2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • tnixen
    MVP
    • Oct 2011
    • 3184

    #1

    2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

    There are 2 kinds of CPU fielding animations that I have seen over the years and would love to see them removed for the next version of MLB The Show.

    The first example is when an infielder like the second basemen moving to his left towards first base runs right over a ground ball that looks like it should have been fielded and so he ends up having to move back to his right to pick up the ball. During this play the second basemen glove actually stops the ball from moving but the second baseman ran past the ball instead of picking it up. You will hardly ever see these happen in real life.

    The second example is cpu pitchers taking way to long fielding ground balls hit back at them. One example was I hit a fairly hard ground ball back to the cpu pitcher and when the pitcher picked the ball up he makes like this like big swing animation around with his arm and my batter barley had left home plate so I should have been thrown out pretty easily at first. But of course I was safe at first because of the cpu pitcher doing this strange animation with his arm.

    And one other fielding animation user controlled that happens sometimes is when an outfielder runs to either field or catch a ball near a wall and he gets kind of stuck or slowed down by the wall which of course allows the base runner to get extra bases.

    All three of these fielding animations happen at random times and they drive me nuts. I am sure there are lots more fielding animations that need to be removed also but these 3 stick out the most to me.

    MLB 14 The Shows fielding is fantastic and if Sony can clean up some of the older annoying fielding animations that slow down gameplay it would make what is already a great playing game much much better and more enjoyable to play.
    Last edited by tnixen; 09-03-2014, 05:57 PM.
  • Russell_SCEA
    SCEA Community Manager
    • May 2005
    • 4161

    #2
    Re: 3 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

    Originally posted by tnixen
    There are 2 kinds of CPU fielding animations that I have seen over the years and would love to see them removed for the next version of MLB The Show.

    The first example is when an infielder like the second basemen moving to his left towards first base runs right over a ground ball that looks like it should have been fielded and so he ends up having to move back to his right to pick up the ball. During this play the second basemen glove actually stops the ball from moving but the second baseman ran past the ball instead of picking it up. You will hardly ever see these happen in real life.

    The second example is cpu pitchers taking way to long fielding ground balls hit back at them. One example was I hit a fairly hard ground ball back to the cpu pitcher and when the pitcher picked the ball up he makes like this like big swing animation around with his arm and my batter barley had left home plate so I should have been thrown out pretty easily at first. But of course I was safe at first because of the cpu pitcher doing this strange animation with his arm.

    And one other fielding animation user controlled that happens sometimes is when an outfielder runs to either field or catch a ball near a wall and he gets kind of stuck or slowed down by the wall which of course allows the base runner to get extra bases.

    All three of these fielding animations happen at random times and they drive me nuts. I am sure there are lots more fielding animations that need to be removed also but these 3 stick out the most to me.

    MLB 14 The Shows fielding is fantastic and if Sony can clean up some of the older annoying fielding animations that slow down gameplay it would make what is already a great playing game much much better and more enjoyable to play.


    Video?.....................

    Comment

    • HustlinOwl
      All Star
      • Mar 2004
      • 9713

      #3
      Re: 3 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

      Originally posted by Russell_SCEA
      Video?.....................
      sounds like he is not preloading throws prior to fielding ball, thus branching into these animations?

      Comment

      • HopiDesertPriest
        Banned
        • Nov 2013
        • 597

        #4
        Re: 2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

        good post.

        i suggest that you let the cpu do all your fielding and throwing - ratings based.

        scea really cleaned up the animations this year and i hope the continue to improve.

        this game is:

        OUTSTANDING

        Comment

        • decga
          MVP
          • Mar 2004
          • 2469

          #5
          Re: 2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

          If tnixen can get a video of animations or lack there of. It will visibly show the issue. Good post by the way. No bashing, no parting shots.

          Comment

          • Factzzz
            FA
            • Aug 2011
            • 1655

            #6
            Re: 3 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

            Originally posted by tnixen
            And one other fielding animation user controlled that happens sometimes is when an outfielder runs to either field or catch a ball near a wall and he gets kind of stuck or slowed down by the wall which of course allows the base runner to get extra bases.
            Originally posted by HustlinOwl
            sounds like he is not preloading throws prior to fielding ball, thus branching into these animations?
            Nope, regardless of preloading throws, his third point happens A LOT.

            It's incredibly annoying, my teammates always do this in my SP RTTS, it looks like you have a shot to throw a player out at second or home, and they do all this extra stuff before the throw or they run into a wall that they could have easily avoided.

