Madden NFL 11 Rookie Ratings

[IndyColts2]

Way to high! These guys are rookies make them earn 80+ OVR cap it at around there for the first couple picks and then spread it out!

[sniperhare]

Fans have Haden at 80.

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by HHHBigFan

I completely agree

I really don't think -5 across the board is even enough but then again I think that all ratings should be much more spread out to where each individual rating takes into account the full 100 point range and overall ratings would take in atleast 80% of that. Also, I do not think overall ratings should be judged on a scale that goes above 100 like they currently are. I feel that ratings should go up to 100 just because from a computing standpoint that makes more sense but I also feel that to get a 100 overall a player should need a 100 in each rating applicable to his position or atleast enough that when weighted by importance of the rating it averages out to above a 99.5. Such an overall scale would really allow differentiation of the players and then if it was truly represented on the field it would make a much better overall game.

[kcarr]

mcclain is only the second pick that the fans haven't upped by atleast a point overall and correct be if I am wrong but I don't think a single individual rating has been dropped on average by the fans yet has it?

[cdk10]

I've already have a problem with the ratings.

1. Trent Williams is more athletic than Okung. How does Okung have a higher speed and acc. rating??

2. Eric Berry only a 50 tackle rating?? Mays better have the same because Berry is just as good a tackler as Mays. And Earl Thomas better have a 40 or less.

Edit: Haden with a higher block shed and tackle rating than Berry????? I'm done...

[jbooc13]

So would a 50 ovrl on a 100 scale be an avrge player?

[IndyColts2]

Quote: Originally Posted by cdk10

I've already have a problem with the ratings. 1. Trent Williams is more athletic than Okung. How does Okung have a higher speed and acc. rating?? 2. Eric Berry only a 50 tackle rating?? Mays better have the same because Berry is just as good a tackler as Mays. And Earl Thomas better have a 40 or less. Edit: Haden with a higher block shed and tackle rating than Berry????? I'm done...

Dont forget Haden has a 60 STR and berry has a 55 STR

[jbooc13]

So would a 50 ovrl on a 100 scale be an average player?