23 or 24 on PS4?

[TGov]

Long story short.
I play on PS4 and the last game I bought was The Show 21.
For PS4, is it worth upgrading to The Show 24, without created stadiums, etc?
Or just save my money and get The Show 23?

I mostly play franchise, barely play RTTS or DD.(And have no interest in Jeter's story) I'm interested in creating my own teams and playing in some new stadiums. I know 24 has the Kingdome and Greenlee Field but is that worth the cost?
Is 24 a big enough upgrade to 23 on PS4?

Thanks.

[steelcityjames]

Re: 23 or 24 on PS4?

Great question. I play on PS4 as well. 23 was awesome, in my opinion. I bought 24 because I'm guessing it could be the last one on PS4, so my intention is to play it for a couple years. So far I think 24 is a slight upgrade over 23. The hitting feels a bit better to me and pitching is also a tad bit more challenging. They are both great versions, you can't go wrong with either one. I didn't mind paying full price for 24 because, like I said, I plan on playing it for a few years... So I'll definitely get my money's worth

[bayou_city_bob]

Re: 23 or 24 on PS4?

I am also a Franchise-exclusive player on PS4.

I went ahead bought '24 for PS4, and have been mostly satisfied with this year's version. The addition of the Pitch Clock & Disengagement rules is a plus over '23's game. It makes the running game more realistic, since in '22 and '23- the computer would have a tendency to throw a high number of pickoffs during the same batter, if you were most likely stealing from 1st base.

Also, in '24, 'just enough' extra depth has been added to Franchise with the new Top Prospect Lists and PPI Incentive Draft Picks.

Glaring issues that remain, of course, are: the need for larger rosters (Starting a new Franchise with 'Real-Life' injuries on really shows this, with some MLB teams close to the max of 5 players on the Injured List before Opening Day), flexible Starting Rotations (4, 5 or 6), and new logic for bullpen usage.

[TGov]

Re: 23 or 24 on PS4?

Thanks guys, I appreciate the responses!

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: 23 or 24 on PS4?

My opinion is if you dont already absolutely consider 24 a must-have-now game, you'd be better off with 23. Just from a cost perspective.