Challenges

[milldaddy35]

Has anyone seen any so far?

[PhilliesFan13]

Re: Challenges

Saw my first one and lost it.

[TheSnake]

Re: Challenges

Brett Gardner,bunt down the first base line, called out,Giradi comes out of the dugout I challenge, call over turned,safe.

[WatchdogXC]

Re: Challenges

In my first Play Now game other than the Royals/Giants game Carlos Santana tried to beat out and infield hit and was called out. I was given the option to challenge and did with Francona and ended up having it overturned and ruled safe so I got that trophy right away. Had 20 seconds it looked like to decide but did right away.

Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk

[Skyboxer]

Re: Challenges

1-1 in my challenges so far...

[Dolenz]

Re: Challenges

Had one challenge and I won it.

[Posada]

Re: Challenges

Had one challenge and I won it.

Same here.

[countryboy]

Re: Challenges

I'm 0 for 5

Mike Matheny's not very convincing lol

[BL8001]

Re: Challenges

These challenges are auto right?

No way to initiate them?

[mrcultureshock]

Re: Challenges

I've seen 2 in exhibition. Lost the 1st challenge and won the 2nd one. But the 2nd call was a horrible one by the 1B ump. The runner was a at least 4 steps from the base when my first baseman caught the ball. The ump called the play safe.

I hope the umpire accuracy rate isn't negatively affected because SCEA implemented the challenge function.

[FloorGeneral]

Re: Challenges

I've had 2. Won both of them.

Same here. One where I was on defense, and one where I was on offense.

[bcruise]

Re: Challenges

I've seen 2 in exhibition. Lost the 1st challenge and won the 2nd one. But the 2nd call was a horrible one by the 1B ump. The runner was a at least 4 steps from the base when my first baseman caught the ball. The ump called the play safe.

I hope the umpire accuracy rate isn't negatively affected because SCEA implemented the challenge function.

Well, in a sense it is, because the AI doesn't need to challenge calls. I had this exchange with Woodweaver pre-release:

Bit of a groin kick that the AI will not challenge calls. For me that puts the feature in kind of the same boat as Balks. Ultimately I'd rather the game get the call right in the end for both teams. I realize that would require situational AI to be put in on when it would be most beneficial for the CPU team to challenge though, so as a first year effort I'm fine with that.

Hopefully we still have the option of turning the umpire missed calls off (basically a shortcut to the eventual outcome of a replay challenge)

Edit: Yes, I am well aware that 1B is the only challengeable call, and that either way this is not going to have a huge impact on the game (replays are rare enough in MLB as it is, and having only one category of them makes the impact even smaller).

Yeah, the AI gets the correct call. Besides when the AI would get a potential bad call, I believe the desire to not have the user sit through the process while the CPU plays the challenge out was a consideration.


Maybe next year...

Appreciate the explanation WW. Actually if the AI doesn't NEED to challenge (that's the impression I'm getting from your post, correct me if I'm wrong), then I'm perfectly fine with using the challenges myself.

One thing about that though - are we going to be limited in our number of challenges like in the real MLB? If there is a limit then that could put the user in a disadvantaged situation vs a CPU that doesn't need to use them.

I know it's just a series of cutscenes (with a prompt) triggered by a close play, so maybe the limit thing doesn't factor in.

I've got a vivid enough imagination that I can imagine the CPU challenging a close play, and ultimately getting the call right.
Sent from my SM-G900P using Tapatalk

I know people are going to cry foul on that, but to me it's better than the CPU being unable to challenge and being stuck with a bad call. As WW said maybe next year they can get challenge logic for the AI in....

For now if you want everything to be fair, turn umpire close plays off (therefore disabling challenges because the right call is always made).

[HozAndMoose]

Re: Challenges

These challenges are auto right?

No way to initiate them?

I believe they are kind of semi auto. You cant just choose any play. But if it was a close play then the option will come up and you have to decide if you want to challenge it or not.

[ctzn.]

Re: Challenges

1-1 in my challenges so far...

Same here. Won the first challenge, lost the second. Pretty nice feature.

[milldaddy35]

Re: Challenges

How do you challenge?