Bug or rare bunting rule?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • My993C2
    MVP
    • Sep 2012
    • 1588

    #1

    Bug or rare bunting rule?

    Not sure if this is a new bunt bug because of the patch (the release notes mentioned some bunt code was worked on) or if this is just one of those really rare bugs that has existed in the game since day one, or perhaps it was not even a bug but some rare rule. But in my game last night, the CPU opposition pitcher got four bunting foul balls before he was called out when he should have been called out on that 3rd bunting foul ball? Oh and the 2nd pitch of the plate appearance might have been what triggered the issue. Here is the scenario.

    - Opposition had base runners on 1st and 2nd with no outs.

    - Opposition pitcher is at bat and a sacrifice bunt is expected.

    - 1st pitch is high and in and the batter fouls it for a 0-1 strike.

    - 2nd pitch also high and in and it hits the batter. A walk right? Nope ... the commentator mentioned that the umpire ruled on a rare play where the batter stepped into the pitch and a strike was called on batter putting him down 0-2.

    - 3rd pitch is low and away and fouled off. Batter out right and I am thinking, "Woohoo I lucked out on this one". However ...

    - Instead of facing the next batter, the pitcher is still at the plate. On the 4th pitch my pitcher throws another pitch low and away, the batter fouls it away again and this time he is out.

    But why did the batter get that 4th attempt? He clearly had an 0-2 count after the 2nd pitch where it was ruled that he stepped into the pitch. Shouldn't he have been called out after the 3rd bunt attempt was fouled off? Is this a bug? or is there some sort of rare bunting rule I am not aware of related to what happened on that 2nd pitch?
  • bigdaddykraven
    Rookie
    • Jun 2007
    • 300

    #2
    Re: Bug or rare bunting rule?

    Originally posted by My993C2
    Not sure if this is a new bunt bug because of the patch (the release notes mentioned some bunt code was worked on) or if this is just one of those really rare bugs that has existed in the game since day one, or perhaps it was not even a bug but some rare rule. But in my game last night, the CPU opposition pitcher got four bunting foul balls before he was called out when he should have been called out on that 3rd bunting foul ball? Oh and the 2nd pitch of the plate appearance might have been what triggered the issue. Here is the scenario.

    - Opposition had base runners on 1st and 2nd with no outs.

    - Opposition pitcher is at bat and a sacrifice bunt is expected.

    - 1st pitch is high and in and the batter fouls it for a 0-1 strike.

    - 2nd pitch also high and in and it hits the batter. A walk right? Nope ... the commentator mentioned that the umpire ruled on a rare play where the batter stepped into the pitch and a strike was called on batter putting him down 0-2.

    - 3rd pitch is low and away and fouled off. Batter out right and I am thinking, "Woohoo I lucked out on this one". However ...

    - Instead of facing the next batter, the pitcher is still at the plate. On the 4th pitch my pitcher throws another pitch low and away, the batter fouls it away again and this time he is out.

    But why did the batter get that 4th attempt? He clearly had an 0-2 count after the 2nd pitch where it was ruled that he stepped into the pitch. Shouldn't he have been called out after the 3rd bunt attempt was fouled off? Is this a bug? or is there some sort of rare bunting rule I am not aware of related to what happened on that 2nd pitch?
    Sounds like a bug. I know when bunting, same as swinging at a ball, if you are across the plate enough, it'll be a strike if you're hit. As far as I know it doesn't give them a 4th strike though.

    Comment

    • My993C2
      MVP
      • Sep 2012
      • 1588

      #3
      Re: Bug or rare bunting rule?

      Originally posted by bigdaddykraven
      Sounds like a bug.
      If people think it is a bug I will submit a bug report. Not sure how easily the DEVs can reproduce the conditions inside of their debug development environments to be able to reproduce the problem. But I am sure for us joe-blow users of the game, it has to be a pretty rare occurrence. My planets just happened to be aligned last night to see it. So I would not say it is a high priority issue.

      Comment

      • miamikb2001
        Pro
        • Feb 2008
        • 795

        #4
        Re: Bug or rare bunting rule?

        I've had it happen around 3-5 times it's a bug.
        Giants
        49ers
        Hurricanes
        Warriors
        Sharks

        Comment

        • kevin_bondra
          Rookie
          • Apr 2012
          • 26

          #5
          Re: Bug or rare bunting rule?

          I've had it happen where the batter didn't get hit, bunted foul on 3rd strike and the batter wasn't out.

          The next pitch he bunted fair for the sacrifice. Not sure that the bug is specific to your situation - may just be a 3rd strike issue where the out isn't recorded.

          Comment

          • Woodweaver
            Developer
            • Apr 2006
            • 1145

            #6
            Re: Bug or rare bunting rule?

            Originally posted by My993C2
            If people think it is a bug I will submit a bug report. Not sure how easily the DEVs can reproduce the conditions inside of their debug development environments to be able to reproduce the problem. But I am sure for us joe-blow users of the game, it has to be a pretty rare occurrence. My planets just happened to be aligned last night to see it. So I would not say it is a high priority issue.

            Report it, please.
            "Yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man"

            Comment

            • Aweb20
              Rookie
              • Aug 2013
              • 42

              #7
              Re: Bug or rare bunting rule?

              Yes this has been a bug from the beginning. There is already a report on it around page 2 or 3. It would probably be best to just upvote that so the votes are not split. Although now that I double check, the current report doesn't mention the hit by pitch part, and now that I think back, when this bug happened to me, strike two was a pitch that hit the batter who was still trying to bunt.
              Last edited by Aweb20; 04-24-2015, 11:37 AM.

              Comment

              Working...