MLB '10: The Show - Top 5 Right Fielders

[EnigmaNemesis]

Quote: Originally Posted by ATLNYankee

Wow another crappy list. Nelson Cruz?????????? The guy has 1 ok year hitting in an extreme hitters park and gets put over almost everybody? Where in the world is Andre Eithier? Nick Swisher had a better year than Nelson Cruz. Where is Nick Markakis? How in the world is Nelson Cruz so frigging over rated. SCEA really needs to add in park factors when evaluating players.

Just throwing this out there, but it is funny you mention Cruz and Park factors, then talk about Swisher who played at Yankee Stadium, in a more potent non pitch around line up to add.



Nick Swisher

BA HR RBI OBP SLG .249 29 82 .371 .498

Nelson Cruz

BA	HR	RBI	OBP	SLG
.260	33	76	.332	.524

Better would be defined with slight bias I think.

[CommunityCollege]

Quote: Originally Posted by EnigmaNemesis

Just throwing this out there, but it is funny you mention Cruz (who had 33 HRs) and Park factors, then talk about Swisher (a career .245 hitter) who played at Yankee Stadium, in a more potent non pitch around line up to add.

It's funny you mention Nick Swisher and the new Yankee Stadium seeing as he had 8 HR's at home and 21 HR's away compared to Nelson Cruz's 18 HR's @ home and 15 HR's away.

[EnigmaNemesis]

Quote: Originally Posted by CommunityCollege

It's funny you mention Nick Swisher and the new Yankee Stadium seeing as he had 8 HR's at home and 21 HR's away.

And Cruz has 18 at home and 15 away. Means nothing, just throwing it out there, that funny how ones wont take into account lineups they play in as well as stadiums for their own players.

[BatsareBugs]

Quote: Originally Posted by CommunityCollege

It's funny you mention Nick Swisher and the new Yankee Stadium seeing as he had 8 HR's at home and 21 HR's away compared to Nelson Cruz's 18 HR's @ home and 15 HR's away.

Damn Nick Swisher for playing in band boxes on the road!

[JermaineDye05]

Quote: Originally Posted by CommunityCollege

It's funny you mention Nick Swisher and the new Yankee Stadium seeing as he had 8 HR's at home and 21 HR's away compared to Nelson Cruz's 18 HR's @ home and 15 HR's away.

Idk if this adds to a players rating but one thing that could be benefiting Cruz is the fact that he was an allstar last year so that could boost his game rating.

Also, Swish's rating probably wasn't too respectable last year considering his .219 BA the year before.

I'd say both factored ultimately in the decision for this rating.

[econoodle]

Quote: Originally Posted by JermaineDye05

Idk if this adds to a players rating but one thing that could be benefiting Cruz is the fact that he was an allstar last year so that could boost his game rating. Also, Swish's rating probably wasn't too respectable last year considering his .219 BA the year before. I'd say both factored ultimately in the decision for this rating.

I was wonderin Dye, willl u be signing Jermaine in your franny? or will u let his FA flag fly?

[tazbk]

Wow, no Andre Either and no Nick Markakis means unauthentic. Magglio, Dye and Vlad all should not be on this list.

Ichiro well deserving of #1. And my boy Justin Upton is definitely deserving of that 2nd spot. The top 3 are dead on but yeah Nick and Andre should be rounding out that Top 5.

[jcabler24]

I thought Justin Upton was faster than that?