Getting roster update into existing dynasty

[Mizzoutiger]

Is there a way to get the latest roster update into an existing offline dynasty? Or , do I have to start a new dynasty to use the latest update?


Thanks!

[TripleCrown9]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Pretty sure you have to start a new one.

[I_HATE_THAT_DUDE]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Gotta start a new one chief...this is something that been lacking from sports games imop...there should be a way to have the option to have live franchise/dynasty updates if you choose to with all the AAA sports games. To have all the current transactions done.

Sent from my SM-S928W using Tapatalk

[fnz21]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

These things sound good in theory, but your dynasty or franchise in other games will never match what's happening in real life in terms of real game results. And updating the rosters would make whatever is happening in your save useless. If in week 2 of your franchise Ashton Jeanty got hurt, but a roster came out by the time you were in Week 3, his in-game injury would not be included in a real-life roster update. How should the game handle that? What about players who are in their third season of a dynasty? How would that work

In real life DeAndre Hopkins just got traded from the Titans to the Chiefs, but what if in my Madden franchise the Titans were undefeated? Why would they trade him?

[ReturnoftheTmac]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Gotta start a new one chief...this is something that been lacking from sports games imop...there should be a way to have the option to have live franchise/dynasty updates if you choose to with all the AAA sports games. To have all the current transactions done.

Sent from my SM-S928W using Tapatalk

This is why I wish there was a “start today” option. Plus it would help a lot with the busted stats.

[matt2053]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Gotta start a new one chief...this is something that been lacking from sports games imop...there should be a way to have the option to have live franchise/dynasty updates if you choose to with all the AAA sports games. To have all the current transactions done.

Sent from my SM-S928W using Tapatalk

Makes no sense whatsoever.

I can't even fathom why you'd want that?

[gman2774]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

I do wish the new equipment was applied to players in my existing dynasty. It’s not, correct?

[Mizzoutiger]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Thanks for the info everyone! Much appreciated.

[Illin Degenerate]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Makes no sense whatsoever.

I can't even fathom why you'd want that?

youre not a real sim player if you play more than one game a week sir. there are games that let you make roster moves for each team but no game is going to make live roster updates within a dynasty for that .0001% of the player base that wants that feature. editing on the other hand obviously everyone at least wants that as an option.

[DonkeyJote]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Gotta start a new one chief...this is something that been lacking from sports games imop...there should be a way to have the option to have live franchise/dynasty updates if you choose to with all the AAA sports games. To have all the current transactions done.

Sent from my SM-S928W using Tapatalk

I don't even know how that would work. If there's been any progression, roster moves, injuries, etc. if your dystany/franchise, or if you're even just past the real life date, there's no way for that to work.

Sent from my Pixel 6 using Tapatalk

[Fall_DIFH]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Does anybody know if you can actually use the new rosters at all?

After the first roster update it wasn’t letting me import the current rosters into an offline or solo online dynasty

[jasontoddwhitt]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

Does anybody know if you can actually use the new rosters at all?

After the first roster update it wasn’t letting me import the current rosters into an offline or solo online dynasty

Oh, it uses the new roster.

The problem is a glitch with new players and players with position swaps or archetype changes.

https://answers.ea.com/t5/Bug-Reports/Updated-Rosters-not-updated-in-dynasty/td-p/14174603

So this issue started on Aug 29 with the roster update. It has been 56 days. We have seen a few minor patches, two major title updates (including today), and another roster update. And no acknowledgement or fix.



What it Affects:

-Any player who was added to the base roster in any roster update since launch.

-Any player who had their position changed in the base roster since launch.

-An estimated 15-40% of all the players in the game.



The Problem:

-These players' archetypes will change upon creating a new dynasty (offline and online).

-This can result in a massive drop in OVR.

-It will also affect player progression in dynasty, as the player will develop with the wrong archetype.



The problem seems to vary by position. Here are some examples:



-QB seem to default to Field General

For example: FAU QB Kasen Weisman should be a 67 OVR Improviser, but appears as a 63 OVR Field General



-HB seem to default to Receiving Back

For example: JMU RB George Pettaway should be an 85 OVR Elusive Back, but appears as a 76 OVR Receiving Back



-FB seem to default to Blocking

For example: NC State FB Jordan Poole should be a 78 OVR Utility, but appears as a 62 Blocking



-WR seem to default to Deep Threat

For example, Western Michigan WR Kaevion Mack should be a 72 OVR , but appears as a 71 OVR Deep Threat



-TE seem to default to Blocking

For example: Cal TE Corey Dyches should be an 83 OVR Vertical Threat, but appears as a 45 OVR Blocking



-OL seem to default to Pass Protector

For example, JMU LT Tyshawn Wyatt should be a 70 OVR Power, but appears as a 64 OVR Pass Protector



-DL seem to default to Power Rusher

For example, Coastal Carolina RE Jayden Bryant should be a 58 OVR Speed Rusher, but appears as a 50 Power Rusher



-OLB seem to default to Power Rusher'

For example, Texas ROLB Morice Blackwell Jr should be a 79 OVR Pass Coverage, but appears as a 65 OVR Power Rusher



-MLB seem to default to Field General

For example, Cincinnati MLB Monty Weedon should be a 67 Pass Coverage, but appears as a 65 Field General



-CB seem to default to Slot

For example, Duke - Tre'shon Devones should be a 76 Zone, but appears as a 71 Slot



-S seem to default to Hybrid

For example, Utah State SS Omari Okeke should be a 77 OVR Run Support, but appears as a 74 OVR Hybrid

[canes21]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

These things sound good in theory, but your dynasty or franchise in other games will never match what's happening in real life in terms of real game results. And updating the rosters would make whatever is happening in your save useless. If in week 2 of your franchise Ashton Jeanty got hurt, but a roster came out by the time you were in Week 3, his in-game injury would not be included in a real-life roster update. How should the game handle that? What about players who are in their third season of a dynasty? How would that work



In real life DeAndre Hopkins just got traded from the Titans to the Chiefs, but what if in my Madden franchise the Titans were undefeated? Why would they trade him?

Only feasible way I can see something working is each player has a unique ID. Whenever a player has a ratings adjustment, the same tweaks are applied in your dynasty. Even if you're in year 3 and they've progressed, if the tweak docked their speed 2 points, then they get docked in your dynasty those 2 points from where they have progressed to that point.

And, if a real player replaces a fake player, that player ID allows the fake player in your dynasty to turn into the real player. The real player inherits any stats the fake player accumulated in your dynasty.

Sent from my SM-S901U using Tapatalk

[Feros Ferio 7]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

So I'm in year 6 of a dynasty and you'd want these roster updates applied to an existing dynasty that no longer has any of these players?

I mean this really makes sense. The coding should be super easy. Just write over what's happened and make up some new stuff.

This will go great.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Funkycorm]

Re: Getting roster update into existing dynasty

These things sound good in theory, but your dynasty or franchise in other games will never match what's happening in real life in terms of real game results. And updating the rosters would make whatever is happening in your save useless. If in week 2 of your franchise Ashton Jeanty got hurt, but a roster came out by the time you were in Week 3, his in-game injury would not be included in a real-life roster update. How should the game handle that? What about players who are in their third season of a dynasty? How would that work

In real life DeAndre Hopkins just got traded from the Titans to the Chiefs, but what if in my Madden franchise the Titans were undefeated? Why would they trade him?

This right here. It would mess up my current franchise. For any sports game.

Sure, it may be something you could do optionally, but it should be and lucky is a very low priority for sports devs. There are other things to focus on then something like an extremely niche feature.