MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

[thaSLAB]

Hey OSers! Having spoken with our friends over at Sony SDS, it's about that time again... Time to start gathering more stadium details and feedback for MLB 17. As the OS community rep for MLB stadiums, I wanted to reach out to everyone and give the community as a whole the opportunity to help make the game even more true to life as possible.

Please leave any details, updates and feedback for the 30 MLB Ballparks here. Photos are the most useful (with arrows and circles are even better), and please make sure that all reference materials are from the 2016 season. The clearer and higher resolution, the better. And of course, a brief description of the detail or change is recommended. SPOILER tags are always nice too.

There are 4 stadiums that will not need any info submitted for, due to the ball clubs providing official means of access to info. So there's no need to bother with those, which are:

Orioles Park at Camden Yards (Baltimore)
SunTrust Park (Atlanta)
Marlins Park (Miami)
Petco Park (San Diego)

Other than that, share away! Thanks!

[PhilliesFan13]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

I'll get you some Citizens Bank Park pics when I go to my next game.

Sent from my LGLS991 using Tapatalk

[andybill]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

Nats park:
The big "curly W" analog clock next to the scoreboard in right center doesn't work or even have hands anymore IRL (it keeps time in the game).

It has not been keeping time well through the years and they finally just removed the hands in 2014 (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/...ost-its-hands/)

If the developers are striving for accuracy, remove the hands. If they wanted to make it an easter egg, maybe just have it not keep time well

[MauerMorneau09]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

I know we've been over this before Slab, but just to make sure it's not lost in the shuffle. The weather bug at Target Field is still my biggest gripe about the stadium in general. Just gonna post the link to the thread I made awhile back, it's got all the pics SCEA needs.

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...d-weather.html

[thaSLAB]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

Comerica Park

The biggest change was the unveiling of the new brick backstop, and faux brick padding on the access doors. Also, the Tigers Club section (top half of the lower section behind home plate) has had wood chairs and tables, since 2007 (in-game it looks like wheelchair seating).

Spoiler

In the outfield, the DAC building added a 7th floor 'club' that became a hot spot for watching a game. Also, the colors of the vehicles in the CF fountain will be orange and blue from now on.

Spoiler

Sent from my 831C using Tapatalk

[WaitTilNextYear]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

I'm not sure that this requires photo evidence, but the center field dimension in MLB '16 at Busch Stadium is listed at 336 FT to dead center (which is absurd for a major league park). According to Wikipedia, the center field fence is 400'. There are also some poor photos on the internet that aren't zoomed in enough, but maybe a Cardinals fan has some better photo evidence.

[TripleCrown9]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

The Red Sox retired Wade Boggs' number this year.

[beau21]

MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

Been waiting for this thread!!

Slab - Let me know if anything is unclear or if you need more information.

---------------------------------------------

Kauffman Stadium

Crown Club pt.1 (Seating)

Spoiler

Updates #1a and #1b are top two priorities that I would love to see made as they've been incorrect for years, and are immediately visible for half of the game when playing at Kauffman Stadium. The seating section immediately behind home plate (called the Crown Club Seats) at the K needs some love. The aisle locations I think are actually correct, however the number of seats needs correcting - in MLB 16 there's too many gaps of missing seats, even though the risers are there. This makes it appear as if there's too many aisles. (Images below show seat plan for number of rows and aisle locations, and also a crude Photoshopped seat plan that shows how many seats are in each section) There also appears to only be two-three rows of people in this section in The Show, but IRL there are actually four rows of people as the images and seat plan shows.

Crown Club pt.2 (Advertisement)

Spoiler

Coupled with the post above re: Seating, this is necessary update #1b for me. Behind the seating described above, there needs to be a fixed advertisement board covering the railing behind the middle part of the section (see second image for extents). In MLB 16, you see the legs and feet of fans in the seating section above, where you shouldn't. Also, in the middle, directly behind home plate (shown as a Subway advertisement in real snapshot), should be a digital sign. In real life, this shows either sponsor logos, or upcoming promotions, etc.

Craft & Draft Seating Section

Spoiler

For the 2015 season, Kauffman Stadium replaced what had been the '.390 Club' along the 3rd base line. The most noticeable change is that the old .390 Club was closed off with glass, but the new 'Craft & Draft' section is open.

Grass Pattern

Spoiler

While I initially loved that the devs put the Royals crown in the grass pattern in center field, now seeing it for every game in MLB 15 and MLB 16 has caused it to lose its luster. The Royals very rarely mow the crown grass pattern - less that 5-10 games max per season (including playoffs). The predominant pattern for games at the K is a simple cross pattern with a slightly smaller hatch pattern on the infield than the outfield. Knowing that the crown is really only mowed at the K for primetime (re: playoff) series', I would actually prefer to have it removed if there's only going to be one pattern for every home game in MLB 17.

Hall of Fame Window Graphic(s) and Flag Count

Spoiler

I understand there's likely copyright issues with having the exact graphics on the Royals' Hall of Fame (visible in left field). However, it would be nice to have something a little truer to reality. The past 5-6 years, the team has branded the glass with a new Kansas City focused graphics facing the field (with the large green Commerce branding being added for the 2015 season), but the general graphic has been consistent (blue tinted, KC skyline, etc). The Show still has the plain window graphic style that was used circa 2010-ish.

