Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Iteachpercussion
    MVP
    • Jul 2012
    • 1816

    #1

    Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

    Alright folks, with all of the Madden 24 hype getting starting, I thought it was a good time to start thinking about what classic roster I would do for M24.

    Most of you know my rosters and what to expect out them, I have been making them and sharing with them the community since the option has been available.

    For M23 I created 1987. It was an odd year where I only made 1 roster. The only other thing I did was rerate Soundwave's 1995 roster (all credit to Soundwave for creating the roster).

    So, I have a ton of different ideas for seasons, but I wanted to know the community's thoughts as well.

    Here are some years I have been thinking about.
    1975- I did this roster several years back, but it is a fun year and the WFL was alive so that provides an easy way to fill out the teams that did not exist in 1975.

    1984- I have never done 84, but what a great year. Marino's amazing season and the big match up with the 49ers in the Super Bowl. The Bears were on the verge of greatness as well. Also, the USFL existed which again makes the other teams easy to handle.

    1993- A fun year with lots of greats in the NFL. Elway, Marino, Young, Montana, Emmitt Smith, Barry Sanders, Jerry Rice... the list goes on.

    2002- Not a truly epic season for me, but fun to build with. Still, a lot of great players and the Browns made the playoffs. Dominant Buccaneers defense.

    2007- The almost perfect season by the Patriots, a close playoff race in the AFC.

    Other seasons I am considering:
    1978- The Steelers were still super tough and the Super Bowl against the Cowboys was epic. Earl Campbell was running over defenses. Staubach, Bradshaw, Tarkenton, Fouts, Franco Harris...

    1985- A season that I love because of the Bears that year. That defense was just soooo good! It is the start of the Kosar era in Cleveland, who came close to upsetting the Dolphins in the playoffs.

    1988- An epic Super Bowl; 49ers and Bengals, Tom Landry's last year as the Cowboys coach, Thurman Thomas' rookie season

    1999- The Browns are back. I see 99 as a transition year for several teams in the NFL. It was Steve Young's final season, Peyton Manning was quickly becoming amazing, and who can forget the Greatest Show on Turf!


    As you can see, there are so many great seasons and I have made rosters for many of them in the past.

    So, throw out your ideas or let me know if you like any of the years I mentioned. At this point I simply do not know what year I will go with, just looking for feedback and ideas.

    Also, if you have any questions about my rosters, how I make them, ratings, etc... feel free to ask
  • iceman43
    Rookie
    • Jun 2003
    • 261

    #2
    Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

    Originally posted by Iteachpercussion
    Alright folks, with all of the Madden 24 hype getting starting, I thought it was a good time to start thinking about what classic roster I would do for M24.



    Most of you know my rosters and what to expect out them, I have been making them and sharing with them the community since the option has been available.



    For M23 I created 1987. It was an odd year where I only made 1 roster. The only other thing I did was rerate Soundwave's 1995 roster (all credit to Soundwave for creating the roster).



    So, I have a ton of different ideas for seasons, but I wanted to know the community's thoughts as well.



    Here are some years I have been thinking about.

    1975- I did this roster several years back, but it is a fun year and the WFL was alive so that provides an easy way to fill out the teams that did not exist in 1975.



    1984- I have never done 84, but what a great year. Marino's amazing season and the big match up with the 49ers in the Super Bowl. The Bears were on the verge of greatness as well. Also, the USFL existed which again makes the other teams easy to handle.



    1993- A fun year with lots of greats in the NFL. Elway, Marino, Young, Montana, Emmitt Smith, Barry Sanders, Jerry Rice... the list goes on.



    2002- Not a truly epic season for me, but fun to build with. Still, a lot of great players and the Browns made the playoffs. Dominant Buccaneers defense.



    2007- The almost perfect season by the Patriots, a close playoff race in the AFC.



    Other seasons I am considering:

    1978- The Steelers were still super tough and the Super Bowl against the Cowboys was epic. Earl Campbell was running over defenses. Staubach, Bradshaw, Tarkenton, Fouts, Franco Harris...



    1985- A season that I love because of the Bears that year. That defense was just soooo good! It is the start of the Kosar era in Cleveland, who came close to upsetting the Dolphins in the playoffs.



    1988- An epic Super Bowl; 49ers and Bengals, Tom Landry's last year as the Cowboys coach, Thurman Thomas' rookie season



    1999- The Browns are back. I see 99 as a transition year for several teams in the NFL. It was Steve Young's final season, Peyton Manning was quickly becoming amazing, and who can forget the Greatest Show on Turf!





    As you can see, there are so many great seasons and I have made rosters for many of them in the past.



    So, throw out your ideas or let me know if you like any of the years I mentioned. At this point I simply do not know what year I will go with, just looking for feedback and ideas.



