Can rosters make a difference?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • GoodyBucs
    Pro
    • May 2003
    • 689

    #1

    Can rosters make a difference?

    I will preface this by saying that I have been a baseball gamer all the way back to the Intellivison and I can still remember spending my paper route money to get the first Nintendo just for the original baseball game which was thankfully replaced by RBI and Baseball Stars.

    That said I have suffered through the years of out-of-the-box is what you got and you were darn happy to have it, to the no left-handed homer debacle of MVP years back. I mess with sliders and use rosters that are created right here by the dedicated members of OP. I have always wondered if differing rosters could even react differently and perform differently when integrated with the game. That question in my mind has be thoroughly put to test this evening...

    For the last month or so I have been playing a Cubs franchise using OSFM 1.5 roster and Armor's sliders, directional hitting and classic pitching. Up to patch 1.10 I was able to hit and score at a reasonable rate with the game having a good "feel." After 1.10 dropped I slowly saw a changes that included my hitters having very little pop and barely ever hitting a ball that even got to the warning track. The cpu hitters started to feel unchallenging to me and they had lost their pop as well. I started adding to the hitting sliders trying to regain that feel. By doing this I saw the cpu regain some of their prowess and I gladly felt challenged pitching again. Still my hitting was meak. During this time I went 1-10 which was believable in my eyes but I scored a paultry 22 runs over that span with one homer. One homer over 11 games in this day and age was tough to swallow.

    So feeling disgusted and tired of not hitting I decided to play a game using the 'live rosters' that had recently downloaded and used my normal sliders. What happened opened my eyes. In the first inning I laced the ball around the field scoring four times including a homer with Sano on a 1-2 count, pulling down with a contact swing! In the second inning I hit another homer this time with Kepler. With one out in the 3rd I hit another 1-2 pitch out of the park, this time with Dozier, again pulling down using a contact swing...

    I know the post will immediately be met with "small sample size" and "that's baseball" comments, but I sure know the difference I felt in that small sample. After I post this I'm going fire up the Cubs and see how it "feels."
    Baseball junky....
  • Caulfield
    Hall Of Fame
    • Apr 2011
    • 10986

    #2
    Re: Can rosters make a difference?

    Having played with many different historical rosters over the years I can verify they do yield varying results. not only that, different users using the same rosters and sliders will yield different results esp, if one user is playing above or below his skill difficulty.
    And not only that, you can get different results with the same rosters sliders and user,
    Couple or 3 years ago, I played a season with the Pirates starting around September of that year and I fell just shy of 70 wins. Fast forward to the following February, I replayed the season and won the NL Central.
    OSFM23 - Building Better Baseball - OSFM23

    A Work in Progress

    Comment

    • KBLover
      Hall Of Fame
      • Aug 2009
      • 12172

      #3
      Re: Can rosters make a difference?

      Originally posted by GoodyBucs
      I know the post will immediately be met with "small sample size" and "that's baseball" comments
      Those comments would not be wrong.

      While roster = ratings and ratings, of course, make a difference, sample size and the variance of baseball is a thing.

      You can load the same roster or different rosters for one game or 10 games each and still get very varied results.

      Over the longer term, though, yes, the ratings differences will generally change the "feel" and outcomes of how games play out.
      Last edited by KBLover; 06-18-2018, 03:44 AM.
      "Some people call it butterflies, but to him, it probably feels like pterodactyls in his stomach." --Plesac in MLB18

      Comment

      • Detroit Tigers
        MVP
        • Mar 2018
        • 1376

        #4
        Can rosters make a difference?

        I’m not 100% convinced they make a huge impact. Last year or maybe the year before everyone in my lineup with over 300 at-bats hit within 20 points of each other.

        Power numbers surely matter - you won’t hit 40 homers with a guy with 25 power - but just about anyone in the lineup can hit .220 or .320 depending on .... whatever this game’s actually doing under the hood.

        Not saying whether this is good or bad. I enjoy playing it, so, whatever.
        Just one man’s opinion.
        I don’t actually care about any of this.

        Comment

        Working...