College Football Magazines (Top QB's)

[Bootzilla]

I always look forward to this time of year when the college and pro annuals start to hit newsstands. I always look at the college mags to see if their ratings and EA's ratings are similar. I also get familiar with programs I'm not that familiar with in anticipation of playing NCAA football. Lindy's has the following as their top 25 QB's.

1. Kellen Moore- Boise St.
2. Ryan Mallett- Arkansas
3. Jake Locker- Washington
4. Case Keenum- Houston
5. Terrelle Pryor- Ohio St
6. Andrew Luck- Stanford
7. Jerrod Johnson- Texas A&M
8. Greg McElroy- Alabama
9. Josh Nesbitt- Ga.Tech
10. Christian Ponder- Fla.St.
11. Blaine Gabbert- Missouri
12. Andy Dalton- TCU
13. Colin Kaepernick- Nevada
14. Tyrod Taylor- Va. Tech
15. Landry Jones- Oklahoma
16. Russell Wilson- NC State
17. Robert Griffin- Baylor
18. Jacory Harris- Miami
19. Ricky Dobbs- Navy
20. Scott Tolzien- Wisconsin
21. Matt Barkley- USC
22. Ricky Stanzi- Iowa
23. Nick Foles- Arizona
24. Tom Savage- Rutgers
25. Zach Collaros- Cincinnati

What do you guys think? Who should be added or eliminated? Who will be rated highest in NCAA?

[Watson]

I think that this should go in the CFB forum.


But that's just me.

[Bootzilla]

Quote: Originally Posted by WatsonTiger

I think that this should go in the CFB forum. But that's just me.

Why would I ask guys in the CFB forum about how players should be/will be rated in a video game? Seems applicable in this forum.

But that's just me.

[Gosens6]

I think what he means is this will turn into a huge college football debate, but on the topic subject, I say Jake Locker should be ranked first and Matt Barkley removed from the list.

[Wrec86 Ag]

My guess

1. Kellen Moore- Boise St.- 93
2. Ryan Mallett- Arkansas- 96
3. Jake Locker- Washington-97
4. Case Keenum- Houston-94
5. Terrelle Pryor- Ohio St-94 (spd around 90)
6. Andrew Luck- Stanford-92
7. Jerrod Johnson- Texas A&M-92 (spd around 88)
8. Greg McElroy- Alabama-93
9. Josh Nesbitt- Ga.Tech-91 (spd around 90)
10. Christian Ponder- Fla.St.- 90
11. Blaine Gabbert- Missouri- 88
12. Andy Dalton- TCU-88
13. Colin Kaepernick- Nevada-87
14. Tyrod Taylor- Va. Tech- 86
15. Landry Jones- Oklahoma-88
16. Russell Wilson- NC State-86
17. Robert Griffin- Baylor-88
18. Jacory Harris- Miami- 86
19. Ricky Dobbs- Navy 86
20. Scott Tolzien- Wisconsin 85
21. Matt Barkley- USC 86
22. Ricky Stanzi- Iowa-88
23. Nick Foles- Arizona- 86
24. Tom Savage- Rutgers- 85
25. Zach Collaros- Cincinnati- 85

[Watson]

Quote: Originally Posted by Gosens6

I think what he means is this will turn into a huge college football debate

yup

[Thaen]

jerrod johnson rank 7 christian ponder rank 10???

gabbert @11??? even though i love landry jones i think he is gonna be real good i still couldn't place him in the top 15 until he improves on his turnover problems. no bj daniels too i dont like this list too much

[bh446066]

Holy cr@p, Lindy's is out? I'm going to Barnes and Nobles right after work...