MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

[UNDERTAKER1215]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

So I have two days until the trade deadline and want to make some deals for CPU teams. I'll list the teams in contention, positions of need, and players who could potentially be available. If anyone could come up with some deals that would be realistic and make sense, that would be great.

Yankees: RHP RP

Indians: RHP RP

Mariners: SP, LHP RP, RHP RP, Backup OF

Rangers: LHP RP, Backup INF

Astros: SP, 1B, INF, LF

Nationals: Backup INF

Mets: RHP RP, C, 1B, INF, OF

Phillies: SP, LHP RP, RHP RP, C, Backup INF

Cubs: LHP RP, Backup INF

Pirates: SP, LHP RP, RHP RP, Backup INF, Backup OF

Cardinals: LHP RP, RHP RP

Diamondbacks: RHP RP

Dodgers: LHP RP

Giants: LHP RP, CP, Backup OF

I know this would take some time for people to come up with deals so I went ahead and came up with some, so let me know what you think.

#1)
Yankees Receive: Junichi Tazawa

Marlins Receive: Ronald Herrera, Yefrey Ramirez

#2)
Indians Receive: Kyle Barraclough

Marlins Receive: Brady Aiken, Giovanny Urshela/Tyler Krieger, Mike Papi

#3)
Mariners Receive: Marco Estrada, Aaron Loup

Blue Jays Receive: Nick Neidert, Dan Altavilla, D.J. Peterson

#4)
Rangers Receive: Fernando Abad

Red Sox Receive: Zachary Bird

#5)
Rangers Receive: Eduardo Escobar

Twins Receive: Nick Martinez

#6)
Astros Receive: Alex Cobb, Brad Miller

Rays Receive: Brady Rodgers, Yordan Alvarez, Jason Martin

#7)
Astros Receive: Steve Pearce

Blue Jays Receive: Jandel Gustave

#8)
Nationals Receive: Luis Valbuena

Angels Receive: Drew Ward

#9)
Mets Receive: Stephen Vogt, Jed Lowrie, Khris Davis

Athletics Receive: Rafael Montero, Kevin Plawecki, David Thompson, Brandon Nimmo

#10)
Mets Receive: Byung Ho Park

Twins Receive: Logan Taylor, Phillip Evans

Because there are so many deals, I'll have two separate posts, so here is the first half.

[BlueJays09]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

I know this would take some time for people to come up with deals so I went ahead and came up with some, so let me know what you think.

#1)
Yankees Receive: Junichi Tazawa

Marlins Receive: Ronald Herrera, Yefrey Ramirez

#2)
Indians Receive: Kyle Barraclough

Marlins Receive: Brady Aiken, Giovanny Urshela/Tyler Krieger, Mike Papi

#3)
Mariners Receive: Marco Estrada, Aaron Loup

Blue Jays Receive: Nick Neidert, Dan Altavilla, D.J. Peterson

#4)
Rangers Receive: Fernando Abad

Red Sox Receive: Zachary Bird

#5)
Rangers Receive: Eduardo Escobar

Twins Receive: Nick Martinez

#6)
Astros Receive: Alex Cobb, Brad Miller

Rays Receive: Brady Rodgers, Yordan Alvarez, Jason Martin

#7)
Astros Receive: Steve Pearce

Blue Jays Receive: Jandel Gustave

#8)
Nationals Receive: Luis Valbuena

Angels Receive: Drew Ward

#9)
Mets Receive: Stephen Vogt, Jed Lowrie, Khris Davis

Athletics Receive: Rafael Montero, Kevin Plawecki, Luis Guillorme, Brandon Nimmo

#10)
Mets Receive: Byung Ho Park

Twins Receive: Logan Taylor, Phillip Evans

Because there are so many deals, I'll have two separate posts, so here is the first half.

I am looking to deal Estrada so I might look to the Mariners for a deal like this one.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[UNDERTAKER1215]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

So I have two days until the trade deadline and want to make some deals for CPU teams. I'll list the teams in contention, positions of need, and players who could potentially be available. If anyone could come up with some deals that would be realistic and make sense, that would be great.