            But as stated, it happens with user controlled outfielders too.
            NFL : Atlanta Falcons
            MLB : Toronto Blue Jays

            Comment

            • Bobhead
              Pro
              • Mar 2011
              • 4926

              #7
              Re: 3 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

              Originally posted by Russell_SCEA
              Video?.....................
              You know, back in my day, we didn't have these "videos." Us folks just read the darn thing and then we used our imagination to picture everything.

              You kids these days don't even know how easy you have it!

              Comment

              • HustlinOwl
                All Star
                • Mar 2004
                • 9713

                #8
                Re: 3 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                Originally posted by Factzzz
                Nope, regardless of preloading throws, his third point happens A LOT.

                It's incredibly annoying, my teammates always do this in my SP RTTS, it looks like you have a shot to throw a player out at second or home, and they do all this extra stuff before the throw or they run into a wall that they could have easily avoided.

                But as stated, it happens with user controlled outfielders too.
                guess its to reflect poorer fielding ratings and also user input on preloading throws as I have seen these animations as well. Can always remove and replace with another animation to annoy everyone like some stumble fail to get clean throw off resulting in error

                Comment

                • Woodweaver
                  Developer
                  • Apr 2006
                  • 1145

                  #9
                  Re: 3 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                  Originally posted by HustlinOwl
                  guess its to reflect poorer fielding ratings and also user input on preloading throws as I have seen these animations as well. Can always remove and replace with another animation to annoy everyone like some stumble fail to get clean throw off resulting in error
                  These animations play depending on the speed/momentum of the fielder making the catch and his proximity of the wall. If the throw to which he would normally branch would carry him into/through the wall, then, as logic, physics and the available animations dictate, the "brace yourself against the wall instead of running into it" animations are played.


                  That being said, there may still be a bug...which is why providing a video is essential for us to determine if the play is "by design", a bug, or new animations need to be captured.
                  "Yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man"

                  Comment

                  • HustlinOwl
                    All Star
                    • Mar 2004
                    • 9713

                    #10
                    Re: 3 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                    Originally posted by Woodweaver
                    These animations play depending on the speed/momentum of the fielder making the catch and his proximity of the wall. If the throw to which he would normally branch would carry him into/through the wall, then, as logic, physics and the available animations dictate, the "brace yourself against the wall instead of running into it" animations are played.


                    That being said, there may still be a bug...which is why providing a video is essential for us to determine if the play is "by design", a bug, or new animations need to be captured.
                    which is why a lot of times I will take control of fielder after fielding with LS and then make throw

                    Comment

                    • Clarke99
                      Banned
                      • Feb 2012
                      • 462

                      #11
                      Re: 2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                      The OP forgot the worst animation of all, outfielders bracing themselves from the wall especially while they have the ball. NO ONE does this you turn and fire. Base runners get almost 2 whole bases from this animation.

                      Comment

                      • Padgoi
                        Banned
                        • Oct 2008
                        • 1873

                        #12
                        Re: 2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                        How about the animation that pretty much dictates every play, which is the fact that no fielder ever displays any urgency to throw the ball, resulting in a lot of infield singles and close plays that have no business being close.

                        Or do I need video.....?

                        Comment

                        • HustlinOwl
                          All Star
                          • Mar 2004
                          • 9713

                          #13
                          Re: 2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                          Originally posted by P.A.D.
                          How about the animation that pretty much dictates every play, which is the fact that no fielder ever displays any urgency to throw the ball, resulting in a lot of infield singles and close plays that have no business being close.

                          Or do I need video.....?
                          sure or just lower base runner speed?

                          Comment

                          • Padgoi
                            Banned
                            • Oct 2008
                            • 1873

                            #14
                            Re: 2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                            Why should I have to fix a flaw in the game with a slider that slows down all base runners to a crawl? Why not just . . . fix the flaw in the game?

                            Comment

                            • Woodweaver
                              Developer
                              • Apr 2006
                              • 1145

                              #15
                              Re: 2 fielding animations that need to be removed/fixed!

                              Originally posted by P.A.D.
                              How about the animation that pretty much dictates every play, which is the fact that no fielder ever displays any urgency to throw the ball, resulting in a lot of infield singles and close plays that have no business being close.

                              Or do I need video.....?

                              What are you talking about?


                              And in case you missed it...yes, videos are essential when trying track down bugs. Should be easy to capture one, no, since the issue you mentioned "dictates every play"?
                              Last edited by Woodweaver; 09-05-2014, 05:27 PM.
                              "Yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man"

                              Comment

                              Working...