23-25

[mooch49]

I know 26 is just about here, and possibly this question won't matter much. But out of curiosity, which one is your favorite of the three. I ask because they are all so similar, especially 23 and 24. I know 25 gets a lot of love, but I feel 23/24 are better in some areas.

Sent from my CPH2655 using Tapatalk

[Ghost Of The Year]

Couple things I like about 24 over 25, 24 has Oakland Coliseum, 25 doesn't.
24 has real player photo's on scoreboard, 25 doesn't. There are more things too but these are my biggest and leap immediately to mind.

[mooch49]

Let me ask it this way. Say 26 is more like 25, and you didn't like 25 much, would you go back to 23 or 24.

Sent from my CPH2655 using Tapatalk

[Ghost Of The Year]

I honestly enjoyed 24 more than 25, enjoyed 24 a little more than 23.
I enjoyed 25 but if I were forced to keep only one between 23 24 and 25, I'm keeping 24 no contest.

[Krebstar]

I originally played 23 and 24 on PS4, and thought 23 was much better due to performance issues on PS4, so I didn’t play much of 24 at all.

Upgraded to a PS5 in December and grabbed 25 and was enjoying it but then grabbed the PS5 version of 24 and I think it’s a much better game overall than 25. The new free agent mini game I guess I’ll call it is at least a change in franchise, but the removal of contract front/backloading and options is just shockingly inexcusable.

As of now, I’m starting a new franchise with 24. Feels next-gen enough to me, and there’s much more freedom and control with 30-team control in franchise.

I also don’t mind the light background—feels cleaner and less…cartoonish?