Users Online Now: 1954  |  July 5, 2022
ryan36's Blog
How do you judge a game 
Posted on August 4, 2010 at 01:03 PM.
As a fairly casual gamer, I ask is it fun? That's really about it.
-A game is not fun, if I absolutely can't do something that can be done in real life.
-I keep notice players reacting, moving, and playing like they know what's coming,
or are simply way too good at any one thing
-The balance is way too off.
-Or there're a whole bunch of meters, power ups, completely diff. mechanics for
something in my view should happen naturally (Unable to hit an HR in 2k with
contact swing)
-Or if too much control is taken away from me, that interrupts a flow (pickoffs in
the Show, Fight for Fumble in Madden)...basically if a game has to "generate" a
result by some means other than natural gameplay.
As a franchise player, I ask it is close to realistic?
-Is the trade AI ok
-Is progression severely broken?
-How does the game handle free agents?
Things I don't notice , even though they could ruin a game for some...
-CPU/CPU trades being horribly lopsided (I never look)
-The ball size in Madden, the wrong headband in NBA 2k, stuff like that
-Bad drafts, I never knew 2k5 had a bug
Graphics help a lot...a nice looking/sounding game goes a long way with me

What about you? What do you notice/not notice in games?
Comments
# 1 shadthedad @ Aug 4
The game has to feel ilke it's viewed when watching not playing. Once again the game has to feel like it feels when watching not being played.
 
# 2 DGMikeBarker @ Aug 4
Put it in a category of simulation or arcade; then fun or not fun. I think most people want a fun simulation.
 
# 3 BurghFan @ Feb 10
First I like my games to be smooth and at a fairly natural pace. I don't want to be forced to sit through some auto replay after every play (that can't be turned off) while mashing the X button because I just want to move on to the next play. Secondly, physics and probability are important. I don't want to see things that blatantly defy the laws of physics and I don't want to see highly improbable things happening on a regular basis. Thirdly, I look at presentation and layout. Are the menus easy to navigate and arranged in a logical manner? Is it easy to find what I'm looking for? Are the stats easily readable and sortable? To me those are the most important aspects of any sports game.
 
ryan36
36
ryan36's Blog Categories
ryan36's Screenshots (0)

ryan36 does not have any albums to display.
More ryan36's Friends
Recent Visitors
The last 10 visitor(s) to this Arena were:

ryan36's Arena has had 33,127 visits