MLB challenge system BROKE

[nflguzzler]

can anyone explain to me how they say the game is best sim mlb ever. Why some of that is true there are parts that are not and need to be fixed.

First off All we ever see for challenge plays are at 1b WHy??? that's not true in real life. Why is it hard to get 2nd,3rd or home to be challenged.

Then I have played games where I am out at 1st im called safe, watch replay and CPU never challenge.
Then I get a lead off double, the call me out i watch replay and i cant challenge. They need to make a tab that after you hit start it should say challenge like 2k did back in the day and let you pick what you are challenging. Its so unfair for cpu and users to be screwed.

Yet MLB is worried about adding legends and we cant fix a challenge logic only at 1b. its a joke.

[Caulfield]

Re: MLB challenge system BROKE

literally a hundred other things need touched up first, though I dont think anyone will disagree the Show's challenge system is lacking, to put it mildly. thankfully replay in MLB is still in its infancy and you can go whole games without seeing a replay challenge

[Detroit Tigers]

Re: MLB challenge system BROKE

Honestly I turn umpire close plays off anyway. They don’t add anything to the experience, in this game or in real life.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Caulfield]

Re: MLB challenge system BROKE

Honestly I turn umpire close plays off anyway. They don’t add anything to the experience, in this game or in real life.



Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

if anger/emotion/passion can be counted, thats the most I'd say replay brings to the table FBOW

[countryboy]

Re: MLB challenge system BROKE

It's not hard its time consuming.

It would be a major undertaking at this point for them to add challenges to all the bases, which is why it hasn't been done. It would basically take up all their resources from a gameplay standpoint to add those into the game.

That is why there is the option to turn off umpire close plays, so that calls are correct 100% of the time.

[Jeffrey Smith]

MLB challenge system BROKE

I all honesty I think the challenge system is broke IRL as well. Seems like all sports still get the wrong call sometimes even with replay.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports