MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

[earp4530]

Thanks a lot. I like how they show their career statistics.

[metsfan4life1]

Damn, my mets, the As, Padres, orioles and Priates are the worst teams. With it in this order: Orioles, As, Pirates, padres, and the mets. Thanks for the video!

[metsfan4life1]

Quote: Originally Posted by econoodle

oh my, when RA Dickey is your 3rd highest rated player, things aint lookin' too good. Good to see D-Rob getting his ratings due.

Not to be rude, but dickens a great number four on a winning team. Look at his numbers the last two year. He's earned it and truthfully, Ryan V from the giants I think is a tad bit higher and he's only done it for one year(last) and dickey did it in 2010 and was still underrated. But Dickeys earned it. He's a competitor and he also got off to a terrible start last year!

[metsfan4life1]

Quote: Originally Posted by metsfan4life1

Not to be rude, but dickens a great number four on a winning team. Look at his numbers the last two year. He's earned it and truthfully, Ryan V from the giants I think is a tad bit higher and he's only done it for one year(last) and dickey did it in 2010 and was still underrated. But Dickeys earned it. He's a competitor and he also got off to a terrible start last year!

If he doesn't get off to such a bad start, you're talking about his ERA being just over 3.00! For a knuckleballer! I think his ERA was 3.28, if that's not a great number four starter on a winning team, then I don't know what is..

[metsfan4life1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rdogg1026

As a Mets fan, looking at the Top 9 for our team is so depressing...

But think! Based on bays last two years, he's overrated greatly. And Wright is underrated; one bad injury year should'nt make you become a B rated player, just in 2010 he put up pretty good numbers. I think we'll see Bay and Wright have great years in both reality and virtually! The demnisons will play a role in Bays home runs by far.

[ILiveForThis]

My two cents:

A-Rod not in the top nine for the Yanks.. shocking.
Hiroki Kuroda seems highly ranked for my liking.
Glad to see Matt Moore in for the Rays, well deserved.
Brett Lawrie rounds out the nine for the Jays, awesome. Sad when he left Milwaukee.
The White Sox are STACKED on the mound. Wow.
Prince Fielder ranked over Miguel Cabrera is different. Also, Jamey Carroll is the EIGHTH best player on the Twinkies. Need I say more?
Montero over Ackley is kinda bleh for me and the M's. I see that different, I feel the sample size is too small for Montero yet.
The Braves bullpen.. :S
Victorino the top position player for the Phils.. sounds right to me.
The Astros suck.
Shocked to see Beltran over the likes of Holliday, Berkman, and possibly even Freese. Freese should be in the top 9, imo.
Chris Young finally getting some love with his ratings.

[earp4530]

Quote: Originally Posted by metsfan4life1

If he doesn't get off to such a bad start, you're talking about his ERA being just over 3.00! For a knuckleballer! I think his ERA was 3.28, if that's not a great number four starter on a winning team, then I don't know what is..

I agree with the Dickey comment but the Mets weren't a winning team last year, going 76-85

[Nooooovak]

Millwood, Kelley, and Vargas are all rated higher than Dustin Ackley? Hmmmmm.