The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • thescoop
    MVP
    • Jan 2006
    • 1288

    #1

    The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

    Stadium creator was revolutionary when it first debuted in MLB The Show 21. It was limited that first year to day games and other items but we excused it due to it being the first year.
    Year Two gave us night games and a few other improvements. However, Year Three the mode felt untouched. When the biggest new feature is more dino props added after a patch, you know it is time to revisit the items that still have not been added in.

    1. Year to year transfers of stadiums. Stadiums take a while to build. With the vaults, we really should be able to transfer our work from this year to next year. It would save us some time and we could edit them with any of the requested improvements below if needed.

    2. Domes and retractable roofs. No excuses for them not getting these in the creator at this point. This needs to be figured out for next year. It is past due.

    3. Astroturf and artificial turf options. We need these two options to go along with the Domes.

    4. Team branding on the field and in the stadium. If I want the team’s logo on the field, on the scoreboard, give me those options. I want to see the home team’s logo on the batter’s circle. Little things. You can tie this to whomever the home team is or whomever I assign the stadium. However, team branding is something that should be included.

    5. Ad placements on walls and other spots. The fact we cannot put ads on the walls without creative fixes is sad. We have been asking for since day one this feature. It is one that needs to be figured out. I had much rather have this be allowed than more Dino Island props.

    6. More wall props. Ivy on the walls, club type seating behind the walls, etc. Give us more we can place on the walls. I will get to more at number 10 on this list but they could easily be added to this spot here.

    7. Ability to move the bullpens. Again, year one I get why the bullpens were locked. Year two, I understood but was not happy. However, in year three this needs to be figured out and addressed. Very few teams still have bullpens on the field. We need to be allowed where to place our bullpens to truly build stadiums we want to build.

    8. More flags/every state flag – Again, they can give us more Dino Island props that no one is really asking for but we only get two flags to use? They have more flags than this in the game but we are only granted the US flag and Pride flag? We need all the flags they already have plus flags for all 50 states. Give us some international flags. We should not be limited to just two. This one should be easy.

    9. Current Stadium as base models/edit feature. MLB might be tying their hands on this one but love it if we could edit current stadium or at least get them as a base. This would allow an easier time creating a classic Wrigley or Fenway. Could also allow us to make expansions/renovations to existing parks. Again, MLB might be the reason this does not exist and is why I have it ranked further down my list.

    10. House rules/homerun lines. Some stadiums have high walls but feature yellow lines that are the actual home run line. We cannot do this in our created stadiums. This one might be harder ask but I would love to see stadium house rules of some kind, even if it is just a home run line of sorts, be added into the game. Because I view this as a hard ask, I have it lower on the list.

    11. Wall distances/lines at time of wall. This one ties into the one above it but is easier. But we need at the very least we should be able to have the wall distance numbers and lines at the top of the walls added. These are not hard asks to at least include this. Would be higher if I had not wanted to mention house rules first.

    12. Fans seating on grass areas and other parts. As it is today, we have to put stands and put several in the ground to give the appearance of fans sitting in the grass or in other areas. We should have some standing fans, fans in pools, fans sitting in grass, etc. type of options. The workarounds do work, but this would make it look more real when closing in on them.

    13. Ad creator. I would love to be able to create my own ads to place on outfield walls. We already have a logo creator. Should not be hard to add.

    14. Fan section assignment – I would love to create a themed fan section of some type. Like fans who show up dressed in certain ways, family section where I see more kids.

    15. Custom foul poles. I’d like to be able to create some cool or unique looking foul poles. I’d love it if we could do some fun things to make our stadiums feel more unique.

    Thoughts? Anything I left out you'd like to see added? Remember, this is for fun so request even if you don't think it is possible.
    Last edited by thescoop; 08-25-2023, 11:42 AM.
    Check out my updated 2017 blog on building a high school football video game:
    http://forums.operationsports.com/th...ame-revisited/
  • JoeRodgers1175
    Rookie
    • Jan 2020
    • 268

    #2
    Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

    Yes to all of this. Add things such as exits in the seating bowls, more horizontal ads, realistic-size dugouts and stadium facades. Also throw in an undo button or something. Center field backdrops shouldn’t be mandatory, and there should be a way to cover seats with a tarp or mark them as vacant.

    It’s unfortunate how stagnant the mode has gotten. It’s just not keeping up with the creativity of users, myself included.