    Also, if you have any questions about my rosters, how I make them, ratings, etc... feel free to ask
    You gotta do 2000 Ravens

    Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

    Comment

    • tommycoa
      MVP
      • Nov 2008
      • 4982

      #3
      Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

      Originally posted by Iteachpercussion
      Alright folks, with all of the Madden 24 hype getting starting, I thought it was a good time to start thinking about what classic roster I would do for M24.

      Most of you know my rosters and what to expect out them, I have been making them and sharing with them the community since the option has been available.

      For M23 I created 1987. It was an odd year where I only made 1 roster. The only other thing I did was rerate Soundwave's 1995 roster (all credit to Soundwave for creating the roster).

      So, I have a ton of different ideas for seasons, but I wanted to know the community's thoughts as well.

      Here are some years I have been thinking about.
      1975- I did this roster several years back, but it is a fun year and the WFL was alive so that provides an easy way to fill out the teams that did not exist in 1975.

      1984- I have never done 84, but what a great year. Marino's amazing season and the big match up with the 49ers in the Super Bowl. The Bears were on the verge of greatness as well. Also, the USFL existed which again makes the other teams easy to handle.

      1993- A fun year with lots of greats in the NFL. Elway, Marino, Young, Montana, Emmitt Smith, Barry Sanders, Jerry Rice... the list goes on.

      2002- Not a truly epic season for me, but fun to build with. Still, a lot of great players and the Browns made the playoffs. Dominant Buccaneers defense.

      2007- The almost perfect season by the Patriots, a close playoff race in the AFC.

      Other seasons I am considering:
      1978- The Steelers were still super tough and the Super Bowl against the Cowboys was epic. Earl Campbell was running over defenses. Staubach, Bradshaw, Tarkenton, Fouts, Franco Harris...

      1985- A season that I love because of the Bears that year. That defense was just soooo good! It is the start of the Kosar era in Cleveland, who came close to upsetting the Dolphins in the playoffs.

      1988- An epic Super Bowl; 49ers and Bengals, Tom Landry's last year as the Cowboys coach, Thurman Thomas' rookie season

      1999- The Browns are back. I see 99 as a transition year for several teams in the NFL. It was Steve Young's final season, Peyton Manning was quickly becoming amazing, and who can forget the Greatest Show on Turf!


      As you can see, there are so many great seasons and I have made rosters for many of them in the past.

      So, throw out your ideas or let me know if you like any of the years I mentioned. At this point I simply do not know what year I will go with, just looking for feedback and ideas.

      Also, if you have any questions about my rosters, how I make them, ratings, etc... feel free to ask
      As a quick reference, i did a 2007 file for ps4 on madden 21. If you have two consoles, it’d be easy to get the names and measurements and equipment. The ratings are a lot like what you use as well.

      Very fun season to mess around with. Also that season/era mixes well with the generic playbooks and the era better fits the newer madden engine. Honestly the generic playbooks, especially west coast and balance and run and gun better represent the 2000s than it does now. Itfeels like leftover playbooks from that era.

      it wasnt hard to make it look like 2007 as is for 90s and 80s teams with special playbooks and slider tinkering.
      Last edited by tommycoa; 06-08-2023, 03:18 PM.
      For an alltime legends team on xbox, search usertag haughtypine7723

      The file is called xboxassantesgreatestever.

      Teams finished:
      Bears, bills, browns, KC, Dall, Miami, Philly, ATL, SF, NYG, Jags, GB, NE, OAK, Rams, Ravens, WASH, NO, PITT, broncos, Texans, panthers, vikings, colts

      Comment

      • Iteachpercussion
        MVP
        • Jul 2012
        • 1816

        #4
        Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

        Originally posted by iceman43
        You gotta do 2000 Ravens

        Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk
        2000 is an intriguing season and one I have never done. That defense was amazing, and Dilfer does not get enough respect for his play that year. He was not great by any means, but he made plays when he had to and understood his role that season.

        Comment

        • Iteachpercussion
          MVP
          • Jul 2012
          • 1816

          #5
          Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

          Originally posted by tommycoa
          As a quick reference, i did a 2007 file for ps4 on madden 21. If you have two consoles, it’d be easy to get the names and measurements and equipment. The ratings are a lot like what you use as well.

          Very fun season to mess around with. Also that season/era mixes well with the generic playbooks and the era better fits the newer madden engine. Honestly the generic playbooks, especially west coast and balance and run and gun better represent the 2000s than it does now. Itfeels like leftover playbooks from that era.

          it wasnt hard to make it look like 2007 as is for 90s and 80s teams with special playbooks and slider tinkering.
          I have a file pretty close to ready for 2007 with all the rosters and everything. I have M21 on NextGen, but I think it has the dual entitlement so I could download it on my PS4 as well.

