Ranking MLB The Show
Collapse
Recommended Videos
Collapse
X
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
Sent from my SM-A146U using Operation Sports mobile appComment
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
Funkycorm
Currently Playing:
MLB The Show 25 (PS5)
Red Dead Redemption 2 (PS4)
Pokemon Violet (Switch)
Twitch:
Twitch
Dynasties:
None at the momentComment
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
MLB '23 is the best all around game, ever! And the the best playing on the field…
the presentation and every other aspect of the broadcast style looks awesome, commentary is fairly new but is good. As a Franchise Player only for 10 some years it gets the somewhat “boring” sometimes because of how much you can do and how many difficulties you encounter during a season, but other than that its the best mode in the series by far… so ‘23 is the best game, ever! Period.
I will probably skip every game forward until something really important is added or change in franchise or in real life MLB.Comment
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
A couple reasons
1) it was used by a small portion of the user base (OS is almost a niche market compared to overall user base)
2) it’s extremely difficult to maintain and make work with the newest edition of the game. Due to the maintenance difficulties, it’s extremely difficult to make major changes (see draft/scouting this year) to franchise mode.
Imagine if Madden had something similar, at any point. Then imagine the outrage of that fanbase if that option was just wantonly thrown overboard.
Thankfully 20 is still a viable version that has sustainability. Hopefully it will be modable at some point. But still, just so unfortunate, beacuse gameplay does improve incrementally with this series.You want free speech?
Let's see you acknowledge a man whose words make your blood boil, advocating at the top of his lungs that which you would spend a lifetime opposing at the top of yours.Comment
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkComment
-
Ranking MLB The Show
My ranking is 20, 23, 22, 18/19 tied (not ranking 21 I agree with most on OS worst irritation of The Show)
Im torn tho! So torn! I can’t get into either my 23 chise or my 20 chise because every time I play one I think about the other awh man! Such a bad spot to be in. I love the fact I know I can plug and play w/ A&S sliders on 20 forget about it and just play and I know I won’t have wonky things happen. But I think about 23 new schedules new scouting the google stat cast and the biggest thing to me is I hate how the contract system is in 20 but my God the gameplay! Any help I respect a lot of people’s opinions in this thread! Thanks
Sent from my iPhone using Operation SportsComment
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
My ranking is 20, 23, 22, 18/19 tied (not ranking 21 I agree with most on OS worst irritation of The Show)
Im torn tho! So torn! I can’t get into either my 23 chise or my 20 chise because every time I play one I think about the other awh man! Such a bad spot to be in. I love the fact I know I can plug and play w/ A&S sliders on 20 forget about it and just play and I know I won’t have wonky things happen. But I think about 23 new schedules new scouting the google stat cast and the biggest thing to me is I hate how the contract system is in 20 but my God the gameplay! Any help I respect a lot of people’s opinions in this thread! Thanks
Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
Even when I played 21, 22, and 23, I was always playing my RTTS on 20. Now I am just back to 20 but there is no harm in playing 2 games you enjoy in a series.Last edited by Funkycorm; 06-17-2023, 03:14 PM.Funkycorm
Currently Playing:
MLB The Show 25 (PS5)
Red Dead Redemption 2 (PS4)
Pokemon Violet (Switch)
Twitch:
Twitch
Dynasties:
None at the momentComment
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
I'm exclusively franchise - manage full game.
They tend to fix one or two things and break other things. Kind of hard to say which is better. Rebranding and building a stadium are fantastic. Lack of year to year saves is the reverse.≡Comment
-
Comment
-
Re: Ranking MLB The Show
I'd go 23,20,22,21
This year's game is giving me no issues to dwell on.I like the new scheduling and decent enough hit variety.
20 and 22 are close and I'd be able to play either instead without feeling like I'm missing much.
21 isn't that bad to me but clearly the lesser of the bunch.Comment
Comment