Yankees: RHP RP

Indians: RHP RP

Mariners: SP, LHP RP, RHP RP, Backup OF

Rangers: LHP RP, Backup INF

Astros: SP, 1B, INF, LF

Nationals: Backup INF

Mets: RHP RP, C, 1B, INF, OF

Phillies: SP, LHP RP, RHP RP, C, Backup INF

Cubs: LHP RP, Backup INF

Pirates: SP, LHP RP, RHP RP, Backup INF, Backup OF

Cardinals: LHP RP, RHP RP

Diamondbacks: RHP RP

Dodgers: LHP RP

Giants: LHP RP, CP, Backup OF

#11)
Phillies Receive: Wade Miley, Brad Brach

Orioles Receive: Drew Anderson, Jorge Flores, Cornelius Randolph

#12)
Phillies Receive: Ryan Schimpf, Alex Dickerson

Padres Receive: Nick Pivetta, Yacksel Rios, Jhailyn Ortiz

#13)
Cubs Receive: Tommy Milone, Hernan Perez

Brewers Receive: Duane Underwood, Jhondaniel Medina, Yasiel Balaguert

#14)
Pirates Receive: Mat Latos, Nori Aoki

Blue Jays Receive: Trevor Williams, Luis Escobar, Elvis Escobar

#15)
Cardinals Receive: Liam Hendricks, Santiago Casilla

Athletics Receive: Chris Ellis, Rowan Wick, Oscar Mercado

#16)
Diamondbacks Receive: Francisco Rodriguez

Tigers Receive: Jose Martinez, Ryan Burr

#17)
Dodgers Receive: Ian Krol

Braves Receive: Chris Hatcher, Joshua Sborz

#18)
Giants Receive: Anthony Swarzak, Melky Cabrera

White Sox Receive: Jordan Johnson, Austin Slater/Ryder Jones

#19)
Giants Receive: Glen Perkins

Twins Receive: Ray Black, Daniel Carbonell, Ronnie Jebavy

[Danpagnepapi]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

What kind of return could i get for JT Realmuto in my Marlins franchise? I just don't seem to cook up with him like i should for whatever reason. Currently hitting .227 2hr 12rbi through 23 games in 2019. 2018 he hit .244 13hr 63rbi in 144 games. He's 86 ovr with above average defense and pretty good contact stats for a catcher.

Anyone have any ideas on what i can get for him? I'm desperate to move him

[GamecocksLaw17]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Anyone have any ideas on what i can get for him? I'm desperate to move him

Similar to last year's Lucroy deal. Realmuto is a very valuable piece

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Operation Sports mobile app

[whbaseball51121]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

#11)
Phillies Receive: Wade Miley, Brad Brach

Orioles Receive: Drew Anderson, Jorge Flores, Cornelius Randolph

#12)
Phillies Receive: Ryan Schimpf, Alex Dickerson

Padres Receive: Nick Pivetta, Yacksel Rios, Jhailyn Ortiz

#13)
Cubs Receive: Tommy Milone, Hernan Perez

Brewers Receive: Duane Underwood, Jhondaniel Medina, Yasiel Balaguert

#14)
Pirates Receive: Mat Latos, Nori Aoki

Blue Jays Receive: Trevor Williams, Luis Escobar, Elvis Escobar

#15)
Cardinals Receive: Liam Hendricks, Santiago Casilla

Athletics Receive: Chris Ellis, Rowan Wick, Oscar Mercado

#16)
Diamondbacks Receive: Francisco Rodriguez

Tigers Receive: Jose Martinez, Ryan Burr

#17)
Dodgers Receive: Ian Krol

Braves Receive: Chris Hatcher, Joshua Sborz

#18)
Giants Receive: Anthony Swarzak, Melky Cabrera

White Sox Receive: Jordan Johnson, Austin Slater/Ryder Jones

#19)
Giants Receive: Glen Perkins

Twins Receive: Ray Black, Daniel Carbonell, Ronnie Jebavy

Phillies aren't trading Randolph for that. Pirates wouldn't do that, good as Kari's has been in game that's a marginal upgrade on Williams and Luis Escobar on top is too much. Estrada isn't netting Neidert either, he's a very good prospect. Don't really get Krol/Hatcher, they'd probably just do the Cingrani deal then.

