"The best part of the game is the replay value. You'll want to take your team deep into the years, and the online play mode makes the replay better. It's easily the best baseball game when it comes to franchise mode and gameplay."
"Overall this game isn't anything above mediocre. It might have succeeded as an additional mode to FIFA 2005, but as a standalone without online play, a faulty multiplayer, and no depth, I cannot honestly recommend it. Hopefully next year EA will put some money into this and make it worthy of the Street brand."