05-18-2009, 08:07 PM
|
#5
|
All Star
OVR: 21
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 6,220
|
Re: NFL2K1 Appreciation Thread....
NFL2K1 was a great game; it was the last non-Madden game I think my friends really got into. While I acknowledge it's pushing the football genre forward, I think that the primary reason was it was the first online football game. I think Madden '03 took that formula and factored it x10. That was right when Madden's popularity was at a fever-pitch, with weekend tournaments sprouting everywhere and people playing the game non-stop, either at all night parties or online. If the Tiburon crew didn't completely screw up the formula with Madden '04 who knows where the title would've gone.
Imo NFL2K5 really became the game that was ahead of it's time because it excelled in so many areas that are still benchmarks today - in part because of the ineptness of Tiburon, but also in part because the 2K crew seemed to have a grasp of where football titles needed to go. Presentation, OL/DL interaction, DB/WR interaction, QB play, etc. were just a few of the areas where the game was way ahead of it's time. Some of those ideas were refined some in APF, and of course APF plays better but don't think it had the impact 2K5 had across the board. If 2K5 had been able to progress naturally instead of being cut off at the knees by exclusivity, I can only imagine where the title would be now. Think about the things that would be more refined now:
- like VIP which was ideal for football games/scouting opponents. If they could've grew in a way to replicate offensive/defensive player placement it would've been like playing a human opponent
- maximum tackling; Madden's STILL playing catch up
- all team uniforms and the years the teams wore them. At default
There's a lot I'm not thinking of, but think those are some of the reasons I think 2K5 was the more impactful football game, and perhaps the one game that impacted every other sports game across the board
__________________
HBO's "The Wire" should rank as one of the top 10 shows EVER on tv - period
XBL gamertag: d0meBreaker22 (that's a zero)
congrats Steelers, city of Pittsburgh, and Steeler Nation - SIX TIME WORLD CHAMPS
|
|
|