And RE on Pederson to TOR for the guy who asked, why would LAD trade Pederson? He's cheap, talented and controllable. You'd have to deal Pillar+ or Stroman/Sanchez to motivate them to move him.

[Danpagnepapi]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Similar to last year's Lucroy deal. Realmuto is a very valuable piece

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Operation Sports mobile app

Hmm i figured that with his stats this year it'd look more like this year's Lucroy deal but word. Any idea how the prospects the Rangers gave up translate to grades in game?

[Remixxxxxxx]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Playing through year 1 of my Red Sox franchise and I'm looking to trade for some power at 1B and one person that intrigues me is Chris Davis - figure he can play 1B for the time being and slide into the DH role when Hanley is done.

My question is what would a fair package to acquire Davis?

[millertime98]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Playing through year 1 of my Red Sox franchise and I'm looking to trade for some power at 1B and one person that intrigues me is Chris Davis - figure he can play 1B for the time being and slide into the DH role when Hanley is done.

My question is what would a fair package to acquire Davis?

I always thought the Sox and Jays would be the ones to go after Votto. Seems a little unrealistic that Baltimore would deal him after signing him to that extension but hey, what do I know?!
I'd suggest a few young SP. I think the Orioles are pretty depleted in that area in the minors. Maybe two B's. Or a B SP and a B position prospect. IRL I think the Orioles are on the verge of a rebuild by trading Britton, Jones and maybe Machado before FA hits. Just my 2 cents.
Good luck

[UNDERTAKER1215]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Phillies aren't trading Randolph for that. Pirates wouldn't do that, good as Kari's has been in game that's a marginal upgrade on Williams and Luis Escobar on top is too much. Estrada isn't netting Neidert either, he's a very good prospect. Don't really get Krol/Hatcher, they'd probably just do the Cingrani deal then.

And RE on Pederson to TOR for the guy who asked, why would LAD trade Pederson? He's cheap, talented and controllable. You'd have to deal Pillar+ or Stroman/Sanchez to motivate them to move him.

I wasn't sure what to do for Philly as they're tied with the Giants and Cardinals for the Wild Card, but also trying to build a future contender, so I wasn't sure what a return would look like, and I also didn't realize Randolph was the 13th prospect for Philly as I haven't heard a ton about him. Baltimore also has Tillman who's also a FA after the season. I listed everyone that could be available, so if there's a better matchup, let me know. Would Shoemaker and Petit from the Angels be a better get for that package.

Not sure who Kari is, but Latos has been out of this world this season in-game, and Aoki is controllable for another three seasons and is hitting .292 in 339 AB. Would Brandon Waddell and Tyler Eppler be a better combo to Williams/Escobar? Still include Elvis Escobar?

OH DAMN! I definitely did not realize Neidert was the #2 prospect for Seattle. Last I saw of him (which was probably last year), he was a lower end prospect. Would someone like Chase De Jong or Rob Whalen be a good replacement.

I actually already did the Cingrani deal, but he has a 5.97 ERA in 31.2 IP, so I figured Krol would be a good target for LA, and Hatcher would be a throw in to fill the bullpen for the rest of the season, and Sborz would be a nice prospect get. What would you suggest for Krol? I could do Hatcher and an infielder like Arruebarrena, and maybe a throw in of Rhame (who was just the PTBNL for Granderson), or keep Sborz in the deal? Krol is controllable for another two seasons.

What about the other deals, any suggestions?

[kenp86]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

2018 off-season. 30 team control. Think its finally time for Miami to rebuild. Just dealt Stanton to Oakland for an A pot OF and an A pot INF who both are ready to play this year. Time to deal Ozuna, Yelich and Gordon. Have some ideas, thoughts?

