Madden NFL 11 Full Player Ratings: Miami Dolphins and New York Jets

[DaCarver13]

Henne is the real deal.
Sanchez, not yet convinced.

[warrior7807]

Quote: Originally Posted by iBlievN5

bess is not equal to cotchery. cotchery has had 4 consecutive seasons with 800 yds or more receiving. anyway, holistically the jets have a better core. their top 3 can all start for a plethora of teams, your top 3 can't. only marshall.

notice how i said in the current offensive players. this Means the QB also. Meaning I am taking what NY;s WR have done with Sanchez and Miami's WR's with Henne. I could have explained that better.That is, after all, what we are comparing. Theres no doubt that Cotchery has had a much better career up to this point, but based on the current offensive systems both teams run, they are more equal than anything else.

[Maelstrom-XIII]

Cotchery is a beast...as an NC State alum, I had the pleasure of a year or two of him and Philip Rivers lighting it up...I'd say that he is a much better receiver than he gets credit for. Sure hands, good route running, but he doesn't have elite speed...

Not too sure about Bess, but (call me biased, go wolfpack!) I give the nod to Cotchery...of course, I don't really like the Jets, but...

[iBlievN5]

Quote: Originally Posted by warrior7807

notice how i said in the current offensive players. this Means the QB also. Meaning I am taking what NY;s WR have done with Sanchez and Miami's WR's with Henne. I could have explained that better.That is, after all, what we are comparing. Theres no doubt that Cotchery has had a much better career up to this point, but based on the current offensive systems both teams run, they are more equal than anything else.

that makes no sense. but w/e you win. go fins, since that's all you want to hear.

[dan77733]

At first glance, am I the only one that cant figure out Dolphins FB Lousaka Polite is rated 91 and Ricky Williams is only an 87 despite rushing for over 1100 yards and 11 TD's???

[a4reak]

Quote: Originally Posted by DaCarver13

Henne is the real deal. Sanchez, not yet convinced.

What success has Henne had?

[Johnny "Too Tall"]

Quote: Originally Posted by dan77733

At first glance, am I the only one that cant figure out Dolphins FB Lousaka Polite is rated 91 and Ricky Williams is only an 87 despite rushing for over 1100 yards and 11 TD's???

I think Ratings are only relevant to their specific position. Essentially it would be like comparing the ratings of a CB to that of a safety. Polite's rating is in comparison to other Fb's, Williams to other HB's.

That being said, I think Williams should be around a 91 92 himself.

[warrior7807]

Quote: Originally Posted by iBlievN5

that makes no sense. but w/e you win. go fins, since that's all you want to hear.

tell me how that doesn't make sense? Why would we compare what Cotch did in 2007 with a completely different team and FO. Other than pointing out the obvious, cotchery had some very good seasons, there is nothing to pull from that to compare the two. I would think that consistency would bring about a better debate.