Madden NFL 12 Rookie Ratings: Top Quarterbacks

[s38s38s]

Well as a gamer I'm happy. Though I wil admit when I created him, I had him at a 74 ovr with...77 SAC, 76 MAC, and 81 DAC.

[JerseySuave4]

Problem is they feel that just because someone was drafted higher than someone else they should be rated higher. Mallett should at worst be the 3rd best QB. Ponder, Kapernick, Dalton & Locker all ahead of him?!? Give me a break.

[damien6663]

I think they did a pretty decent job, i wouldnt mind seeing cam as a 75 as i feel like the is not the most "nfl ready" qb in the draft.

I also think a 71 for Mallet would be pretty fair.

Im just nit picking i think they hit qb ratings better then many other positions.

[gohogsfan14]

Im ok with Mallett's rating. Its not like hes going to play for a few years anyways...then it will be raised. Im just looking foward to watching him in preseason :P

I do think most of his character concerns were BS though

[bostonsports]

Did they just rate this based on where players were drafted? mallett is the 3rd best qb in the draft at the very least, imo he should be the highest rated because of how pro ready he is compared to gabbert and newton, but he was certainly more talented than kaepernick, ponder at the very minimum. Off the field issues are the only reason he fell.

[CatMan72]

Cam should be the highest rated based on the combination of all his skills, 77 seems fair.

[brettmickey]

Yeah I actually don't have many problems with these overalls. Could Mallett be a little higher? Sure, but that is about the only minor issue I see with these

[GaryT531]

I will boldly predect that Colin Kaepernick emerges as the best QB to come out of this class.