New Sounds of the show bug

[ARoid1313]

Default stadium sound effects now play overtop any assigned custom track. Example you assign the real Yankees homerun song with siren, it plays but the default siren in the game will still play which fights with the custom version. Same with the strikeout whistle for the Yankees, as the default version plays overtop the authentic one I’ve assigned .

This used to be a bug years ago so something must have reintroduced it. Please fix if possible in the next patch


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[UNIT180]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

The default siren is actually very accurate to real life...What I did I delayed the naughty by nature song by five seconds and added the chimes to it...Sounds perfect...So do the custom track with no siren and boom its perfect!

[ARoid1313]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

its personal preference and unfortunately its a bug. The pc richards whistle sounds horrible when compared to the authentic sound. They shouldnt play if you mapped custom sounds

[JustSteve]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

FYI, it's not a bug and it's not new. It's a music cue. It replaces the shipping home run music with your home run music. What you're looking for is a sfx replacement which we don't currently support. It wouldn't be a bad idea for you guys to make a SOTS wish list for future enhancements. No promises but we would definitely look at your feedback and top requests.

[CujoMatty]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

The overlapping sounds isn’t new either. It’s been like that since launch but fortunately it doesn’t happen that often and that’s probably why you didn’t notice it before. As for the homerun music I think we will have to make them with just the song. In the past we added home run horns or other stadium sounds for authenticity but now SDS has included a lot of them and they aren’t necessary and moreover actually make them sound crappy.

As for the other stadium sounds overlapping it’s because the slots for cheers jeers chants or yells are intended for just that purposely by SDS. If the sounds we included in the packs were just yells and things like that it wouldn’t sound bad if say someone yelled”cmon ump” and it overlapped the inning music. That is how SDS intended those slots be used. Lowlight and myself utilized those slots to further the authenticity and individuality of each stadium so for example Toronto plays the Day-o chant or the Adams family organ multiple times a game in real life so we added those as chants to add the authenticity to the stadium. Unfortunately if those overlap inning music or stolen base music etc it sounds terrible. What we need in the future hopefully is dedicated slots for user generated stadium sounds that won’t cue overlapping with anything else. I will start a wish list.

[ARoid1313]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

FYI, it's not a bug and it's not new. It's a music cue. It replaces the shipping home run music with your home run music. What you're looking for is a sfx replacement which we don't currently support. It wouldn't be a bad idea for you guys to make a SOTS wish list for future enhancements. No promises but we would definitely look at your feedback and top requests.

thanks for the response
I swear I never had the default sfx stuff play last year when using custom HR & strikeout tracks but if this is the way it is designed then its a strange occurrence.
Perhaps the quick fix for this year would be to disable sfx if a custom track is assigned to that context.

[dazzelle]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

it wouldn't be a bad idea for you guys to make a SOTS wish list for future enhancements. No promises but we would definitely look at your feedback and top requests.

Please please please add slots for hitting and defensive lineups or for there to be a way to disable it , the music when they are displayed is far to loud so it would be great if we could set all our music to the same level.

Sounds for pitchers when they are on the mound, i have tested the last few years and chants and yells do not trigger while the pitcher is on the mound, they will somtimes play in the innings breack.

Bring back longer walk ups and inning breaks ect. so the best feature of the game can be utilized to its fullest. Would also love a full 7th innings stretch with some great shots of the crowd and ballpark.

Also great work on the last patch, i seem to be able to hear a lot more of the default crowd yells and sounds, whistles ect. .
Any chance that the default team chants sounds could be boosted, they are far to soft for crowd chants. I have posted some clips in the stadium volume thread to compare them with chants added via sots.

Thank you.

[dazzelle]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

thanks for the response
I swear I never had the default sfx stuff play last year when using custom HR & strikeout tracks but if this is the way it is designed then its a strange occurrence.
Perhaps the quick fix for this year would be to disable sfx if a custom track is assigned to that context.

I was messing around in 17, just to see if i was remembering correctly, even though it was only a few weeks ago since i played 17, to see if default sfx played when using sots.
I never heard any of the default sfx play in spots where i use sounds from sots, i only tried a few teams ,nyy, rangers and a few others. Wasn't sure what other teams would have sounds as i never hear them while playing them because i have always used sots.

I still hope this can be patched.

[ataranto2]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

I was messing around in 17, just to see if i was remembering correctly, even though it was only a few weeks ago since i played 17, to see if default sfx played when using sots.
I never heard any of the default sfx play in spots where i use sounds from sots, i only tried a few teams ,nyy, rangers and a few others. Wasn't sure what other teams would have sounds as i never hear them while playing them because i have always used sots.

I still hope this can be patched.

Default Sfx never overlapped with my SOTS homerun sirens in 17 for me as well. The default siren at Progressive field sounds nothing like the real one, so removing the SOTS version isn’t a very good option. This needs to be patched.

[muaaahh]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

thanks for the response
Perhaps the quick fix for this year would be to disable sfx if a custom track is assigned to that context.

...it seems so simple and basic! Next patch would be nothing than necessary this fix.

Until The Show 18 release I was playing MLB The Show 16 and I had no issue with it. The Cujomatty pack worked perfectly.

[Juzbee]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

...it seems so simple and basic! Next patch would be nothing than necessary this fix.

Until The Show 18 release I was playing MLB The Show 16 and I had no issue with it. The Cujomatty pack worked perfectly.

You are correct - MLB 16 had it correct out of the box. MLB 17 screwed it up but was patched to work as well as 16 did. MLB 18 has screwed it up yet again, and the Twitch stream last week gave the impression that there will be one more patch. I hope they fix this for good.

[ARoid1313]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

anyone notice if this still happens after the latest patch?

[lowlighthabit]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

FYI, it's not a bug and it's not new. It's a music cue. It replaces the shipping home run music with your home run music. What you're looking for is a sfx replacement which we don't currently support. It wouldn't be a bad idea for you guys to make a SOTS wish list for future enhancements. No promises but we would definitely look at your feedback and top requests.

Well, the first thing I would suggest is allowing the default SFX for defensive/offensive events like Stikeout, HR, etc. to fall into the Defensive Music option so we can choose to turn it on or off. Seems like a simple enough fix.

[muaaahh]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

anyone notice if this still happens after the latest patch?

Its a shame. Not at all.

[Cycloniac]

Re: New Sounds of the show bug

Has anyone noticed that sometimes, walkups will play and sometimes they won't?