Unfortunately madden as we knew it is not what it is now. Roster creation is so bad there aren't even any good current rosters moreless anything with any real depth.
The best you can do is take the original roster by default and sim 10 to 15 years then go in and edit to get that roster, it's not worth it, just install one of your previous maddens that had it and play that.
Currently I use 25 just for today's teams, for classic rosters madden 20. People will say it's old, but guess what, I have over a complete 2 decades with real draft classes while those saying it's so old struggle to get 1 real classic roster in a modern game that was not built for that kind of playstyle.
On xbox you can press Y, on Ps you can press Triangle to get the list of rosters Currently available, all are either marked wip or a joke. Percussions did 92 and I think phantom is doing a older file, not sure if its done or not, everything else is not worth it.