Start of year recurting board

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Heelz
    Rookie
    • Apr 2009
    • 29

    #1

    Start of year recurting board

    So i'm starting my third season in a offline dynasty, setting up and populating my board with recruits. I can only scout and offer scholarships, can not add any other recruiting action like send the house etc. Everything is grayed out with a lock icon other than scout and offer scholarship? I have like 1200 hrs of points to spend. What am I missing? Has it always been like that?


    Thanks
  • Orange Krush
    Pro
    • Jun 2013
    • 581

    #2
    Re: Start of year recurting board

    Yes, you can only scout and offer scholarships

    Comment

    • jello1717
      All Star
      • Feb 2006
      • 5720

      #3
      Re: Start of year recurting board

      It’s always been like that. If you hadn’t noticed, then hopefully you didn’t skip the preseason recruiting in the past. When you get to that stage, the recruiting section under your actions tab is checked by default, making it look like you’re already done, even though you’ve done nothing. In all other stages it’s only checked if you have spent all recruiting minutes. So I can definitely see someone seeing the check mark and not knowing they still need to do ALL a recruiting because they think it’s done already.
      Favorite Teams:
      College #1: Michigan Wolverines
      College #2: Michigan State Spartans (my alma mater)
      College #3: North Carolina Tar Heels
      NHL: Detroit Redwings

      Comment

      • Heelz
        Rookie
        • Apr 2009
        • 29

        #4
        Re: Start of year recurting board

        Thanks guys. Apparently I just forgot, somehow I thought yr1 of my dynasty I spent all the hours. Appreciate yall chiming in!

        Comment

        • jello1717
          All Star
          • Feb 2006
          • 5720

          #5
          Re: Start of year recurting board

          Originally posted by Heelz
          Thanks guys. Apparently I just forgot, somehow I thought yr1 of my dynasty I spent all the hours. Appreciate yall chiming in!


          You very well might’ve spent them all year 1 if your school had less prestige (which equates to fewer hours to spend) or had less coach recruiting abilities (which equates to more hours needed to scout. 1200 is a lot of hours. I think I had 450 hours total to scout/offer my 1st year and could only fully scout 15 guys during the preseason.
          Favorite Teams:
          College #1: Michigan Wolverines
          College #2: Michigan State Spartans (my alma mater)
          College #3: North Carolina Tar Heels
          NHL: Detroit Redwings

          Comment

          • tessl
            All Star
            • Apr 2007
            • 5685

            #6
            Re: Start of year recurting board

            What I do is offer every 4 star or (rarely) 5 star who has me high on his list. Then I scout 3 stars who have me top 3 and offer the ones I like. Then I scout certain positions and offer the ones I like.

            Then adjust based upon how many offers the players have and remove those I can't get while going all in on players at the top of my list. I have yet to have 85 on scholarship but I win a lot because I get good players.
            Last edited by tessl; 09-15-2024, 01:55 PM.

            Comment

            • sherrane
              Pro
              • Apr 2013
              • 688

              #7
              Re: Start of year recurting board

              Chase wrote an article on this a couple of weeks ago.





              While I don't agree completely with this because I think it lacks strategy, it is a good starting point and explanation. He suggests you offer 35 scholarships initially. That does not reflect "real life" in my opinion but then again in real life verbal commits reopen their recruiting which does not happen in this game.


              I will add 25-- 30 players to my recruiting board. I initially scout the players and Gems get an immediate offer. I usually remove Busts from the board unless I desperately need to fill the position and his ratings are still in the "star power" range for the current state of my program. A recruit who has me #1 will also get an offer unless I was not impressed with his attributes after scouting. I am still working through the recruiting to see what does and doesn't work for me. I have noticed that is it difficult to overcome a pipeline disadvantage. If I'm #1 for a recruit with a silver (level 2) pipeline and #2 or #3 has a gold (level 3) or higher I know that I have to assign at least as many recruiting points as the computer controlled program to have a shot at signing him. I have watched the slow, painful recruiting death from a weaker pipeline often enough to know that I may not be the best recruiter at this point.

              Comment

              • tessl
                All Star
                • Apr 2007
                • 5685

                #8
                Re: Start of year recurting board

                Originally posted by sherrane
                Chase wrote an article on this a couple of weeks ago.





                While I don't agree completely with this because I think it lacks strategy, it is a good starting point and explanation. He suggests you offer 35 scholarships initially. That does not reflect "real life" in my opinion but then again in real life verbal commits reopen their recruiting which does not happen in this game.


                I will add 25-- 30 players to my recruiting board. I initially scout the players and Gems get an immediate offer. I usually remove Busts from the board unless I desperately need to fill the position and his ratings are still in the "star power" range for the current state of my program. A recruit who has me #1 will also get an offer unless I was not impressed with his attributes after scouting. I am still working through the recruiting to see what does and doesn't work for me. I have noticed that is it difficult to overcome a pipeline disadvantage. If I'm #1 for a recruit with a silver (level 2) pipeline and #2 or #3 has a gold (level 3) or higher I know that I have to assign at least as many recruiting points as the computer controlled program to have a shot at signing him. I have watched the slow, painful recruiting death from a weaker pipeline often enough to know that I may not be the best recruiter at this point.
                It was a good article and I learned from it but I do things a bit differently. I'm Iowa State - not great pipelines - I don't shy away from offering in the initial recruiting week because schools with higher pipelines are on the list. I wait to see if those other schools (a) offer a scholarship and (b) invest recruiting points in that player. If you offer in week 1 you get a head start.

