Is Comeback Logic Rearing Its Ugly Head Again???

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Padgoi
    Banned
    • Oct 2008
    • 1873

    #1

    Is Comeback Logic Rearing Its Ugly Head Again???

    Can this really still be happening? Someone please explain to me because I'm always listening and trying to be open minded, but here are some videos based on the Gamespot gameplay video released today and it's boggling my mind.

    Top of second, Ramone starts grooving pitches so some balls are put in play. Astros score 2 runs and take 2-0 lead. Very next half inning, with two outs, this happens:

    Didi Gregorious hits a home run to right on this pitch and swing. Please check out the PCI:



    So now it's 2-1. Very next batter, Greg Bird, fouls off a pitch he's RIGHT ON down the right field line. And then, one pitch later, this happens:



    He hits a home run to tie the game at 2 on a pitch in which the PCI ISN'T EVEN ON!!!!

    Can someone please defend this? Why is this happening again? How can you defend two home runs in which PCI isn't on either one to conveniently tie the game in the very next half inning?
  • KCowse
    Rookie
    • Jun 2017
    • 176

    #2
    Re: Is Comeback Logic Rearing Its Ugly Head Again???

    I think it has something to do with the new swing feedback that pops out. On the didi swing you can see that it hits off the end of the bat, but on the early side of good timing so he pulls it over there. Bird's PCI looked odd, but the new feedback showed him squaring it up pretty perfectly. It seems almost like instead of trying to explain PCI to death, they just created a new system. But I guess we'll learn more about that in a stream.

    Comment

    • Marino
      Moderator
      • Jan 2008
      • 18113

      #3
      Re: Is Comeback Logic Rearing Its Ugly Head Again???

      I'm closing this. We seem to have these numerous times. Its been confirmed for many years that there is no comeback code.

      Comment

      Working...