Liking this.....



                            Power

                            Power - 1



                            Driving

                            Accuracy - 1

                            Control - 0



                            Approach

                            Accuracy - 1

                            Control - 1

                            Recovery - 0



                            Short

                            Accuracy - 1

                            Control - 1

                            Recovery - 0



                            Putting

                            Putt - 3



                            I'm trying to figure out how to add additional points and at what point once I hit the PGA tour. I'm thinking if I skip an event, I can add a single skill point. Took the week off to practice with my caddy on a specific skill. This gives me a reason not to play every event on the tour.



                            I'm thinking on the korn ferry, I can only add skill points at the end of the season....a single point to power or one of the driving skills, 1 point to approach, and 1 point to short or putting. So I can add 3 points total at the end of korn ferry.



                            At some point I hit the max on allowed skill points as defined in the first post (or slightly adjusted from that post) and that is it.
                            What are max levels you want to go for each attribute? I created a new guy to start over on the skill tree. Played two rounds at Bandon dunes. First round I was even par. Second round I shot -4. Feels pretty fair to me. Course is extremely easy regardless of what you do.

                            I like your idea, but mainly just want to figure out a max level for each attribute. I can't tell which one makes you overpowered.

                            Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
                            https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

                            Comment

                            • DarthRambo
                              MVP
                              • Mar 2008
                              • 6630

                              #15
                              Re: EA PGA Tour 23 Searching for difficulty

                              Originally posted by SituationSoap
                              Really curious how many people here are playing with 3-click swing on. In my experience, with that on hard, it's much, much harder to consistently be accurate, as even tiny misses outside the optimal window are pretty punished.



                              With 3-click on, and a golfer that's at 92 overall, I've had 4-round tournaments that ranged between -8 and -20. That's still too good, I should have tournaments where I'm even par, even at that level. But if I use the swing stick, I'll basically be hitting every fairway and every green without fail, unless the winds are cranked super high. With 3-click, that's not true.
                              I use 3 click. I definitely feel like I mess up quite a bit with it. And I have it on normal difficulty for swings lol. I do have it set to hard for putting. Feels really good to me. I would agree with your assessment though. Every time I watch someone online play using the sticks their swing plane is always straight.

                              The only thing I see is slight over and under swings, which could be done on purpose. And like slow or fast backswings, which I have no idea if that effects anything. I never see the slight miss left or right that I do all the time using 3 click.

                              Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
                              https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

                              Comment

                              Working...