                Week 2 I filter for recruits with 0 offers and fully scout players to find players who can play. You also need to have a grasp on attributes and which ones matter in the game. As in real life star level doesn't tell the whole story.

                Comment

                • letsgopens66
                  Pro
                  • Aug 2010
                  • 847

                  #9
                  Re: Start of year recurting board

                  Originally posted by sherrane
                  Chase wrote an article on this a couple of weeks ago.





                  While I don't agree completely with this because I think it lacks strategy, it is a good starting point and explanation. He suggests you offer 35 scholarships initially. That does not reflect "real life" in my opinion but then again in real life verbal commits reopen their recruiting which does not happen in this game.


                  I will add 25-- 30 players to my recruiting board. I initially scout the players and Gems get an immediate offer. I usually remove Busts from the board unless I desperately need to fill the position and his ratings are still in the "star power" range for the current state of my program. A recruit who has me #1 will also get an offer unless I was not impressed with his attributes after scouting. I am still working through the recruiting to see what does and doesn't work for me. I have noticed that is it difficult to overcome a pipeline disadvantage. If I'm #1 for a recruit with a silver (level 2) pipeline and #2 or #3 has a gold (level 3) or higher I know that I have to assign at least as many recruiting points as the computer controlled program to have a shot at signing him. I have watched the slow, painful recruiting death from a weaker pipeline often enough to know that I may not be the best recruiter at this point.

                  I always send out 35 schollies and I think it’s somewhat true to real life, lots of schools send out an initial offer just to show the kid they’re interested. I like it for that initial influence bump
                  Pittsburgh Penguins
                  Penn State Nittany Lions
                  Pittsburgh Pirates
                  Denver Broncos

                  Comment

                  • sherrane
                    Pro
                    • Apr 2013
                    • 688

                    #10
                    Re: Start of year recurting board

                    Originally posted by letsgopens66
                    I always send out 35 schollies and I think it’s somewhat true to real life, lots of schools send out an initial offer just to show the kid they’re interested. I like it for that initial influence bump

                    While I would be surprised 35 offers flow out in the first week, you bring up something else in the game that isn't real life in that the coaching staff knows about kids well before their Senior year in high school. Some kids may have been offered in their Junior or Sophomore season, which we cannot do in this game.

                    Comment

                    • dipatach
                      Rookie
                      • Dec 2005
                      • 199

                      #11
                      Re: Start of year recurting board

                      Offer all 35 scholarships. Only scout 3 stars player. Always fight hard for the top players in my state in my Maryland and Minnesota dynasties.


                      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                      Comment

                      • Inverarity
                        Rookie
                        • May 2003
                        • 145

                        #12
                        Re: Start of year recurting board

                        I focus on scouting 3 star and 4 star players at position of need. I’m at Georgia State so I don’t get the luxury of 5 star players. Not yet at least.

                        I also prepare by tracking which positions I need and which players I might replace (typically lower rated, Normal dev dudes or guys that won’t likely take the field due to their class and who is in front of them). And focus there first.

                        Comment

                        • letsgopens66
                          Pro
                          • Aug 2010
                          • 847

                          #13
                          Re: Start of year recurting board

                          Originally posted by sherrane
                          While I would be surprised 35 offers flow out in the first week, you bring up something else in the game that isn't real life in that the coaching staff knows about kids well before their Senior year in high school. Some kids may have been offered in their Junior or Sophomore season, which we cannot do in this game.

                          Yeah usually the good ones will have an “offer” by sophomore year it seems. Most schools will have their classes wrapped up before the season but idk how EA could recreate that without it being incredibly tedious/overwhelming. I like following recruiting in real life but managing four different classes of HS kids at once would be insane in the game.
                          Pittsburgh Penguins
                          Penn State Nittany Lions
                          Pittsburgh Pirates
                          Denver Broncos

                          Comment

                          • jello1717
                            All Star
                            • Feb 2006
                            • 5720

                            #14
                            Re: Start of year recurting board

                            Originally posted by letsgopens66
                            Yeah usually the good ones will have an “offer” by sophomore year it seems. Most schools will have their classes wrapped up before the season but idk how EA could recreate that without it being incredibly tedious/overwhelming. I like following recruiting in real life but managing four different classes of HS kids at once would be insane in the game.


                            Granted basketball recruiting classes are much, much smaller, but in CH2K8 you could recruit underclass HS players and I LOVED this about that game. Recruiting a kid for multiple years, not knowing what his final star rating would be, or if he’d stick with you over the bigger schools if he blossomed into a top recruit was awesome.
                            Favorite Teams:
                            College #1: Michigan Wolverines
                            College #2: Michigan State Spartans (my alma mater)
                            College #3: North Carolina Tar Heels
                            NHL: Detroit Redwings

                            Comment

                            • Inverarity
                              Rookie
                              • May 2003
                              • 145

                              #15
                              Re: Start of year recurting board

                              My first year I successfully recruited 31 of 35 possible. The next year, another 31. In year 3 I purposely only got 23. And I still ended up having to make tough choices on who to cut (aka 'Encourage Transfer').

                              This year I'm aiming for 12-15 total recruits, because that's all I really need. I want the kids I already have to turn into the players I hoped they'd be when I recruited them.

                              Does anyone else do it this way or do y'all try for as many as possible and just encourage the bottom to transfer out each year?

                              Comment

                              Working...