[fossen]

Quote: Originally Posted by KBomber

Somewhere, somehow, OS is going to have to expand their numeric scoring system to provide greater coordination and relevance to the written commentary or just scrap the numeric scores altogether. Given that the review itself speaks to this issue in detail, I think it's time that this was seriously considered.

I'll quote myself from the other thread ...

Quote:

It's really a matter of weight. For me, a game is mainly on-the-field. That's what the overwhelming majority of the score comes from. As you'll note in the review, I really like the on-the-field gameplay of Madden 07, and it's only real huge black eye is the fatigue issue.

I think it's a fair score, but I think the review should be detailed enough that you could assign your own score based on your own weighting system.

Quote: Originally Posted by bears4444x

Terrible review. Tells nothing that you can't get from the forums or on other websites. Boring and long. Why do they keep letting this guy write reviews?

Did I kick your dog or something? Piss in your cornflakes? Ban you in a previous life?