I thought the trade logic was fixed?

[DaveSBX]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

I traded Neftali Feliz and Luke Jackson for Stanton.

[midnightbottle]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

This was accepted straight up?

haha yep I was shocked.

[Jr.]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

There is something wrong with the trade value of relief pitchers. I'm seeing trade offers of 2 A Potential prospects for an 80s rated RP. I'm not sure if it's a bug or if the game was designed that way, but it's really bad.

[chitown1-23]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

That's where 30 team control comes into play

[DaveSBX]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

That's where 30 team control comes into play

This shouldn't have to be an option or a workaround. It should just work properly.

[rspencer86]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

I know trade logic is a tough thing to nail down. There are so many variables, so many things that the CPU needs to be able to "understand".

But this...





...this just can't happen. Ever. No excuse for it. Joe Mauer... Minnesota hometown hero, was hitting .298 with 8 homers and 51 RBI. Was traded for a 61 OVERALL RATED RELIEF PITCHER. Target Field would be burned to the ground if that happened in real life.

I would love to see trade logic addressed in a patch. It sucks to basically have to turn it off in order to be able to stomach playing franchise mode.

[Jr.]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

That's what I've been seeing too. It's got to be a glitch.. something in the code that makes RP's way too valuable in the trade algorithm

[GruffyMcGuiness]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

I literally decline almost every trade in my OF. The mariners and brewers do the same trade every ingame day which is getting annoying. Lucroy for Seager and Smoak

[MLB14]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

This shouldn't have to be an option or a workaround. It should just work properly.

Think about what trading logic has to encompass: Human thought patterns based around finance, player worth, current player durability, age, possible future situations, etc...

I wouldn't expect this type of thing to ever be perfect. It's based on human thought patterns. Maybe you should try programming it and pitch it to them.

[Jr.]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

I literally decline almost every trade in my OF. The mariners and brewers do the same trade every ingame day which is getting annoying. Lucroy for Seager and Smoak

It does get really annoying. I tried manually changing some teams' trading block but that didn't seem to help as they just made similarly awful trades with different players.

[GruffyMcGuiness]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

The worst I've seen so far is Todd Redmond and Colby Rasmus for Oscar Taveras (OS roster). I want to turn of trades but don't want teams to all look almost exactly the same five years in.

[Jr.]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

The worst I've seen so far is Todd Redmond and Colby Rasmus for Oscar Taveras (OS roster). I want to turn of trades but don't want teams to all look almost exactly the same five years in.

The trade discussion thread here has some good info on values and guys that would be traded in different situations. I'm going to go through teams starting July 1 and figure out some trades that make sense. It'll take time, but it's worth it in the end.

[birthday_massacre]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

I know exactly who they have man. Sizemore is iffy. Gomes, nava, Victorino are getting older.. After that.. We hardly have anyone besides Bradley Jr and Bryce Brentz.

I don't think it's the best deal, but in situations... It makes sense

Yeah so what happens two weeks into the next season? The red sox trade Clint Frasier for Doug Fister.

Care to explain that one to me

I know trade logic is a tough thing to nail down. There are so many variables, so many things that the CPU needs to be able to "understand".

But this...





...this just can't happen. Ever. No excuse for it. Joe Mauer... Minnesota hometown hero, was hitting .298 with 8 homers and 51 RBI. Was traded for a 61 OVERALL RATED RELIEF PITCHER. Target Field would be burned to the ground if that happened in real life.

I would love to see trade logic addressed in a patch. It sucks to basically have to turn it off in order to be able to stomach playing franchise mode.

I thought they added something this year to make it near impossible for Franchise players to be traded?

[ItAllFades]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

Something else promised and not delivered on? SHOCKER.

[Grub]

Re: I thought the trade logic was fixed?

The worst I've seen so far is Todd Redmond and Colby Rasmus for Oscar Taveras (OS roster). I want to turn of trades but don't want teams to all look almost exactly the same five years in.

I swear, Colby Rasmus is always part of some insane deal. He's the quintessential CPU ace-in-the-hole.