On his fifth ballot, catcher Krish Balvinder earned his spot in the South Asia Baseball Hall of Fame. He was the lone inductee for the 2003 class, making a big jump up to 84.5%. Two others were above 60%, but short of the needed 66%. LF Indirjeet Dayada had 61.5% on his third ballot and RP Harini Shreenath got 60.8% for his second try.

RF Najib Kumaili fell off the ballot after ten votes. He was hurt by starting his official career at age 27 with only nine years’ worth of stats between Dhaka and Hyderabad. Kumaili still managed six Silver Sluggers, 1315 hits, 800 runs, 221 doubles, 395 home runs, 922 RBI, a .265/.346/.557 slash, 157 wRC+, and 55.7 WAR. He was twice an LCS MVP and helped the Hippos to the inaugural SAB title in 1980. The lack of longevity sank him though, peaking at 38.8% in 2000 and ending in 17.2%. Had Kumaili had the luxury of his early 20s, he probably would’ve gotten the tallies needed to earn a spot.

Krish Balvinder – Catcher – Ahmedabad Animals – 84.5% Fifth Ballot
Krish Balvinder was a 6’0’’, 200 pound right-handed catcher from Khargone, India; a city of 106,000 in Madhya Pradesh (central province). Balvinder was an excellent contact hitter, especially for a catcher. He was great at avoiding strikeouts, but didn’t get many walks. Balvinder had strong gap power and averaged 34 doubles per 162 game average. He wasn’t a big bopper though with a career high of 11 home runs in a season.
Balvinder was a fairly crafty baseunner, but like most catchers, he was really slow. He spent his whole career behind the plate and was rated as firmly above average to good defensively. Balvinder became a popular player with many fans, but he didn’t endear himself with teammates or coaches. Balvinder was described by some as disloyal, lazy, greedy, and dumb. However, a durable catcher with a great bat and solid defense were almost like unicorns.
In the 1982 SAB Draft, Balvinder went third overall to Hyderabad. He was a full-time starter as a rookie for the Hippos and a solid one, taking third in Rookie of the Year voting with 2.9 WAR. That would be his only season with Hyderabad though. In the offseason, Balvinder and fellow catcher Austin Leiker were traded for three players to Ho Chi Minh City. Balvinder was the starting catcher for five seasons with the Hedgehogs, although he missed the final half of his first season there to a severely strained hip muscle.
The next four seasons for HCMC saw four straight Silver Sluggers and batting titles in 1986 (.351) and 1987 (.356). Balvinder also had 6+ WAR in both of those seasons. The great Ho Chi Minh City dynasty began with Southeast Asia League titles in both 1987 and 1989. Both seasons, they fell to the Ahmedabad dynasty in the SAB Championship. In 31 playoff starts for the Hedgehogs, Balvinder had 32 hits, 7 runs, 9 doubles, 15 RBI, a .278/.298/.400 slash, 92 wRC+, and 0.3 WAR.
Although playing in Vietnam, Balvinder did return home to India for the World Baseball Championship from 1986-94. He wasn’t a full-time starter though with only 23 games and 16 starts in that stretch, posting 17 hits, 8 runs, and 0.4 WAR. When HCMC’s team control ended after the 1988 season, the soon-to-be 28-year old Balvinder wanted to return home to India.
He would jump to the other side of the epic playoff rivalry, signing a four-year, $2,628,000 deal with Ahmedabad. Balvinder won a Silver Slugger in 1991 and helped the Animals win four straight SAB titles from 1989-92. Three of those wins came at the expense of his former squad HCMC. Balvinder stepped up in the playoffs with Ahmedabad with 71 starts, 81 hits, 21 runs, 13 doubles, 2 home runs, 27 RBI, a .308/.339/.388 slash, 120 wRC+, and 1.9 WAR.
Balvinder’s contract expired after the 1992 season and Ahmedabad brought him back on a one-year deal for 1993. He posted a very solid 5.5 WAR season, finishing his Animals run with 735 hits, 245 runs, 121 doubles, 49 home runs, 277 RBI, a .313/.339/.433 slash, 139 wRC+, and 25.6 WAR.
Even with his talent, Balvinder’s poor attitude and perceived laziness soured his reputation from many in the game. Although he still seemingly could go at a high level, Balvinder was unsigned in both 1994 and 1995. It wasn’t until the winter of 1995 that he formally retired at age 35.
Balvinder’s career stats saw 1623 hits, 551 runs, 306 doubles, 91 home runs, 606 RBI, a .312/.339/.431 slash, 128 wRC+, and 49.8 WAR. He had a lot working against him with many voters, led by his personality. Balvinder’s accumulations weren’t tremendous in part due to being a catcher and in part due to leaving the game young. He also didn’t have big power numbers and as of 2037, would only be tenth all-time in WAR amongst catchers.
Considering how hard it is for catchers to make it into any Hall of Fame generally, it’s almost a minor miracle Balvinder made the cut. Most agreed that he was the top catcher for the first decade-ish of SAB and an important part of both of the historic dynasty runs of the era. Balvinder debuted at 51.8%, then got to 64.2% in 2001. He dropped back to 59.5% in 2002, but earned a stronger look with no standouts on the 2003 ballot. Balvinder won over a large chunk of doubters to get 84.5% for a fifth ballot induction as the lone addition from the 2003 SAB class.
Comment