Which QB to pick??? Help!

[burnum]

I'm playing a pass-heavy offense, mostly using short/medium passes. I'm in desperate need of a new QB and I'm in position to draft either of the following 2 prospects:

QB 1:
8.1 adjusted grade (7.1 grade)
6-2, 215
very high bars all over the place (almost every bar is completely filled after scouting), except for 'timing' which is average and 'Third Down Passing' which is about 3/4 filled.

Style: Long Passes
Leadership: 0
Intelligence: 47
Personality: 38
Character Red Flag
Volatility: 24
Combine: 44 Sole, 4.45 dash, 18 reps, 7.08 agi, 9-0 broad, 78 position, 32% dev.
Scout ('Excellent' with QBs) says he's underrated.


QB 2:
7.2 adjusted grade (6.3 grade)
6-4, 228
low to medium bars all over the place
Style: Short Passes (which fits my Offensive Style)
Leadership: 67
Intelligence: 91
Personality: 19
Volatility: 96
Combine: 54 sole, 4.44 dash, 13 reps, 7.57 agility, 9-3 broad, 91 position, 37% dev.
Scout ('Excellent' with QBs) says he's very underrated.


QB 1 has clearly the better bars and, on the first look seems the superior prospect. QB 2 has great 'intangibles' and might be a sleeper who could turn out better than his bars suggest.

I'm really not an expert, so please help me which QB I should pick as the future of my franchise!!!

[Julio Riddols]

QB1 wins, IMO. Still don't believe there is a consensus about what exactly the red flag means, but thats the only negative about him, IMO.

[bighouserulez]

Yeah too many signs of big red bars on the QB1.

[MIJB#19]

QB1 has the superior agility score and also shows a stronger arm. The Sole score seems to be up in the air with the wide margin in intelligence. I'd prefer QB1, but wouldn't mind settling for QB2.

[burnum]

Alright, I picked QB 1. He looks promising (31/76) and QB 2 went off the board one pick after mine. He looks like a bust (16/31) but it's still early...

Edit: After camp QB1 is up to 38/76 and QB2 is up to 17/40.

[aston217]

QB2 has a totally bangin' sole score. I would've taken QB1 though, easy.

[burnum]

QB 1 turned out to be a good selection. After 6 seasons he's 86/86, won 2 Superbowls and 1 MVP.

QB 2 turned out as a solid 55/55 player.