No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

[MetsFan16]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

Bummer for the roster community and Y2Y franchise players

I haven't dipped my toe in Y2Y because I always saw the glitches when transferring and missing out of new player scans/models

I've always been a yearly release day buyer and while I understand the benefit for a lot of people, it won't affect my decision to buy.

I do wish the Stadium creator was able to be transferred, we lose some greats ones each year in the vault and it'd be nice to have mine in year after year.

With all of this said, this is the reason I stopped playing MLBTS until release day because I know any progress I make in RTTS/Franchise will be for nothing when I restart on '23. Looking forward to getting fresh eyes on the game with this break

[Wbcfan]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

Hard pass for me again. Bought every MLB the Show from 2007-2020 and havent bought one since. Sticking with 20 again as I have for the previous two years. Y2Y saves being taken has ruined any chance of me ever buying a new game. Too much work on rosters to lose everything.

[Karle]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

In regard to Y2Y saves and the disappearing face scan, this should not be an issue with historic rosters as all the faces in historic rosters are created. The archive for MLB 20 has lots of such rosters.

In modern rosters which include face scans, I understand that when a Y2Y save is used some or all of the face scans disappear from the players when the roster is carried over to the next year. I would guess this is due to how the data is structured. The face scans are likely stored in a separate folder in the program apart from the roster file. The roster file knows to grab the faces from this folder. When the roster file is transfered to the next edition of the game the face scan folder is not transfered with it. Rather, the roster looks for the face scan in the face scan folder of the next year's files. If there is no face scan in that folder corresponding to a particular player then you get the lost face scan effect.

This is only my best guess as to what is going on with the faces.

Sent from my CLT-L29 using Operation Sports mobile app

[ninertravel]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

In regard to Y2Y saves and the disappearing face scan, this should not be an issue with historic rosters as all the faces in historic rosters are created. The archive for MLB 20 has lots of such rosters.

In modern rosters which include face scans, I understand that when a Y2Y save is used some or all of the face scans disappear from the players when the roster is carried over to the next year. I would guess this is due to how the data is structured. The face scans are likely stored in a separate folder in the program apart from the roster file. The roster file knows to grab the faces from this folder. When the roster file is transfered to the next edition of the game the face scan folder is not transfered with it. Rather, the roster looks for the face scan in the face scan folder of the next year's files. If there is no face scan in that folder corresponding to a particular player then you get the lost face scan effect.

This is only my best guess as to what is going on with the faces.

Sent from my CLT-L29 using Operation Sports mobile app

It is all to do with player ID

Tatis for example has a ID that is linked to the face ID (he is hidden now on mlb 22 because they removed him if you have the latest roster) but he is still there unless a roster editor was created we have no way to bring in a player and link the ID with the correct face ID

what used to happened with Y2Y savse was if Derek Jeter for example came into mlb 15 the game would go 'face ID don't exist with this player ID' and they were turn generic random name and face. keep the career stats and equipment and audio (if it is in the new game of the show)

that is the biggest pain in the utter *** is that now when a player like lets say Michael Conforto who will be missing this year comes along the starting outfielder for giants. we can't just simply export him from a older roster in 22 keep his career stats and fix his face up.

now like the issue with Cano last year we got to sit around for 3 months waiting for a roster update that has him in it with his career stats and audio.

it is either that or create a ROOKIE conforto with no career stats and no card and the game thinks he is a rookie then even if you have his service time edited to 20 years. the game still will have him going for rookie of the year and the commentators carrying on about his first career hit or homer etc

yeah I know I go on about this a lot someone will say but this is now 3 years dealing with this crap. and the Cano example last year was an annoying joke. it actually raised the question if the roster guys were gonna wait around or just go with it. they made the right choice just to create a rookie Cano

[Madden08PCgmr]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

Soul crushing.

Bargain bin for me, because I doubt I can skip playing with this Mariners team.