          You are right, it is easier to replicate 2000s NFL in Madden than the 80s and 90s. However, I was pleasantly surprised with how well M23 handled my 87 roster and the 95 roster. The run heavy playbook did a far better job than it has in the past with play calling and truly being run heavy.

          Comment

          • Ram209
            MVP
            • Feb 2003
            • 1161

            #6
            Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

            1990...... My vote .... Chiefs ground and pound... Bills start of dynasty... Bo Jackson last year....Giants SB run..... Niners end of dynasty (kind of). Barry Sanders rookie year.

            Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

            Comment

            • Iteachpercussion
              MVP
              • Jul 2012
              • 1816

              #7
              Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

              Originally posted by Ram209
              1990...... My vote .... Chiefs ground and pound... Bills start of dynasty... Bo Jackson last year....Giants SB run..... Niners end of dynasty (kind of). Barry Sanders rookie year.

              Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk
              I did 1990 for M22. Not saying I won't turn around and do it again. LOL

              That was a fun year, especially if you keep it going in franchise mode.

              Comment

              • Ram209
                MVP
                • Feb 2003
                • 1161

                #8
                Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                Originally posted by Iteachpercussion
                I did 1990 for M22. Not saying I won't turn around and do it again. LOL



                That was a fun year, especially if you keep it going in franchise mode.
                Man I would seriously pay you a small fee if you did it.... Also you still doing it on PS5? Or you going to move to Xbox also?

                Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

                Comment

                • Iteachpercussion
                  MVP
                  • Jul 2012
                  • 1816

                  #9
                  Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                  Originally posted by Ram209
                  Man I would seriously pay you a small fee if you did it.... Also you still doing it on PS5? Or you going to move to Xbox also?

                  Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk
                  I am still on PS5, I have an Series X also, but use it for mostly other games. I did play M21 on it though and made a 1999 roster.

                  Comment

                  • Ebpmd
                    MVP
                    • Dec 2013
                    • 1191

                    #10
                    Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                    1975 was great year. Unfortunately any classic roster now is just lacking something without the Redskins old jerseys.

                    Comment

                    • Iteachpercussion
                      MVP
                      • Jul 2012
                      • 1816

                      #11
                      Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                      Originally posted by Ebpmd
                      1975 was great year. Unfortunately any classic roster now is just lacking something without the Redskins old jerseys.
                      It does suck not having the old Redskin uniforms anymore; any of the uniforms. At least in M21 the uniforms they were wearing were close to the old ones, just without the head, but the rest of the uniform was close. I would absolutely take that in the game. Keep the old uniforms but take the logo off the helmet. But that is not going to happen.

                      While it does suck, it is one of those things I will just have to live with. I enjoy classic rosters too much. LOL

                      Comment

                      • sheredia
                        MVP
                        • Apr 2006
                        • 2351

                        #12
                        Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                        the lack of any historic rosters is "maddening", to say the least. thank you for the time and effort for making these historic rosters. EA should be rewarding you guys for adding ANY replayability to these games. while 2k and sony are at least including some type of modes to honor the past, madden has done nothing.....for years.

                        Comment

                        • ripcandlestickpark
                          MVP
                          • Aug 2014
                          • 1175

                          #13
                          Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                          Out of the seasons you listed, I would be most interested in 1984, 1988, 1993, 2002, and/or 2007. And, to a slightly lesser extent, 1999.

                          I'd also like to pitch 2003. A fun season/set of players that doesn't get as much attention as 2002, IMO.

                          And, I know these seasons might be a bit too modern/recent, but, as a Niner fan, I have a lot of nostalgia for 2011 through 2013 and I'd love to see any of those seasons represented in classic roster form.
                          Last edited by ripcandlestickpark; 06-09-2023, 02:26 PM.
                          MLB: San Francisco Giants, Oakland Athletics (Sell The Damn Team, Fisher!)
                          NFL: San Francisco 49ers
                          NHL: San Jose Sharks
                          MLS: San Jose Earthquakes
                          EPL: Brentford FC

                          RIP San Francisco Deltas | 2017 NASL Champions

                          Comment

                          • TheBrew101
                            Rookie
                            • Mar 2003
                            • 309

                            #14
                            Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                            I would enjoy 1984. My Packers were mediocre but fun with James Lofton, John Jefferson, Paul Coffman amd Lynn Dickey on offense.

                            I appreciate any historic you make. Thanks for putting those together.

                            Comment

                            • doncropper
                              MVP
                              • Jul 2002
                              • 1414

                              #15
                              Re: Madden 24 Classic Roster Thoughts

                              1975, in my opinion, is one of the All-Time Greatest Classic Seasons .........

                              Comment

                              Working...