ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

[scoman]

Well i was getting ready to go out to the local EB to get ESPN baseball,but from what im reading with the wild pitch bug,amoung others,i really have had to step back and reavaluate. So whats the verdict, which one is the best,i really havent read about MVP bugs so i really dont know yet,any help would be appreciated.

[p2xgamers]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

Well i was getting ready to go out to the local EB to get ESPN baseball,but from what im reading with the wild pitch bug,amoung others,i really have had to step back and reavaluate. So whats the verdict, which one is the best,i really havent read about MVP bugs so i really dont know yet,any help would be appreciated.

I like ESPN better but if you were a huge fan of the style gameplay MVP 04 had, then go with that game. Though your best bet would be to buy both for $50 total.

[p2xgamers]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

Well i was getting ready to go out to the local EB to get ESPN baseball,but from what im reading with the wild pitch bug,amoung others,i really have had to step back and reavaluate. So whats the verdict, which one is the best,i really havent read about MVP bugs so i really dont know yet,any help would be appreciated.

I like ESPN better but if you were a huge fan of the style gameplay MVP 04 had, then go with that game. Though your best bet would be to buy both for $50 total.

[Afroman4ever]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

Just bought 2k5..I already had MVP 05...MVP is BY FAR the better game...2k5 has some very weird things goin on topped off by the SLAM ZONE...Fielding is weird...throwing animations are weird. Outfielders look weird when waiting for a fly ball to drop outta the sky. The camera angles are weird. I'm just not impressed with 2k5...IMO it was/is a waste of $21.50

[Afroman4ever]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

Just bought 2k5..I already had MVP 05...MVP is BY FAR the better game...2k5 has some very weird things goin on topped off by the SLAM ZONE...Fielding is weird...throwing animations are weird. Outfielders look weird when waiting for a fly ball to drop outta the sky. The camera angles are weird. I'm just not impressed with 2k5...IMO it was/is a waste of $21.50

[maddenman420]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005



Funny, that is the same thing I thought about MVP this season!

[maddenman420]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005



Funny, that is the same thing I thought about MVP this season!

[p2xgamers]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

Just bought 2k5..I already had MVP 05...MVP is BY FAR the better game...2k5 has some very weird things goin on topped off by the SLAM ZONE...Fielding is weird...throwing animations are weird. Outfielders look weird when waiting for a fly ball to drop outta the sky. The camera angles are weird. I'm just not impressed with 2k5...IMO it was/is a waste of $21.50

Well since you haven't played MLB 2k5 your opinion really doesn't count. That's like me comparing my 32" TV to my other 60" TV. My opinion on that wouldn't count because I lied, I don't have a 60" TV.

I wouldn't of said this if not for you mentioning Slam Zone considering you can turn it off. (I know, such a huge effort going into the menu and turning it to "Off") I'm in no way a 2k5 fanboy but I really hate it when other fanboys put down the competitor and lie about them playing the game when they haven't.

[p2xgamers]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

Just bought 2k5..I already had MVP 05...MVP is BY FAR the better game...2k5 has some very weird things goin on topped off by the SLAM ZONE...Fielding is weird...throwing animations are weird. Outfielders look weird when waiting for a fly ball to drop outta the sky. The camera angles are weird. I'm just not impressed with 2k5...IMO it was/is a waste of $21.50

Well since you haven't played MLB 2k5 your opinion really doesn't count. That's like me comparing my 32" TV to my other 60" TV. My opinion on that wouldn't count because I lied, I don't have a 60" TV.

I wouldn't of said this if not for you mentioning Slam Zone considering you can turn it off. (I know, such a huge effort going into the menu and turning it to "Off") I'm in no way a 2k5 fanboy but I really hate it when other fanboys put down the competitor and lie about them playing the game when they haven't.

[Blzer]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

p2x, he said he bought it.

[Blzer]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

p2x, he said he bought it.

[Erratic]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

i think it depends if you plan on playing online much... if you do, then go with 2K5 because Mvp has forced 5 inning ranked games...

I also don't like the hitting in MVP or the fielding meters in general either...

[Erratic]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

i think it depends if you plan on playing online much... if you do, then go with 2K5 because Mvp has forced 5 inning ranked games...

I also don't like the hitting in MVP or the fielding meters in general either...

[p2xgamers]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

p2x, he said he bought it.

I know that's what he said but unless he didn't do anything in the game he would know that you can turn off slam zone so it's not a big deal and the camera can be changed too. That's why I said that he's lying.

[p2xgamers]

Re: ESPN MLB 2K5 vs MVP 2005

p2x, he said he bought it.

I know that's what he said but unless he didn't do anything in the game he would know that you can turn off slam zone so it's not a big deal and the camera can be changed too. That's why I said that he's lying.