Winning Eleven 8 Review (Xbox)

Quote: Originally Posted by adembroski

WE8 took a step backwards in terms of gameplay.

Are you joking?

[ChiTownKid]

I would have bought the game instantly if it had XBox Live support.

They lose.

[pb4201]

Quote: Originally Posted by fossen

Then what would a WE8 with the XBL play that got cut from the U.S. version deserve?

Then what about a 4.5...that's 90%....4/5 for this game is crazy...my math says that's an 80%...come on get real!!

[fossen]

Quote: Originally Posted by pb4201

Then what about a 4.5...that's 90%....4/5 for this game is crazy...my math says that's an 80%...come on get real!!

Ignore your math, it doesn't necessarily apply. Read this:

Quote:

While OperationSports.com grades on a five-star system, it is not meant to represent a "percentage grade". 5/5 - A rare and singular achievement in sports gaming. A "must-buy" for any serious gamer. 4/5 - An overall solid outing with few flaws. Worth purchasing for most gamers. 3/5 - A decent performance with room to improve. Fans of the sport/series will likely enjoy it, but others may wish to rent before buying. 2/5 - A disappointing effort. Rent before buying - at best. 1/5 - A poor game with significant flaws. Only for the very brave, very patient, or obscenely wealthy.