[ShowTyme15]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

It is all to do with player ID

Tatis for example has a ID that is linked to the face ID (he is hidden now on mlb 22 because they removed him if you have the latest roster) but he is still there unless a roster editor was created we have no way to bring in a player and link the ID with the correct face ID

what used to happened with Y2Y savse was if Derek Jeter for example came into mlb 15 the game would go 'face ID don't exist with this player ID' and they were turn generic random name and face. keep the career stats and equipment and audio (if it is in the new game of the show)

that is the biggest pain in the utter *** is that now when a player like lets say Michael Conforto who will be missing this year comes along the starting outfielder for giants. we can't just simply export him from a older roster in 22 keep his career stats and fix his face up.

now like the issue with Cano last year we got to sit around for 3 months waiting for a roster update that has him in it with his career stats and audio.

it is either that or create a ROOKIE conforto with no career stats and no card and the game thinks he is a rookie then even if you have his service time edited to 20 years. the game still will have him going for rookie of the year and the commentators carrying on about his first career hit or homer etc

yeah I know I go on about this a lot someone will say but this is now 3 years dealing with this crap. and the Cano example last year was an annoying joke. it actually raised the question if the roster guys were gonna wait around or just go with it. they made the right choice just to create a rookie Cano

Going to have to wait and see how this plays out when 23 drops. But, them removing him doesn't bode well for him being in 23 out of the box. Would have to wait almost a month to see him in a roster update. Guess it is wait and see.

[ninertravel]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

Going to have to wait and see how this plays out when 23 drops. But, them removing him doesn't bode well for him being in 23 out of the box. Would have to wait almost a month to see him in a roster update. Guess it is wait and see.

Tatis Jr as well. the fact that he was removed last year tells me they won't have him in the game till at least may or June.

going by current history they like to remove suspended players. I think the real reason is that there are no fake players anymore so they want to create roster room and rather make suspended players be removed as punishment for them

that could be 2 big name starters that won't be in the game day 1 and Tatis will be a even longer wait (a guy that used to be on the cover that they removed from the game )

[ShowTyme15]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

Tatis Jr as well. the fact that he was removed last year tells me they won't have him in the game till at least may or June.

going by current history they like to remove suspended players. I think the real reason is that there are no fake players anymore so they want to create roster room and rather make suspended players be removed as punishment for them

that could be 2 big name starters that won't be in the game day 1 and Tatis will be a even longer wait (a guy that used to be on the cover that they removed from the game )

Tatis Jr. is who I was referring to. Sorry man I should have been more specific on that.

[The Kid 24]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

*** **** thats gonna suck having to wait for Tatis… So stupid they remove suspended guys, but believe they’ve done that in previous years.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[ShowTyme15]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

*** **** thats gonna suck having to wait for Tatis… So stupid they remove suspended guys, but believe they’ve done that in previous years.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Could be reality of the situation unfortunately. As of now he's a 50/50 guy.

[ninertravel]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

mind you if Y2Y saves were still a thing it would still be a problem getting Tatis in the game as you can't export face scan players. Conforto however would turn into a generic player. but also you could roll over this card stats audio equipment etc. so that be easy fix and what was so good about Y2Y saves.

I wish they would allow us to export ANY player and import into ANY roster they don't want allow it for franchise I give up on that happened but at least give us the option to do it for rosters first so we can actually create perfect rosters and not have to play games of who was removed or who was added so which roster should be the base one to use. imagine if we could all stay on the same page and just do what we want on the same base roster and not having to worry.

[ShowTyme15]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

mind you if Y2Y saves were still a thing it would still be a problem getting Tatis in the game as you can't export face scan players. Conforto however would turn into a generic player. but also you could roll over this card stats audio equipment etc. so that be easy fix and what was so good about Y2Y saves.

I wish they would allow us to export ANY player and import into ANY roster they don't want allow it for franchise I give up on that happened but at least give us the option to do it for rosters first so we can actually create perfect rosters and not have to play games of who was removed or who was added so which roster should be the base one to use. imagine if we could all stay on the same page and just do what we want on the same base roster and not having to worry.

A player DNA feature is something this game desperately needs or the roster transfer like we had from 19-20. This could/would eliminate quite a few issues.

[tessl]

Re: Cross-Platform, Cross Saves, Cross Progression in for MLB The Show 23

Not sure if it warrants a thread or if added to this discussion, but Y2Y saves will not be in 2023.

Is that official or speculation?

[countryboy]

Re: Cross-Platform, Cross Saves, Cross Progression in for MLB The Show 23

Is that official or speculation?

Official


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[blackhawksfan4ever19]

Re: No Year to Year Saves, Stadiums Will Not Transfer in MLB The Show 23

As to the first and last name sound files, the current number with MLB 22 is 1285 first names and 1552 last names. /URL]

I'M interested in HOW you know how many first and last names there are?!!

PLEASE don't tell me you COUNTED them one by one .

If so, I thought I was crazy 🤣 J/K