My all time rosters

[bhrangerfan0809]

Alright, i've been working on some all time rosters which are basically compilations of each teams all time greats (this does include if someone played his majority of career playing with a team that is now defunct and went on to become another team - such as Walter Johnson being put on the Twins) I've finished all of the AL's starting fielders but not all of their bullpens. I've had limited progression on NL teams, i'm currently on the NL East, although i have finished the Cubs starting fielders. So far, these appearances seem pretty well done to me, and i would love for all of the feedback possible via this thread.

The name for the file is SLIMS ALL TIME ROSTER and is now on sportsconnect roster vault.

also take note that any players whose number is retired and is not already in the game will have a different number than they actually did when they played (Mantle for example).

I put a lot of work into this and used the Neyer/James guide to pitchers to get the pitcher's repertoire correctly. Some AL east pitchers may not have the exact pitches though. Anyway, check it out and comment. Thanks.

[animal829]

Re: My all time rosters

Can you please post your rosters here,for those of us that don't have access to the vault. Thank you.

[bhrangerfan0809]

Re: My all time rosters

Can you please post your rosters here,for those of us that don't have access to the vault. Thank you.

I'll see what i can do. And for those with access to sportsconnect, please download the rosters and critique them in this thread.

[bhrangerfan0809]

Re: My all time rosters

ok here's a more updated one than the one currently in the roster vault. It has all starting fielders through the NL east and the Brewers, Astros, Cubs, and Reds starting 9.

[td7]

Re: My all time rosters

ok here's a more updated one than the one currently in the roster vault. It has all starting fielders through the NL east and the Brewers, Astros, Cubs, and Reds starting 9.

I actually think these rosters are pretty good, great job man, there are afew players not in there ie...Pete Rose for the Reds but, its still a good set.

[bhrangerfan0809]

Re: My all time rosters

Check 3rd base.

[TimmyT34]

Re: My all time rosters

I'd like to dl these but I can't find them on sportsconnect. I see the slim current roster but not the alltime ones. What page are they on please?

[bhrangerfan0809]

Re: My all time rosters

I uploaded them yesterday or the day before, so u should check by date.

[rworth88]

Re: My all time rosters

Good job on this!!!

[animal829]

Re: My all time rosters

Rosters look good, Thank you for posting them here.

[SethMurphy]

Re: My all time rosters

you made Louisiana Lightnin Ron Guidry a righthanded pitcher, he was a lefty, otherwise just diving into them

[bhrangerfan0809]

Re: My all time rosters

Ok thank you much for that bit of info. This is what this thread is for. It will be corrected in the next update.

[CWSpalehoseCWS]

Re: My all time rosters

Not bad but there are some errors for the White Sox if you ask me. All these comments are meant to be suggestions, and are not meant to be offensive.

- 3B Lorenzo Ortiz is a fake player and needs to be replaced.
- Alexei Ramirez and Alex Rios should be no where near the 25-man roster.
- I would get rid of Chet Lemon. Best White Sox CF? Go with Fielder Jones. Led them to their 1st WS win and was a good hitter for the "Hitless Wonders". If you want a player a little earlier/modern then go with Jim Landis, as he'd be the fan favorite.
- Where is Harold Baines? He needs to be the RF without a doubt.
- There are arguments that can be made to put Collins, Fisk, and Jackson on different teams, even though it pains me to say that...
- Just a thought but you could go either way with the backup catcher in Sherm Lollar or adding Ray Schalk. If you drop Fisk you can have both.
- Some stances and deliveries are off at a quick glance.

Pitching looks good. I disagree with a few of the guys, but it's not like the guys you picked aren't Sox greats. IMO, I would get rid of Thornton Lee & Tommy John and add Doc White and Mark Buehrle just because they did more for the White Sox over their careers (both WS winners). Maybe even add Bobby Jenks and Roberto Hernandez too. Jenks is on pace to pass some of the Sox leaders if he stays for a few more years.

If you want what I use as the Sox all-time roster just let me know and I'll post it.

[bhrangerfan0809]

Re: My all time rosters

As I said in the first post, these are just the starting 9 fielders as of now. Some teams have more pitchers than others, but this is not the final roster. right now I'm finishing up the starting 9 for every team and then the bench, rotations, and 25 man roster.

[bhrangerfan0809]

Re: My all time rosters

Not bad but there are some errors for the White Sox if you ask me. All these comments are meant to be suggestions, and are not meant to be offensive.

- 3B Lorenzo Ortiz is a fake player and needs to be replaced.
- Alexei Ramirez and Alex Rios should be no where near the 25-man roster.
- I would get rid of Chet Lemon. Best White Sox CF? Go with Fielder Jones. Led them to their 1st WS win and was a good hitter for the "Hitless Wonders". If you want a player a little earlier/modern then go with Jim Landis, as he'd be the fan favorite.
- Where is Harold Baines? He needs to be the RF without a doubt.
- There are arguments that can be made to put Collins, Fisk, and Jackson on different teams, even though it pains me to say that...
- Just a thought but you could go either way with the backup catcher in Sherm Lollar or adding Ray Schalk. If you drop Fisk you can have both.
- Some stances and deliveries are off at a quick glance.

Pitching looks good. I disagree with a few of the guys, but it's not like the guys you picked aren't Sox greats. IMO, I would get rid of Thornton Lee & Tommy John and add Doc White and Mark Buehrle just because they did more for the White Sox over their careers (both WS winners). Maybe even add Bobby Jenks and Roberto Hernandez too. Jenks is on pace to pass some of the Sox leaders if he stays for a few more years.

If you want what I use as the Sox all-time roster just let me know and I'll post it.

I would love if you could give me tips for the batting stances or pitching stances. I have limited resources when it comes to older footage of batters and their stances, likewise for pitchers. And i would be fine if you posted your all time team, and since there are so many fake players, i could create several that in my opinion would not make the team in the minors (if they received recommendation to be on the all time team). Any extra help is fine, since i'm doing this roster by myself.