Great thread topic. In another thread I actually ranked 2K11 behind 2K14. Since snagging 2K14 i've been reluctant to popping in 2K11 to see how it holds up. Why? Because with 2K12 and 2K13, each time I did that I never looked back and kept playing 2K11. Thats how much I love the feel of that game.
Well...tonight after giving 2K11 a whirl again...I just have to say, DAYMN!!! What a classic game. 2K14 (and 2K12/13 for that matter) is a very good game. With several advantages over 2K11 like:
1. Fast Breaks
2. User controlled bounce pass
3. User controlled fancy pass
4. Updated Rosters
5. More animations (this also can be a negative)
6. Dunk speed - (2k11 has the slower dunks)
But after that...I can't think of much more 14 does better than 11. The game speed in 14 seems very fast compared to 11 - yet fast players in 11 stand out a bit more.
IF 11 had a user controlled bounce pass and improved speed differential (Centers shouldn't always be able to get back so fast on D) on fast breaks - then I would be happy with 11 to this day. Its not like the fast breaks are bad - they're mostly secondary breaks. The rebounding, spacing, and defense in 2K11 is the best its ever been.
Regarding #5 above - I love all of the different animations in 2K14. Its crazy how much is crammed into this game. That said, there are times when I feel like I'm fighting some of the animations (especially on d) or fighting to get control. In 2K11 - the balance is just right. I don't feel restricted and I don't feel like the animations get repetitive. Make sense?