OZUNA
1) Ozuna (28yo, 87/84, 28 HR, 116 RBI, .315 avg, 4.1to war) Washington for V.Robles

2) Ozuna to Toronto for either Guerrero Jr or Bichette

3.) Ozuna to Phillies for S.Sanchez (71/90, A) and 1B D.Anderson (42/91, A)

GORDON
1) Gordon (4HR, 53 RBI, 47 SB, .290 avg, 3.6 war) to ChW for SP, M.Hall (62/83, B.) and RP, C.Rosado (61/87, B )

2.) Gordon to Detroit for SP, S.Palacios (56/85, B ) and RP, J.Ye (66/86, B )

YELICH
1) Yelich (17 HR, 76 Rbi, 10 SB, .277 avg, 5.5 war) to Cubs for SP, B.Jones (75/84, B ), SP, A.Velazquez(56/91, A) and CF, A.Almora Jr (71/96, A)

2)Yelich to LaD for SP, W.Buehler (24/90, A), SP, Y.Alvarez (74/93,A) and CF, A.Verdugo (72/91, A)

3) Yelich to Yankees for SP, J.Sheffield (71/88, B ), SP, W.Quintero (63/93, A) and CF, C.Frazier(83/99, A)

Thoughts?

[sc050610]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Playing through year 1 of my Red Sox franchise and I'm looking to trade for some power at 1B and one person that intrigues me is Chris Davis - figure he can play 1B for the time being and slide into the DH role when Hanley is done.

My question is what would a fair package to acquire Davis?

The problem is his contract. And if he is playing anything like he is in real life than he no value just like Sandoval did for you guys. If he is playing up to at least his career averages then maybe and this is a big maybe because of being a division rival you could send a low B prospect at most. But realistically with taking on such a big contract and freeing a division rival up over 140 million dollars to play with you shouldn't have to part with much if you want to do the deal.

[GamecocksLaw17]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

2018 off-season. 30 team control. Think its finally time for Miami to rebuild. Just dealt Stanton to Oakland for an A pot OF and an A pot INF who both are ready to play this year. Time to deal Ozuna, Yelich and Gordon. Have some ideas, thoughts?

OZUNA
1) Ozuna (28yo, 87/84, 28 HR, 116 RBI, .315 avg, 4.1to war) Washington for V.Robles

2) Ozuna to Toronto for either Guerrero Jr or Bichette

3.) Ozuna to Phillies for S.Sanchez (71/90, A) and 1B D.Anderson (42/91, A)

GORDON
1) Gordon (4HR, 53 RBI, 47 SB, .290 avg, 3.6 war) to ChW for SP, M.Hall (62/83, B.) and RP, C.Rosado (61/87, B )

2.) Gordon to Detroit for SP, S.Palacios (56/85, B ) and RP, J.Ye (66/86, B )

YELICH
1) Yelich (17 HR, 76 Rbi, 10 SB, .277 avg, 5.5 war) to Cubs for SP, B.Jones (75/84, B ), SP, A.Velazquez(56/91, A) and CF, A.Almora Jr (71/96, A)

2)Yelich to LaD for SP, W.Buehler (24/90, A), SP, Y.Alvarez (74/93,A) and CF, A.Verdugo (72/91, A)

3) Yelich to Yankees for SP, J.Sheffield (71/88, B ), SP, W.Quintero (63/93, A) and CF, C.Frazier(83/99, A)

Thoughts?

How many years of control does Ozuna have? Because those proposals are asking for a whole lot and he would need a good deal of team control to get close to either package IMO

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Operation Sports mobile app

[kenp86]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

How many years of control does Ozuna have? Because those proposals are asking for a whole lot and he would need a good deal of team control to get close to either package IMO

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Operation Sports mobile app

Gordon has 1 year remaining after 2019
Yelich has 2 years after 2019
Ozuna is in final year

Thoughts?

[GamecocksLaw17]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Gordon has 1 year remaining after 2019
Yelich has 2 years after 2019
Ozuna is in final year

Thoughts?

Yeah why would a team give up Vlad Jr or Bichette or Robles for one season of Ozuna? I think you'll have a hard time getting any A prospect for one season of him.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Operation Sports mobile app