NHL 2K10 Hi Res Screenshot (Lecavalier)

[baa7]

Quote: Originally Posted by slickdtc

My logic is flawed because...

...because you typed, "Who cares how big the puck is?" Logically, there's a point where it absolutely makes sense to start caring. I suggested that point would be when the puck approaches the size of a frisbee. Maybe you wouldn't care until the puck reached breadbox dimensions, I don't know. I asked you when it is we should all start caring, but you haven't answered that question yet. And until you do, it certainly looks like your logic with this whole argument is flawed, yes.

[baa7]

Quote: Originally Posted by slickdtc

I'd love for the puck to be 1 inch thick and 3 inches in diameter, but if it's 1.2 inches thick and 3.1 inches in diameter, I will live and so will the rest of you.

Actually, the puck in those screens looks to be a good 33% larger than in real life, so more like 4.5 inches wide and 1.5 inches thick. Bigger than a pancake but smaller than a dinner plate in other words.

[baa7]

Quote: Originally Posted by Eddie1967

LOL, great post. These things would never be noticed during gameplay.

LOL, great post and I agre... Er, wait a minute. The oversized goalie masks are entirely noticable during gameplay. Bah, you almost had me agreeing with you even though you're completely wrong!

[LuGer33]

You can only see the first two rows, but I don't see any team sweaters in the crowd. Kind of annoying.

Everything else, like the last screen, looks much nicer in high res.

[Keirik]

Quote: Originally Posted by slickdtc

More and more of the same... The puck is incrementally bigger then it should be, guys. It's not astronomically larger to where it will affect the gameplay at all. That's what I'm trying to say. But now this is 3 posters who have twisted it and exaggerated the size (frisbee, meatloaf... really?) of the puck. My logic is flawed because God forbid the puck be slightly bigger then it should be (if it even is, given the angles of the shots). I can't believe we're really going over something so minute. I'd love for the puck to be 1 inch thick and 3 inches in diameter, but if it's 1.2 inches thick and 3.1 inches in diameter, I will live and so will the rest of you. Come on guys...

your logic is flawed because your reasoning for the puck not being an issue is just because you personally dont care. That doen't make it any less or any more of an issue to others.

Heck, maybe some people would like to play bobblehead hockey as long as it plays a decent game. I personally would not want to however and you win nothing with the "i dont care so you shouldn't either" mentality.

whats up next, over the top fog in the ice? Oh wait...

[daflyboys]

Quote: Originally Posted by Keirik

your logic is flawed because your reasoning for the puck not being an issue is just because you personally dont care. That doen't make it any less or any more of an issue to others. Heck, maybe some people would like to play bobblehead hockey as long as it plays a decent game. I personally would not want to however and you win nothing with the "i dont care so you shouldn't either" mentality. whats up next, over the top fog in the ice? Oh wait...

Well, let's face it. None of these things are "issues". lol

[JimmyDeicide]

If you think i put someone down with my post then sorry too all you sensitive nancy drew readers.

No really i thought everyone used that line nowadays.

Maybe Scott you are partial to some crack?
2k hockey is my crack.... and beer.

No seriously im sorry i wasnt really serious and never am .

[Scottdau]

Drugs are bad! Also, it is cool for me. I have a lot of love for Kings fans. Someone needs too, since their team doesn't Any ways I want a vid now. One showing Joe passing to Marleau and making a wicked goal and then a celebration of a five man hug! Then the crowd going nuts! That is what I want to see.