I still haven't made a decision on the trade. A few hangups I have as I got into the game and revisited the trade:
* Wacha is on the DL for the 2nd time this season. If this trend continues, then losing Bumgarner would mean that we are then relying on 2 young arms from the minors while in the midst of a pennant chase. Again, while I'm confident in the young arms, they aren't MadBum
* I was reviewing McCann and Miller. Miller is fine, but McCann is declining and only hitting .237 this year with 8 homeruns and 40 something RBI. While Thole isn't McCann, he is hitting around .250 and doing a serviceable job as a backup/platoon with Kelly.
* While MadBum has struggled he did pitch well in his first start after the break. He is 7-8 on the year with a 3.71 ERA (I thought it was higher). So what happens if he pitches dominantly in the 2nd half and I've dealt him away?
After strongly leaning towards making the deal, I'm now leaning towards not making the deal.
The life of a GM...


Comment