NCAA Football 09 Beta Player Rating Screenshots

[acarrero]

Any idea as to how final these rosters are? Last year, was the Beta version a final verison as to rosters?

[countryboy]

Quote: Originally Posted by acarrero

Any idea as to how final these rosters are? Last year, was the Beta version a final verison as to rosters?

I don't know how final they are, but they are pretty darn close.

[peteykirch]

Quote: Originally Posted by countryboy

I don't know how final they are, but they are pretty darn close.

I know one thing I'll be mass editing these ratings.

There is no way in hell Cantwell is a 89 and Mike Teel is a 88. 1400 yards, 10tds, 7 ints isn't better than what Teel has accomplished so far.

[countryboy]

Quote: Originally Posted by peteykirch

I know one thing I'll be mass editing these ratings. There is no way in hell Cantwell is a 89 and Mike Teel is a 88. 1400 yards, 10tds, 7 ints isn't better than what Teel has accomplished so far.

Well, given that Cantwell is a big NFL prospect this year given his size and arm strength, that may be way he is rated so highly.

[peteykirch]

I still don't understand how spot duty when Brohm gets hurt makes him rated higher than someone who has started for the last 2 1/2 years.

Size wise Teel and Cantwell are the same, except Cantwell is like 15lbs heavier. Same height though. I kind of wish how deadly Teel could've been last year if he wasn't throwing the ball with a busted thumb for 60% of the year last year.

The same goes with Grutza from Cincy. Even his own coach isn't high on him and he is a 87 overall in the game.

[countryboy]

Quote: Originally Posted by peteykirch

I still don't understand how spot duty when Brohm gets hurt makes him rated higher than someone who has started for the last 2 1/2 years. Size wise Teel and Cantwell are the same, except Cantwell is like 15lbs heavier. Same height though. I kind of wish how deadly Teel could've been last year if he wasn't throwing the ball with a busted thumb for 60% of the year last year. The same goes with Grutza from Cincy. Even his own coach isn't high on him and he is a 87 overall in the game.

I am just giving you a reason as to why he may be rated higher. Don't complain to me, I didn't make the ratings.

[BaseballCtchr]

Cant complain much with Clemson:
RB Davis 95
RB Spiller 95 (little high)
SS Hamlin 95
FS Clemons 93
WR Kelley 92
LE Sapp 91
QB Harper 90 (I think he is more in the 85-87 range)

Now for S. Carolina

MLB Brinkley 97
WR McKinley 92
LE Norwood 91 (he has moved to LB so this is going to be too high)
LB Paulk 91 (too high, never really done much on the field. Fun fact told me he would have went to V. Tech had he ever taken a visit there but he never did and alas ends up a Gamecock)
CB Thomas 90 (as long as he cant catch this will work)
RB Davis 90 (way too high and anyone who has watched him will agree)
RT Sorensen 89 (no sure how this happened)

Where is Captain and Emanuel Cook at for SC

Overall not bad.

[Scott]

I disagree with Harper...He is probably one of the Top QBs in the nation.