    Honestly, I’d love to see the mode jailbroken. Wanna put a bench in center field? Go nuts. That’d allow overhangs and jury boxes and other features.

    Comment

    • thescoop
      MVP
      • Jan 2006
      • 1288

      #3
      Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

      Originally posted by JoeRodgers1175
      Yes to all of this. Add things such as exits in the seating bowls, more horizontal ads, realistic-size dugouts and stadium facades. Also throw in an undo button or something. Center field backdrops shouldn’t be mandatory, and there should be a way to cover seats with a tarp or mark them as vacant.

      It’s unfortunate how stagnant the mode has gotten. It’s just not keeping up with the creativity of users, myself included.

      Honestly, I’d love to see the mode jailbroken. Wanna put a bench in center field? Go nuts. That’d allow overhangs and jury boxes and other features.
      Love the way you're thinking. I knew I was forgetting some items. Tarp seating and custom dugouts are needed for sure. I'd also like a folding chair section like in some college and minor league stadium. Fan props (meaning types of fans to place in non-stadium seating sections) would be huge as well.
      Check out my updated 2017 blog on building a high school football video game:
      http://forums.operationsports.com/th...ame-revisited/

      Comment

      • blashinsky
        Rookie
        • Sep 2022
        • 35

        #4
        Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

        This is why I didn't buy 23. I could just live with ads on the fences, behind home plate and colored seats in the outfield and I'd be happy.

        Sent from my SM-A326U using Tapatalk

        Comment

        • thescoop
          MVP
          • Jan 2006
          • 1288

          #5
          Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

          Originally posted by blashinsky
          This is why I didn't buy 23. I could just live with ads on the fences, behind home plate and colored seats in the outfield and I'd be happy.

          Sent from my SM-A326U using Tapatalk
          That would be great for sure. But we need to have more than two flag options and moving and custom bullpens. I do love how creative some of the better builders are at some of this. But there is no excuse to not give us all the state flags or at least all the flags the game already us is using.
          Check out my updated 2017 blog on building a high school football video game:
          http://forums.operationsports.com/th...ame-revisited/

          Comment

          • TripleCrown
            MVP
            • Jan 2013
            • 1240

            #6
            Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24



            Have look at what talented creators can do with actual version of Stadium Creator. Imagine what they achieve with just half of the legit features you listed.

            Comment

            • thescoop
              MVP
              • Jan 2006
              • 1288

              #7
              Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

              Originally posted by TripleCrown
              https://forums.operationsports.com/f...s-project.html

              Have look at what talented creators can do with actual version of Stadium Creator. Imagine what they achieve with just half of the legit features you listed.
              The creators are amazing in this game. I would love to see what they do if some of the handcuffs are taken off. They already do an amazing job as it is. I download a ton of Minor League stadiums every year and these are by far the best.
              Check out my updated 2017 blog on building a high school football video game:
              http://forums.operationsports.com/th...ame-revisited/

              Comment

              • 2ndBase
                Rookie
                • Dec 2002
                • 450

                #8
                Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

                Originally posted by thescoop
                Stadium creator was revolutionary when it first debuted in MLB The Show 21. It was limited that first year to day games and other items but we excused it due to it being the first year.
                Year Two gave us night games and a few other improvements. However, Year Three the mode felt untouched. When the biggest new feature is more dino props added after a patch, you know it is time to revisit the items that still have not been added in.

                1.Year to year transfers of stadiums. Stadiums take a while to build. With the vaults, we really should be able to transfer our work from this year to next year. It would save us some time and we could edit them with any of the requested improvements below if needed.

                2.Domes and retractable roofs. No excuses for them not getting these in the creator at this point. This needs to be figured out for next year. It is past due.

                3.Astroturf and artificial turf options. We need these two options to go along with the Domes.

                4.Team branding on the field and in the stadium. If I want the team’s logo on the field, on the scoreboard, give me those options. I want to see the home team’s logo on the batter’s circle. Little things. You can tie this to whomever the home team is or whomever I assign the stadium. However, team branding is something that should be included.

                5.Ad placements on walls and other spots. The fact we cannot put ads on the walls without creative fixes is sad. We have been asking for since day one this feature. It is one that needs to be figured out. I had much rather have this be allowed than more Dino Island props.

                6.More wall props. Ivy on the walls, club type seating behind the walls, etc. Give us more we can place on the walls. I will get to more at number 10 on this list but they could easily be added to this spot here.