2016:


2015:


2014:


MLB 16:

Upper Deck Graphics

Spoiler

The upper deck at Kauffman has (1) large vomitory about half way up the 1st base line and (1) half way up the 3rd base line. In The Show, these vomitories are solid concrete (as most of them are). However, in real life, these should have large (mostly blue) sponsor graphics on them. Also, at the top of the press box area are two long 'roof tops'. The Show has these as a plain color, but these should also be sponsored mostly blue.

Left and Right Field Foul Territory Wall Graphics

Spoiler

The walls along the left and right field lines need to have more graphics/advertisements added to them. In The Show, both walls are shown blank.

Right Field '(Script) Advertisement Sign' and 'Baseball Sign'.

Spoiler

The Show 16 does have an advertisement above the bar in right field, but making it a neon script sign would be even more authentic. The true sponsor is Budweiser (and has been the past few seasons), but I know the Show can't put that up there. Red neon text that said something like 'Kauffman' or 'Baseball' would even be great. Full disclosure: the on-field panoramic view is 2016 just to prove current, but the close up is an older picture.

Also, there has been a baseball 360 Vodka sign at the right corner of the building the past few seasons as well that would be great to add for 17 as it's missing from the Show 16.

Outfield Wall LED Boards

Spoiler

The Show 16 has these, but they need to be extended a little bit to replace some static advertisements. The Show's LED boards need to extend all the way to the bullpen fences. What is shown as 'The Show 16' advertisement board in the screenshot below, should be a part of the LED board.

[will edit post with more]

[RLB]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

I'm not sure that this requires photo evidence, but the center field dimension in MLB '16 at Busch Stadium is listed at 336 FT to dead center (which is absurd for a major league park). According to Wikipedia, the center field fence is 400'. There are also some poor photos on the internet that aren't zoomed in enough, but maybe a Cardinals fan has some better photo evidence.

400' is correct

[sydrogerdavid]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

St. Louis guys, anybody have more pictures of the new scoreboard graphics? These two attachments are the only ones I have and it will probably be difficult to find many pics of the graphics online as we're searching against 10 plus years of the old scoreboard.

Budweiser scoreboard: These were in my write-up last year, but the flags on the Bud scoreboard are now exactly the same ones that are above the World Champion years on the OOT scoreboard. Also, that whole section on the clock last year is still relevant. It needs to be updated in 17, neon lighting and all.

Spoilered is the new Perficient Porch, which replaced the Hardee's (Burgers in The Show) in the LF upper deck.

Spoiler

[sydrogerdavid]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

Other than my last post, I've got no photos from 2016.

One thing off the top of my head is that the visitor's dugout is missing the National League Champions 2013 pennant on the roof. They have all the other pennants correct, just missing that one.

Spoiler

Although, if they plan on adding minor league parks, I've memorized nearly everything about First Tennessee Park in Nashville. I could get you anything, from the big guitar scoreboard, to the lake that forms when it rains in the player's parking lot, or the location of all the storm drains in the seating bowl.

[RLB]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

Along with Busch having wrong distance on the outfield wall. PNC, AT&T and Nationals Park also have wrong numbers on the wall.

[WaitTilNextYear]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

Along with Busch having wrong distance on the outfield wall. PNC, AT&T and Nationals Park also have wrong numbers on the wall.

I thought that 382 FT to dead center at AT&T was suspect...it should be 399.

Maybe SCEA should just run over to Wikipedia and double/triple check all the stadium dimensions? It's not like the stadiums are built to incorrect specs, just labeled wrong on the outfield wall in some spots.

[Houston]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

I am not sure if all these are accurate but I wanted to share what I found.

http://baseballsimulator.com/ballpar...team-stadiums/

[tnixen]

Re: MLB 17 Stadium Accuracy / Feedback Thread

I'll get you some Citizens Bank Park pics when I go to my next game.

Sent from my LGLS991 using Tapatalk

Hi

There are quite a few differences between real life Citizens Bank Park and in MLB The Show 16.

1. Could you get a zoomed in screen shot of the left field foul pole showing the distance number. I am pretty sure the color is still little different in 16 vs real life.

2 The ivy in center field has changed and grown in different spots.

3. There are 2 new LED boards in right field one for the pitcher and the other in the upper deck which has the batter info I think.

4. Also on the big jumbotron in left field the team names/logos next to the innings display are wrong in 16 compared to real life.

5. Last but not least the Liberty Bell still does not have the correct animation on Home Runs and end of game victory. The green Citizens Bank Park sign under the bell should blink on and off and also the little stars on the Liberty Bell should also be blinking and changing to different colors.

I am sure there are other small things but these are the main things that have been inaccurate with Citizens Bank Park in MLB The Show for a long time now.

It would be great if the MLB The Show developers could make a trip to Philly someday soon

Anyway thanks PhilliesFan13 for trying to get all the screen shots.

P.S. Almost forgot can you take a screen shot of where the Ball girls chairs are on the field. I am pretty sure in MLB The Show 16 they have the ball boys chairs in the wrong spot compared to real life.