Houston Astros Player Ratings

[onegroove7]

MLB The Show is expecting all these guys to continue dominating and did not consider how they will perform without cheating...

Alex Bregman 97 overall
Jose Altuve 92 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home)
Yordan Alvarez 85 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home)
Yuli Gurriel 79 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home)
Carlos Correa 85 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home)

I don't like editing rosters... I want to play the game as is... but in this game they are still a favorite to win the World Series... Yikes

[Caulfield]

Quote: Originally Posted by onegroove7

MLB The Show is expecting all these guys to continue dominating and did not consider how they will perform without cheating... Alex Bregman 97 overall Jose Altuve 92 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) Yordan Alvarez 85 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) Yuli Gurriel 79 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) Carlos Correa 85 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) I don't like editing rosters... I want to play the game as is... but in this game they are still a favorite to win the World Series... Yikes

SDS just goes by stats and I think that's part of the problem with the scandal; you dont know what's real and what's for sale. whenever the season gets under way and there's enough data to justify updated ratings, we'll get them. for me personally, the cover-up was worse than the crime and I expect Houston to play well enough to win at least 85-90 games, if not more. like all things, time will tell

[onegroove7]

Quote: Originally Posted by Caulfield

SDS just goes by stats and I think that's part of the problem with the scandal; you dont know what's real and what's for sale. whenever the season gets under way and there's enough data to justify updated ratings, we'll get them. for me personally, the cover-up was worse than the crime and I expect Houston to play well enough to win at least 85-90 games, if not more. like all things, time will tell

85-90 seems about right to me. They can pitch and are still a good team. I didn't see anyone but the Astros win the AL West in The Show 19 though. Looks like I can expect the same this year from these rosters.

[Jeffrey Smith]

Started my Jays franchise last night and edited all the 2017 Astros still in Houston. I lowered discipline and vision by 10 points each. I didn’t touch newer players. It lowered their overalls a couple points but nothing major. I should sim a month or two just to see how they perform. Maybe later tonight.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Jeffrey Smith]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jeffrey Smith

Started my Jays franchise last night and edited all the 2017 Astros still in Houston. I lowered discipline and vision by 10 points each. I didn’t touch newer players. It lowered their overalls a couple points but nothing major. I should sim a month or two just to see how they perform. Maybe later tonight. Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

I was gonna edit Marisnik now on the Mets but his vision and discipline are already pretty bad.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Rmiok222]

I’m just mind blown how naquin has 99 arm strength. And I’m a Tribe fan. Lol


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Caulfield]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rmiok222

I’m just mind blown how naquin has 99 arm strength. And I’m a Tribe fan. Lol Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

I bet they used his CF Held % of 50% against the league average of 44.3% in CF. if they had used his RF Held % of 46.3% versus the RF average of 46.8% they would have rated his arm strength more accurately IMO

[PrettyT11]

Quote: Originally Posted by onegroove7

MLB The Show is expecting all these guys to continue dominating and did not consider how they will perform without cheating... Alex Bregman 97 overall Jose Altuve 92 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) Yordan Alvarez 85 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) Yuli Gurriel 79 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) Carlos Correa 85 overall (Homebody - Performs Better at Home) I don't like editing rosters... I want to play the game as is... but in this game they are still a favorite to win the World Series... Yikes

Altuve is not a better player at home. In the two years the cheating was confirmed to have happened his stats were far more impressive on the road. That only helps the story of the players saying Jose was not involved.