Situation - What would you do?

[saucerset]

I was thinking about this after watching the M's game last night. You're up by one run in the 9th, 2 on, no outs, and Pujols up to bat. He is currently hitting .200 something and 0-3 tonight.

Do you put him on? You run the risk of giving up the equalizer but it's better than him belting a 3 run shot.

Do you pitch to him knowing his average is down and he is hitless in the game.

I like to think that I would have just put him on in hopes that I only gave up maybe one run in the inning. Just knowing what he can do would make me avoid him.
Cheers!

[KBLover]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

I try to pitch around him and if I walk him, so be it, but I *hate* just giving away free baserunners without at least giving him a chance to press and chase something he shouldn't.

Sure, he might get a hit anyway, but at least I gave him a chance to get himself out as well. There's no guarantee I get the next guy either. I load the bases and the next guy might drop a 2-run bloop on me anyway.

[UTAllTheWay]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

I faced a similar situation last night against the Yankees. In the bottom of the 11th, tie game, they had a runner on second, 2 outs, and A-Rod comes up. I considered intentionally walking him, but he wasn't having a good game at the plate.

I pitched to him, and he hit a walk off two-run homer.

After much consideration, here is what I've come up with:

- If there are two outs, I walk him because even if I move the runner to third with the walk, they still HAVE to get a base hit to score the runner.

- If there is one or no outs and first base is open, I walk him. Make the play at him a force play, give yourself a chance.

- If there is one or no outs and the runners are on 1st and 2nd, I pitch to him. I don't want to move the runner to third and let them score on a pop-up to the outfield if I don't have to.

[countryboy]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

Depends on where the runners are. If they are on 1st and 2nd, then I go ahead and pitch to him in hopes of getting a ground ball double play. If runners are on 1st and 3rd or 2nd and 3rd, then I walk him and set up force at any base and the opportunity at a double play.

[HozAndMoose]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

I faced a similar situation last night against the Yankees. In the bottom of the 11th, tie game, they had a runner on second, 2 outs, and A-Rod comes up. I considered intentionally walking him, but he wasn't having a good game at the plate.

I pitched to him, and he hit a walk off two-run homer.

After much consideration, here is what I've come up with:

- If there are two outs, I walk him because even if I move the runner to third with the walk, they still HAVE to get a base hit to score the runner.

- If there is one or no outs and first base is open, I walk him. Make the play at him a force play, give yourself a chance.

- If there is one or no outs and the runners are on 1st and 2nd, I pitch to him. I don't want to move the runner to third and let them score on a pop-up to the outfield if I don't have to.

Scenario one completely depends on who the runner on 3rd and pitcher/(catcher to some extent) are. You load the bases now you can't accidentally miss and hit the batter, can't walk the batter, can't give up a wild pitch/passed ball. You now have to get the out.

[UTAllTheWay]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

Scenario one completely depends on who the runner on 3rd and pitcher/(catcher to some extent) are. You load the bases now you can't accidentally miss and hit the batter, can't walk the batter, can't give up a wild pitch/passed ball. You now have to get the out.

True. Excellent point.

[reyes the roof]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

I can't think of a whole lot of scenarios where I'm not going to go after a .200 hitter. If he beats me then so be it

[kenp86]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

Pitch him low and with breaking pitches. Double play

[bestbrother]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

Id walk him, the inevitably... give up the Grand Slam, or balk in a run (or 2)

Tough innings generally end up rough for me

[Beatles]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

Pujols stinks so pitching to him is and was the right call. Not walking Trout is what made me scratch my head. He got a single anyway but still, I walk him every time and take my chances with Pujols.

[briguy4747]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

In real life, the Mariner's closer, Cishek, obviously did NOT pitch Pujols correctly, to give him a home run pitch !!! Should have been low and away pitches throughout his at-bat !! And Blue Jays manager, Gibbons, not bringing in Osuna in the bottom of the 9th on Sat, was a mistake also !! You go with the best pitcher available at the time, who is more likely to send the game to extra innings !! Gibbons is not a good decision-making manager !!

[Mike Lowe]

Re: Situation - What would you do?

He's an easy double play. If you walk him, a single beats you. Under no circumstances would I intentionally load the bases w zero outs in that situation.