NCAAF should have draft stock

[Madwolf]

I was just thinking, why doesn't NCAAF have draft stock? When the players get to Madden everything is pretty much random.

IMO NCAAF should determine a players draft stock week by week. There should be like Kiper's Big Board and you can see how your players improve or decline week to week.

Not only would this mean that they're actual performance has an effect on where they're taken in the draft when importing to Madden, but it would also tell you whether a player was considering going pro, and let you guage how much effort it would take to talk him into returning for another year, or if it was even worth it.

IMO this would add a whole lot more excitement to the game, and a new level of depth to both NCAAF and Madden.

[Gosens6]

Wow that's a great idea actually, CH2K8 had this and it added a lot more depth to the game. Hopefully this is something added into Dynasty mode this year

[steelers1]

I love this idea. It would get rid of the case of the 87 overall player deciding to leave early and when you load it in Madden he's not even in the draft class.

It would obviously make NCAA more in depth. If you get a reputation for developing NFL talent, it could help you in recruiting, and it would allow for a team to be "Linebacker U" or whatever.

It would also fix the problem of boring NCAA to Madden imports. First of all, you would know a little more of what to expect instead of complete randomness, but moreso it would allow for sleeper. Maybe a QB who was highly rated but was a backup and didn't play much or what injured would be tagged as a late rounder, but could turn out to be a really good player. You would also get busts because of 'system guys' who might have great stats but really aren't that great.

[j_tinkler21]

Quote: Originally Posted by Madwolf

I was just thinking, why doesn't NCAAF have draft stock? When the players get to Madden everything is pretty much random. IMO NCAAF should determine a players draft stock week by week. There should be like Kiper's Big Board and you can see how your players improve or decline week to week. Not only would this mean that they're actual performance has an effect on where they're taken in the draft when importing to Madden, but it would also tell you whether a player was considering going pro, and let you guage how much effort it would take to talk him into returning for another year, or if it was even worth it. IMO this would add a whole lot more excitement to the game, and a new level of depth to both NCAAF and Madden.

Awesome, awesome idea.

Edit to add: Especially with the emphasis on potential in this year's edition.

[da ThRONe]

Yeah I hate having a QB break every college record know to man be a 99 in every passing rating and come into Madden as a undrafted free agent and a 47 overall.

[RamblinWreck21]

Great Idea.

[da ThRONe]

And if they would factor in style of offensives that would be great too.

[Gosens6]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Yeah I hate having a QB break every college record know to man be a 99 in every passing rating and come into Madden as a undrafted free agent and a 47 overall.

Colt Brennan anyone?