My first post was to try and avoid all of this but oh well, here we go...
Im not saying Romo is our savior and the best QB to ever play the game. I simply posted my opinion that I feel Romo was deserving of his rating and for some reason that was comical and
you(?) suggested a 71-72 overall I think it was? If that isn't a biased opinion I dont know what is. Heck, maybe mine is even a little biased. Maybe you can knock him down a point or two. But with the way many QBs are rated every year, (outside of Brady's under rating this year) I feel 91 is very fair.
Let me try to explain to you
why i feel Romo is very deserving of his rating...
Romo is 5th (4th among active QBs) in QB rating in NFL HISTORY only behind Aaron Rodgers, Peyton, Steve Young, and Rivers.
Romo is 6th (5th among active QBs) in pass completion % in NFL HISTORY.
Romo is 6th (20th in NFL HISTORY) among active QBs in comebacks.
Romo is 8th (31st in NFL HISTORY) among active QBs in TD's.
Romo is 10th among active QBs in passing yards, passes completed, and total yards.
Romo is 3rd (9th in NFL HISTORY) among active QBs in yards per pass attempt (4th and 3rd in adj yards/pass attempt)
Romo is 5th among active QBs in yards per passes completed.
Romo is 3rd (21st in NFL HISTORY) among active QBs in passing TD%.
Romo is 5th (4th among active QBs) in NFL HISTORY in net yards/pass attempt. (4th and 4th in adj net yards/pass attempt)
Romo doesnt have the highest 4th quarter QB rating in the NFL since he took over starter by accident.
Romo doesnt have great statistics that rank near the top year in and year out by accident.
Romo isnt voted in the top 100 every year by his opponents and other NFL stars by accident.
Im trying to
back my opinion with facts not comments such as "put in any 2nd stringer and youll see an improvement". Dallas fans have witnessed that when Romo has had to sit out games during his career that is not the case.
How could you be fine with Romo being a 91 if Brady was rated higher but any second stringer would out perform Romo and bring better results to the Cowboys? I think that clearly shows that your opinion is very biased by basically contradicting yourself.
And where did i argue that Romo should only be 2 below Brady? I never said anything about Brady's rating.
I totally agree with you that Romo shouldn't only be 2 "points" below Brady. That isn't because Romo is overrated, that is because Brady is underrated. You cant under rate everyone else because one guy is under rated.
Donny clearly sees this at EA year in and year out that Romo is not a bum as you suggest, constantly ranking Romo in the top 10 at the QB position. I am very happy he isn't blinded by the Romo hate as his opinion is what matters when it comes to ratings for Madden.
Dallas fans will miss Romo when he is gone and many people will see how talented he is when Dallas is stuck trying to find another QB if we dont start grooming one soon.
Everyone has an opinion though and that is yours, ill respect it, just dont quite understand it.