Operation Sports Forums - View Single Post - McNabb, Staley, and other Eagle Ratings in Madden

mike62474 · 07-29-2003, 09:01 PM

Quote:

bgeno said:
Numbers aren't everything, Mike. I agree with the poster who said Vick had no talent around him, but I also agree that him being a 95 is up too high. I say somewhere between 87 and 91. He single-handedly put that team into the playoffs. His throwing ability is getting much better and with Peerless Price, i think he can get over the 3000 yard mark for passing. Anytime a d-coordinator has to spy on a quarterback with one, two, even 3 different players, he deserves to be better than an 80 overall.

He didn't single handedly do it. Their defense was very good.

07-29-2003, 09:01 PM	#33
mike62474 Rookie OVR: 3 Join Date: May 2003	Re: McNabb, Staley, and other Eagle Ratings in Madden Quote: *bgeno said:* Numbers aren't everything, Mike. I agree with the poster who said Vick had no talent around him, but I also agree that him being a 95 is up too high. I say somewhere between 87 and 91. He single-handedly put that team into the playoffs. His throwing ability is getting much better and with Peerless Price, i think he can get over the 3000 yard mark for passing. Anytime a d-coordinator has to spy on a quarterback with one, two, even 3 different players, he deserves to be better than an 80 overall. He didn't single handedly do it. Their defense was very good.