Okay. I'm going with a lightly-edited version of Heisman sliders. Most sliders are near default, although I adjusted some sliders a bit based on this set:
J-Kits: NCAA Football Sliders - OFFICIAL 2016/17' season update - Operation Sports Forums
I adjusted cpu rb ability up, ints and tackling down for both cpu and user, and user rush D up. I also used the penalty sliders from the set above.
We can adjust more after people get used to Heisman. I've never tried Heisman in '14, so should be interesting.