                7.Ability to move the bullpens. Again, year one I get why the bullpens were locked. Year two, I understood but was not happy. However, in year three this needs to be figured out and addressed. Very few teams still have bullpens on the field. We need to be allowed where to place our bullpens to truly build stadiums we want to build.

                8.More flags/every state flag – Again, they can give us more Dino Island props that no one is really asking for but we only get two flags to use? They have more flags than this in the game but we are only granted the US flag and Pride flag? We need all the flags they already have plus flags for all 50 states. Give us some international flags. We should not be limited to just two. This one should be easy.

                9.Current Stadium as base models/edit feature. MLB might be tying their hands on this one but love it if we could edit current stadium or at least get them as a base. This would allow an easier time creating a classic Wrigley or Fenway. Could also allow us to make expansions/renovations to existing parks. Again, MLB might be the reason this does not exist and is why I have it ranked further down my list.

                10.House rules/homerun lines. Some stadiums have high walls but feature yellow lines that are the actual home run line. We cannot do this in our created stadiums. This one might be harder ask but I would love to see stadium house rules of some kind, even if it is just a home run line of sorts, be added into the game. Because I view this as a hard ask, I have it lower on the list.

                11.Wall distances/lines at time of wall. This one ties into the one above it but is easier. But we need at the very least we should be able to have the wall distance numbers and lines at the top of the walls added. These are not hard asks to at least include this. Would be higher if I had not wanted to mention house rules first.

                12.Fans seating on grass areas and other parts. As it is today, we have to put stands and put several in the ground to give the appearance of fans sitting in the grass or in other areas. We should have some standing fans, fans in pools, fans sitting in grass, etc. type of options. The workarounds do work, but this would make it look more real when closing in on them.

                13.Ad creator. I would love to be able to create my own ads to place on outfield walls. We already have a logo creator. Should not be hard to add.

                14.Fan section assignment – I would love to create a themed fan section of some type. Like fans who show up dressed in certain ways, family section where I see more kids.

                15.Custom foul poles. I’d like to be able to create some cool or unique looking foul poles. I’d love it if we could do some fun things to make our stadiums feel more unique.

                Thoughts? Anything I left out you'd like to see added? Remember, this is for fun so request even if you don't think it is possible.


                Agreed would also like a no batters eye option to make stadium recreations more feasible.

                Comment

                • thescoop
                  MVP
                  • Jan 2006
                  • 1288

                  #9
                  Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

                  Originally posted by 2ndBase
                  Agreed would also like a no batters eye option to make stadium recreations more feasible.
                  Definitely want to see that. It opens up being able to create true classic stadiums.
                  Check out my updated 2017 blog on building a high school football video game:
                  http://forums.operationsports.com/th...ame-revisited/

                  Comment

                  • majere_74
                    Rookie
                    • Mar 2020
                    • 34

                    #10
                    Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

                    You nailed everything I want added there is a few more things also that really bug me is I want to be able to edit the foul sidelines and move them like I can’t the outfield fences. The batters eye should be optional for sure, especially when I am creating old ball parks that never had them. And they need more bleacher sets that are a little smaller and have different angles to them. They need to allow us to be able to place the lights wherever we want. I don’t know why this year we are not able to compared to the year before. What I would really like, is for them to come out with classic items like old-school retro items that look more like a Ebbetsfield and Shibe Park props, and then your modern set which would include dome pieces, and standing area Concours pieces that are now in modern stadiums that include people standing in them. I think all of us can go on and on about what we want. Question is will they do it?

                    Comment

                    • Orioles1019
                      Rookie
                      • Jan 2024
                      • 5

                      #11
                      Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

                      I've only messed with the stadium creator for maybe an hour total since it got introduced, is there still an issue where a prop can get stuck underground and impossible to save the stadium/delete the prop? I had that issue a while back and remember others complaining of it at the time.

                      Comment

                      • mbberry
                        Rookie
                        • Aug 2009
                        • 111

                        #12
                        Re: The Must Have Overdue Improvements for Stadium Creator in MLB The Show 24

                        If we could just get realistic dugouts and a rolled up tarp I could honestly overlook just about everything else. Yellow home run line on the wall and wall ads would be great also. Not really interested in dinosaurs and space ships. We need elements that add realism.
                        Last edited by mbberry; 03-05-2024, 02:42 AM. Reason: Forgot about the tarp

                        Comment

                        Working...